TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Ask HN: Please review my startup, skipscotch.com, our solution to online reviews

5 点作者 jhdavids8超过 13 年前
Landing page: http://skipscotch.com Live demo: http://skipscotch.com/home/underdev<p>Feel free to play around with the demo, although I can't promise speed will be great. The site can be largely experienced w/o a user account, although feel free to create a temp account if you like (fake email or not). I'll delete any accounts/reviews/etc created and hide the URL again after everyone's had adequate time to play around with the site.<p>Some background info: For the past 4 months, I've been developing SkipScotch, a starting point to increase credibility of online reviews. It's not the ultimate solution, but I'm thinking the structure is in place to get started down the right path. Some highlights:<p>- Reviews are given based on service experienced, and ratings are calculated per service offered. Currently, we are planning on the basic average of reviews to calculate ratings, but we have a more accurate weighted average designed that we'd love to implement (we'd need a decent amount of reviews for the weighted average to matter). Read about the weighted average at http://blog.skipscotch.com/2011/11/only-way-to-do-reviews-right-way-is-to.html (it's mentioned towards the end of the post)<p>- Reviews can be up-voted/down-voted by users. Points awarded for reviews contribute to a reviewer's 'wisdom' score<p>- Scoring reviews/reviewers based on quality should increase credibility of reviews in SkipScotch. We have plenty of future goals with these credibility scores, like utilizing them in a weighted average, review filter, reviewer ranks, and rewards for respected reviewers.<p>- Individual reviewers can be 'trusted', which provides a new trusted rating along with the public rating<p>- Events can exist per service and are searchable through the basic search. Examples currently implemented are trivia and karaoke nights<p>Reviews and ratings are randomly generated for demo purposes. Businesses and events are real and accurate. Reviews show up in each service's show page, simply so they can be experienced regardless of service visited. Our revenue model exists, but I won't get into it here. Just wanted to highlight that we haven't overlooked it.<p>There's 2 founders, but I'm the only developer. This has been entirely bootstrapped. I did not know RoR (what the site is built with) prior to developing SkipScotch, although I've been a full-time software engineer for 3 years. Design is also not my specialty, so I realize there may be issues with it.<p>I'd love any feedback you can offer, especially on strategy and product launch. I realize it'll be tough to solve the chicken and egg problem, but I have a few strategies in mind (if you have some, I'd love to hear them!).<p>Any signups we can get through the landing page will be greatly appreciated. Feel free to contact me directly at founders@skipscotch.com for any reason whatsoever. Cheers and many thanks!

5 条评论

revorad超过 13 年前
Just launch already.<p>It's not clear to me how your reviews are more trustworthy. Voting reviewers has existed for a while on Amazon, but I'm not sure that isn't gamed.<p>Apart from trust, the other problem with reviews is that their relevance depends on the type of reviewer. For example, being Indian, when I'm looking for Indian restaurants, I trust reviews of Indians more than those of Americans because my expectations are more similar to other Indians. If I'm looking for hotels to go on vacation with my kids, I want reviews from other parents, not 20-year old single dudes who hated some place because there were too many kids making noise.
评论 #3291559 未加载
herrwolfe超过 13 年前
Hi - Think you should require images of all businesses. Whenever I see a listing without an image, no matter what, I will skip it. Also, change the "occurring today" flag to something a bit less sterile sounding. Attractive product, though I am not sure I see the difference to google/yelp as well.
评论 #3291639 未加载
michaeldhopkins超过 13 年前
I wish it was a startup related to scotch. Anyway...<p>Wisdom isn't a metric I trust if it's just users voting each other up. Seems like something a few spammers could easily game, right? Also, what does skipping to something do?
评论 #3291498 未加载
jhdavids8超过 13 年前
Clickable links: Landing page: <a href="http://skipscotch.com" rel="nofollow">http://skipscotch.com</a><p>Live demo: <a href="http://skipscotch.com/home/underdev" rel="nofollow">http://skipscotch.com/home/underdev</a>
ffumarola超过 13 年前
What are you hoping to improve over Yelp and Google Maps/Places/Hotpot? They would seem to be the biggest competitors. Is honesty / quality of reviews on Yelp honestly that large of a problem?
评论 #3291530 未加载