TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Notes apps are where ideas go to die (2022)

694 点作者 pps将近 2 年前

77 条评论

waboremo将近 2 年前
I love this, and I love how disturbing it is for a lot of people (especially those who only read the title)!<p>We think we write to remember, but it&#x27;s really the act of letting go as the article gets into as a theory, that really lets those notes become effective to us. We can revisit these notes at a later date, with fresh eyes, having forgotten about it entirely. It adds value, not because the original idea or note was particularly great, but because of what we are then combining it with (action and experience).<p>This is also why blindly making notes isn&#x27;t effective as a form of memorizing. You are writing just to write, you have to revisit them blindly in a new way for them to become effective with a new combination. As if you are a chemist creating a new concoction previously thought impossible.<p>So let your notes app become a giant trash pile. It&#x27;s better for you, and they should do their job with proper search anyways. Don&#x27;t spend time optimizing for note link graphs or any of that BS that doesn&#x27;t help you and you absolutely will stop caring about those &quot;features&quot; in 5 months anyways. Such features are just productivity industry nonsense to make you feel productive while the content remains elusive to your mind.
评论 #36145442 未加载
评论 #36148140 未加载
评论 #36147615 未加载
评论 #36145660 未加载
评论 #36147786 未加载
评论 #36147017 未加载
评论 #36145522 未加载
评论 #36147781 未加载
评论 #36147880 未加载
评论 #36148842 未加载
评论 #36146144 未加载
评论 #36145901 未加载
评论 #36146700 未加载
kqr将近 2 年前
I like the idea presented in TFA, but as a small counter-anecdote, the mileage I&#x27;ve gotten out of my reading has skyrocketed since I started doing spaced repetition.<p>I can now actually whip out enumerative combinatorics to solve problems, or do on the spot estimations of the standard error of log-odds differences from contingency tables, or compute the power or any number to any other with mental maths, without looking it up in my notes first. That&#x27;s immensely powerful.<p>But it also doesn&#x27;t stop there. Since I now remember far more higher-level concepts, I can also make sense of more advanced reading in a way I was unable to when I had to dip back and forth between my notes and the text to try to piece things together.<p>Essentially, remembering what I&#x27;ve read has allowed me to raise the level of abstraction of my thinking, which has been more helpful than I expected it to, across a number of different situations.<p>----<p>That said, I&#x27;m only a few months into my spaced repetition journey, so maybe there&#x27;s a balance to strike and a judgment to make between forgetting and remembering, and I&#x27;m sure that&#x27;s something I&#x27;ll get better at finding as I get practise.<p>Maybe the first few months of spaced repetition is the time before diminishing returns set in. I don&#x27;t know but I&#x27;m excited to find out.
评论 #36148092 未加载
评论 #36148467 未加载
评论 #36149080 未加载
评论 #36149394 未加载
评论 #36147927 未加载
评论 #36149215 未加载
ChanderG将近 2 年前
I strongly recommend everyone read Luhmann&#x27;s original paper [1] on Zettelkasten.<p>What I got from it is that, the process is less about storing&#x2F;retrieving information, but more about building a system that can surprise you - the way ideas emerge when you brainstorm with others. These others being people with the same level of knowledge as you - so, not the kind of information flow that happens between an expert and a beginner, but between peers who have access to the same kind of information, but simply look at things differently.<p>For some reason, every Zettelkasten system out there focuses on the mechanics, and in my opinion, not enabling the original intent of the approach. Not that I have a solution to the problem.<p>[1] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;daily.scottscheper.com&#x2F;zettelkasten&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;daily.scottscheper.com&#x2F;zettelkasten&#x2F;</a>
评论 #36150077 未加载
评论 #36147868 未加载
评论 #36150126 未加载
bsnnkv将近 2 年前
I would add to this that both note apps and read it later queues&#x2F;apps are where ideas go to die. One of the most important mental shifts I had in the last 10 years was to adopt a &quot;read it now or read it never&quot; (RINORIN) model, which de facto meant that I had to also give up annotating my RIL queues with notes and tags (largely for the reasons in this post).<p>Now if something catches my attention, I&#x27;ll read it immediately to the best of my ability, send some highlights directly from the browser (desktop and mobile) to my Notado archive (I&#x27;d say 90%+ of my tagging of whatever I save is automated with rules) and be done with it. Whenever I&#x27;m in the mood to look back through the highlights (and comments) I&#x27;ve saved, it&#x27;s great to have that built-in quality+relevancy+interestingness filter that comes from RINORIN.<p>Life is much better now that I&#x27;m not living with that constant FOMO. Even if I could read, highlight and annotate everything (I can&#x27;t, and neither can you, and that&#x27;s ok), I would never be able to do something with _all_ of it (I can&#x27;t, and neither can you, and that&#x27;s ok).
评论 #36146158 未加载
评论 #36169543 未加载
评论 #36147283 未加载
0xCMP将近 2 年前
While this was true for me for a long time, basically my notes were useless in my day to day life, this has changed for me with Obsidian.<p>I now actually go back and curate my notes into a kind of wiki that is meant just for me. I&#x27;ve tried running a wiki for my self, but it doesn&#x27;t work offline. And I tried just using plain text or OrgMode, but they were impossible to deal with on my phone. It just strikes that perfect amount of customization and cross-platform support that I needed to make it somewhere I trust storing the information. And in the end it really is still just a bunch of markdown files in a git repo (thanks Working Copy!) so I am not really locked in like I was with any other apps I&#x27;ve used.
评论 #36146606 未加载
评论 #36146232 未加载
评论 #36147379 未加载
评论 #36146578 未加载
killjoywashere将近 2 年前
