TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

SenseiDB: Open-source, distributed, realtime, semi-structured database

163 点作者 thomas11超过 13 年前

15 条评论

untog超过 13 年前
I can't speak for SenseiDB itself, but I think that LinkedIn deserves a lot of credit for the technology they have been open sourcing in the last few months. Fantastic to see.
agentultra超过 13 年前
Looks like the marketing copy is off from the actual implementation, AFAICT.<p><pre><code> Sensei (先生) means teacher or professor in Japanese(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sensei). It shares the same pronunciation and writing with the Chinese word that has the same meaning. This name indicates that the system can be used in place of Oracle database in many applications. </code></pre> Okay, so on the name alone I can replace my Oracle database! Great!<p>Seriously though it goes on...<p>They claim the database is ACID: <a href="http://javasoze.github.com/sensei/data-guarantee.html" rel="nofollow">http://javasoze.github.com/sensei/data-guarantee.html</a><p>But they built the entire thing around "eventual consistency."<p>And statements like:<p><pre><code> "Sensei provides a high-level of durability by maintaining N replicas of each shard to guarantee a level of availability and fault-tolerance" </code></pre> Don't seem to make sense when talking about ACID given that a <i>write</i> operation will happen <i>at some point</i>. Looks like the data event producers will shard the data across N replicas without quorum... so there's no guarantee that there will be N replicas available... is that right (and that the transaction won't be lost mid-stream either)?<p>Skimming through the source it doesn't seem to be doing anything terribly revolutionary... and I can see the usefulness of the trade-offs they made in this database for certain scenarios. However I don't think the claims of ACID guarantees and "real time" are particularly representative of what this DB will actually do. They just don't seem to jive with "eventual consistency" models.<p>I'm not a hardcore database guru though so maybe I'm missing something?
评论 #3490377 未加载
评论 #3490433 未加载
评论 #3490623 未加载
joshhart超过 13 年前
Looks like someone non-LinkedIn posted this so the rest of the team is unlikely to be around for a few more hours. Let me know if you have any questions! I worked mostly on the distribution &#38; rpc piece.
评论 #3489940 未加载
评论 #3490107 未加载
opendomain超过 13 年前
3 separate NoSQL stores from ONE company? And their primary business is not Databases? There are currently more than 100 different NoSQL solutions - I believe we will see a consolidation of NoSQL in 2012
评论 #3490254 未加载
andres超过 13 年前
SenseiDB looks really impressive. We were actually thinking about the same problem when we built ThriftDB (<a href="http://www.thriftdb.com" rel="nofollow">http://www.thriftdb.com</a>) for Octopart so it's especially interesting to see LinkedIn's implementation.<p>Looking through the documentation a couple of things come to mind:<p>* Does SenseiDB support nested data structures?<p>* What happens when you modify the schema? Can you add/delete/modify attributes?
评论 #3490674 未加载
hello_moto超过 13 年前
How many home-grown databases have linkedin developed in the past few years?
评论 #3492160 未加载
评论 #3490646 未加载
javajosh超过 13 年前
Options are great (and thanks for contributing to the OS community), but the biggest barrier to adoption will be confusion about all the NoSQL solutions floating around right now (including two others from LinkedIn). Therefore, I recommend that you spend more time on the homepage comparing Sensei with other NoSQL stores. Perhaps take a two-tier approach for those coming from Oracle or MySQL: why NoSQL, and if NoSQL, why Sensei NoSQL?
franklovecchio超过 13 年前
Looking at its config, I'm reminded of Cassandra 0.6, but then I see the ZooKeeper functionality. Interesting. Love the open-sourcing! I showed an example of how to distribute inter-mingled DBs using MQtt a bit ago, but never posted here: <a href="http://franklovecchio.tumblr.com/post/13051814890/mqdb-distributing-databases-with-mqtt" rel="nofollow">http://franklovecchio.tumblr.com/post/13051814890/mqdb-distr...</a>.<p>One thing is for sure -- NoSQL isn't so mysterious anymore :)
ericmoritz超过 13 年前
So to get data into this database, I have to have a Gateway implementation in Java?<p>Would I have to publish messages to Kafka in my language of choice to avoid writing any Java?
评论 #3491355 未加载
zrail超过 13 年前
From a quick glance at the docs there's no database-side aggregations. Is that correct?
评论 #3489956 未加载
评论 #3490595 未加载
dougk超过 13 年前
Can Sensei be used as a replacement to MySQL + lucene?
评论 #3490111 未加载
foobarbazetc超过 13 年前
This is awesome.<p>Thanks for sharing this with the world. :)
cultureulterior超过 13 年前
Is it single-point-of-failure free?
评论 #3490297 未加载
ruslansv超过 13 年前
A truly amazing peace of technology
jamesu超过 13 年前
Nice looking wheel. I have a feeling it could be rounder though.
评论 #3490337 未加载