TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Unfortunately for the Star, that person was their fashion editor

114 点作者 jjar超过 2 年前

13 条评论

motohagiography超过 2 年前
It&#x27;s quite an artifact of its time. Someone appears to be making a play for her magazine editor role and this is basically oppo-research on behalf of whomever they want in place. This kind of scandal playing is sort of how the media game is played, where these were society plum jobs, and journalism in Canada has been a traditional stepping stone to parliament.<p>I was distantly acquainted with some of that crowd, and there was an incentive from editors at the time to be provocatively glib because the conflict and outrage sold papers, when those were still a thing. Some people were just naturally (or dubiously) gifted at making a spectacle of themselves, and the papers hired them (us?) to write. Internationally, Toronto was a relative backwater full of people who had come from other relative backwaters to reinvent themselves in the reflected images of magazine covers. The article in question was written by someone trying to become the reflection they saw. This was in a time when Sex in the City represented feminine success, and many women I knew would follow magazine and newspaper columnists as a kind of rage-read, and I think they related to those figures in fairly complex ways. Vogue at the time functioned as a kind of ministry of desire that told women what they wanted. However, that no one seems to have written critically about this doesn&#x27;t so much ignore a decade when womens&#x27; media dominated the culture, as it mercifully overlooks its excesses. Having known several fashion editors and writers, their craft is a narrative of cohering symbols of power and desire, and the art is walking a tightrope above a pit of firey cringe. This article was definitely one of those cringe-hell fails that wise old-timers use to scare interns over drinks.<p>If you took the series Mad Men from the 1960s era, transplanted it to the late 90&#x27;s and made it about women working at fashion magazines and relegated to the style sections of newspapers, you would get a fairly nuanced view of how, like we take for granted the influence of advertisers on our thinking, we might also understand what the women shaping narratives of desire in the 90s did. Terrible article, but maybe enough time has passed to look at what all that really was.
评论 #32824768 未加载
评论 #32826137 未加载
bombcar超过 2 年前
I actually kind of like this; she&#x27;s honest about what she experienced and she recognizes that fashion will take a back-burner for awhile.<p>People experience shock in various ways and not everyone tries to make everything directly about whatever is happening; most of America at least pretended to plug away at their jobs that day.
评论 #32824902 未加载
something2超过 2 年前
I actually think it&#x27;s unfortunate that she didn&#x27;t focus <i>more</i> on fashion.<p>There are so, so many accounts of 9&#x2F;11 that focus on the facts and the immediate tragedy. But I&#x27;m willing to bet that 9&#x2F;11 impacted industries and people significantly even if they weren&#x27;t directly involved.<p>I have little to no interest in fashion, but I&#x27;d find an article on the impact of 9&#x2F;11 on the fashion capital of North America a much more interesting read than another collection of facts.
评论 #32824571 未加载
评论 #32825286 未加载
JasonFruit超过 2 年前
I suppose you can&#x27;t really fault a person whose professional life requires her to view every event with the question, &quot;How does this affect the fashion industry?&quot; for viewing the attack on the twin towers in exactly that way — especially in this article, which was published as the &quot;Fashion Notebook&quot; column. The tweetstorm blames her for not relating what was told her by survivors and first responders, but those stories were probably passed on to her editors and used in other articles. This article is, obviously, shallow, which is not a fault: fashion is literally not even skin deep.
评论 #32824530 未加载
评论 #32824145 未加载
tinalumfoil超过 2 年前
A lot of journalists covered 9&#x2F;11, so I&#x27;m not sure that this particular fashion reporter didn&#x27;t seem to care is all that interesting.<p>I do think it&#x27;s an interesting case in the level of acceptability in the actions and admissions of semi-public figures like journalists. Today there&#x27;s lots of commotion about people posting their hot takes on the Queen&#x27;s death, a lot of which obviously regrettable. There&#x27;s lots of events over the last few years point to a high level of self and contextual awareness being necessary to keep your job in semi-public roles.<p>Yet, in 2001, days after September 11, you have a journalist that published, after I presume being edited and approved by multiple other people at the paper, about celebrating with Apple Martinis in a $2,000 limo ride <i>driving away from the terrorist event</i> (I&#x27;m I reading that right?). And nobody during the editing process thought, hey, this is a pretty inappropriate thing to publish?<p>Such a completely different world.
评论 #32825168 未加载
评论 #32825399 未加载
评论 #32824681 未加载
theprincess超过 2 年前
I honestly admire the fashion editor. Her life is laser focused on looking great and tracking the developments of high fashion. Events that shake the hoi polloi to their core barely even register to her. A queen.
评论 #32824232 未加载
评论 #32827695 未加载
troelsSteegin超过 2 年前
The suggestion is that in the face of something overwhelmingly weird, you cling to whatever structure you&#x27;ve got.
评论 #32824680 未加载
nathanvanfleet超过 2 年前
I read a bit of it and just thought &quot;okay I guess she wasn&#x27;t prepared for 9&#x2F;11, just like everyone else.&quot; Is it supposed to be funny that this single person who didn&#x27;t work in that kind of journalism was somehow not ready to walk to ground zero?
1123581321超过 2 年前
I like her piece much more than the commentary from that twitter account. I’m not sure they understand what it was like that day. Most of us were helpless, regardless of proximity, and just got on with our pre-siting assignment if we weren’t able to or allowed to fixate on the TV or hold a vigil yet. It happens that she was able to document her helplessness—so what?
epc超过 2 年前
Honestly, kind of enjoyed that. So many stories of that day have been left out of the historical record because they don’t fit the narrative of heroic deeds in the face of terror (writing only from an NYC perspective).
danrl超过 2 年前
She is focused on a level I envy. Just our interests differ. Won’t judge that.
kstenerud超过 2 年前
I don&#x27;t know what sickens me more: That someone is digging up a 20 year old article to throw tomatoes at some poor woman, or that this is front page on HN...
nineplay超过 2 年前
I hate to make everything gendered but I have to wonder if a sports reporter who wrote about the impact of 9&#x2F;11 on the baseball and football seasons would have received the same level of derision. This twitter thread boils down to &quot;person who doesn&#x27;t care about &lt;subject&gt; derides article written about &lt;subject&gt;&quot;. Why has this taken up so much of his headspace?