TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Have we been getting children’s playthings all wrong?

30 点作者 nigerian1981超过 2 年前

8 条评论

kqr超过 2 年前
&gt; In the 1970s and 80s, Gopnik and her colleagues [...] focused not on what children said, but on what they did in creative and problem-solving situations. “It turned out that even the youngest babies already knew more and learned more than we ever would have thought,” Gopnik went on.<p>This was one of the things that really surprised me when becoming a parent. If you take the time to just observe very small children doing their thing, they are surprisingly methodical, consistent, and hypothesis-driven. It looks like chaos at first, but then I&#x27;ve sort of come to realise that it&#x27;s really about performing actions that are likely to trigger a response with high information content.
评论 #33730359 未加载
评论 #33730336 未加载
quickthrower2超过 2 年前
A xylophone is just a fun toy. Claiming it is a conspiracy to educate your kids more is a bit silly. And so are a lot of the digs at various toys.
评论 #33731406 未加载
jonstewart超过 2 年前
I won’t buy my kids electronic toys, anything that makes noise or plays songs. When they’re given to my kids, I take the batteries out after a few days. They lose interest and go back to more imaginative toys, like legos, magnet tiles, marble runs, dress up clothes, crayons and painting, puzzles and games, etc.<p>The alphabet and counting? Read them books, count things with them.
评论 #33729828 未加载
评论 #33729734 未加载
评论 #33737707 未加载
评论 #33729500 未加载
rowanG077超过 2 年前
This article is so long-winded and repeating the same things 5 times that I found it incredibly irritating to read. I stopped after about 70%. I&#x27;m surprised it survived the cutting floor in this form. The content itself is not so bad.
评论 #33729697 未加载
评论 #33729953 未加载
irjustin超过 2 年前
No.<p>Are there better toys? Sure! But &quot;All wrong&quot;? The clickbait is strong with this one.
drewcoo超过 2 年前
First, getting into Harvard should not be the goal of a child&#x27;s toy. Not touching that, though.<p>More importantly, they&#x27;re getting children wrong. In the US, since the 60s, children (teens) have been treated as a market demographic. Since the 80s even pre-teen children have been. Children should not be marketed to. Period.<p>I&#x27;m not only complaining about makeup sales or frivolous things like frisbees. I&#x27;m not only complaining about Transformers: more than meets the eye, because it&#x27;s a bunch of media starring dolls you can buy.<p>Beyond those things, rather than target adults directly, for many decades now we have what is effectively corporate-funded psyops aimed at people&#x27;s children.<p>We somehow care about the relative non-issues of drunk driving, child abduction and &quot;stranger danger!&quot;, drugs, and more. Yet we don&#x27;t seem concerned at all about children&#x27;s desires being subverted to coopt their parents. We don&#x27;t care about highly effective, efficient mechanisms of market capitalism pointed directly at our kids!<p>Thanks, the Guardian, for trying to raise the alarm while also raising a smokescreen.<p>Also:<p>&gt; The history of toys is the history of teaching children to preoccupy themselves usefully and solitarily<p>WTF? No. The history of toys is largely the history of children creating play (where adults didn&#x27;t intend it) and then sharing it. Humans are social. We make and use toys. We use toys other folks invented, too, and often in new ways. Toys are not anti-social.<p>That quote reads like someone who&#x27;s only ever heard about vibrators and has heard that they&#x27;re only used alone! (Out of touch, as it were.)
Markoff超过 2 年前
Any headline that ends in a question mark can be answered by the word no.
评论 #33729578 未加载
评论 #33729929 未加载
Eleison23超过 2 年前
Yes. Children will play in a cardboard box, and together my sister and I can testify as living proof that children can play with anything you set before them.<p>I think middle-class parents are driven to keep-up-with-the-Joneses, and unfortunately the main drivers are the children themselves. Children are spoiled and exposed to all sorts of advertising in the guise of children&#x27;s programming. Children&#x27;s media is geared 100% to monetizing and productizing things and then having the children yelp at their parents in the grocery stores, in the toy stores, at home, at school, wherever, to please please please get me the new GI Joe or I won&#x27;t be cool enough.<p>Yet like a cat, a child can take an emptied out cardboard box on Christmas and have it be the most wondrous source of joy for that entire year.<p>Encourage kids&#x27; creativity, encourage the magic of youth, encourage their innocence.
评论 #33737784 未加载
评论 #33731863 未加载