So, I&#x27;ve been through the 26th grade. More time in school after high school than before. And I didn&#x27;t finish until I was 41. In the middle (if you&#x27;re counting) there were 7 years of training in a different career, a different set of oral boards (passed, btw), and a whopping total of 3 years in the work force where I was really studying for admission into grades 23-26 (aka residency).<p>If expertise is learning all the ways to fail, I must surely be an expert in learning how to learn. I even did a survey of my medical school classmates on the subject and found some trends. I then proceeded to ignore many of those trends myself, and reaped the consequences. Finally, I implemented what I was supposed to from the beginning, and ... you know what? It fucking works.<p>Do not take a laptop to class. Take handwritten notes. Take your notes in a bound volume with a few pages at the front for a table of contents (1). Fill in the table of contents later. That will force you to re-engage with your notes and figure out what it was you meant to write, and boil it down to something very pithy in the ToC.<p>I told my kids what to do. I told them I would buy all the notebooks they wanted. I would keep them. They should never throw them away. They are now crushing it. My daughter has a 3.9 in a top school. My son hasn&#x27;t finished high school and he ran out of math classes in the local community college (2).<p>I still journal. It&#x27;s not really notes now, but I sit down at least a few times a week and write down the things that happened each day. Each and every day is documented. For a number of reasons. First, for my own letting go. Second, for remembering. Third, as memoranda for the record. It&#x27;s quite hard to plagiarize page 42 of 256 pages when all the other pages are filled in too. (3)<p>(1) I strongly favor Leuchtturm1917 A5. Better papers, slightly wider, better ToC, better bookmark ribbons. I prefer dots or grid.<p>(2) the Silicon Valley community colleges have pretty solid math. There&#x27;s a story that Hewlett Packard actually stocked de Anza&#x27;s math department with HP engineers at one point because they projected they wouldn&#x27;t be able to fill their hiring requirements without growing their own. Talk about a build-vs-buy decision!<p>(3) For journaling, I&#x27;ve switched to larger A4+ because I&#x27;m just writing longhand and, especially as a lefty, I find the binding (any binding) to be mildly frustrating.
gexla将近 2 年前
I think it&#x27;s helpful to think of notes and writing as one part in a flow of ideation. Ideas should be thought of as streams, just like thinking. Notes and writing are simply tools which are a part of that flow. Each setting of that flow has different powers of constraint. The best ideas may start with walking, but there&#x27;s the constraint of development. Writing is best for development, but you&#x27;re thinking may be less free than walking as you have more focus in development. Then editing the writing requires a different mindset. You may then publish that writing to propogate the idea for feedback.<p>So, notes are streams. You&#x27;re not saving ideas to forget them. You&#x27;re saving them to interact with them with different tooling. A relatively small portion of those ideas will ever make it to the end the flow, which is publishing. And they lose relevance to us because our context changes. An idea is important to you in a certain moment, with certain circumstances. The following day, the context has changed. Only the ideas which stick will retain their relevance. Just like only a small number of ideas will widely resonate with others.<p>I don&#x27;t think there&#x27;s a need to delete them. You&#x27;re context later may return to a similar enough state that old ideas become useful again, and you can refactor them.
评论 #36154262 未加载
narag将近 2 年前
He has a point about digital hoarding. But that isn&#x27;t the whole story about taking notes. Not everybody takes notes because of some twisted quirk rooted in evolutionary behaviour, really. Some of us take notes because... we need to remember things, a lot of things.<p>The acid test for note taking is: do you get back to your notes, process, organize, sieve, tidy and reformat them regularly?<p>So have a free insight if you&#x27;re writing a note taking app: make it useful for serious note takers.
评论 #36147072 未加载
alkonaut将近 2 年前
I don&#x27;t get people who keep refining their &quot;notes&quot; (They go from a personal wiki to OrgMode to whatever it is the next year). What I don&#x27;t get is what they make notes OF.<p>I get that people might need to keep a list of things to buy the next time they go grocery shopping. But what is it that makes some aggregate page after page of notes week after week? Is it both private and professional notes? Is it more a ritual of organizing thoughts than creating a lasting document? If so then I can understand it. Some people don&#x27;t think clearly until they write. But are there people who also revisit these notes?<p>The topic of &quot;notes&quot; keeps popping up on HN periodically and I feel like I&#x27;m of a different species when I don&#x27;t get what (after 20 years of running a family and software career) I ever missed to take a note of because I made none!
评论 #36150422 未加载
评论 #36162957 未加载
评论 #36150802 未加载
评论 #36150756 未加载
Agingcoder将近 2 年前
I disagree. Notes are not only for ideas - they’re also here to manage complexity and understand things.<p>I use notes app to quickly remember what would otherwise be forgotten. I use notes apps just to make sense of what’s around me and not to have magical ideas.<p>I’m essentially a staff engineer, and my scope is very broad. I can pretend I have eidetic memory ( which I don’t have), or be lucid, and use notes as a way to not forget things, and be able to draw à meaningful plan.
评论 #36146754 未加载
entontoent将近 2 年前
I guess this makes sense if you don’t use a Second Brain&#x2F;PARA&#x2F;Zettelkasten&#x2F;etc. system, but my entire life is structured around Obsidian (at home) and OneNote (at work).<p>If you’re just throwing notes into a note-taking app with no way of processing them, I can see how this would be true, but my system is constantly resurfacing old thoughts, and I make conscious choices about what gets archived and preserved.<p>I read the full article, and it sounds like the author hasn’t heard of these. Confident article. Not deeply researched in my opinion.
评论 #36149373 未加载
renke1将近 2 年前
Notes never really worked for me previously, but somehow I got it working with logseq [1] (it doesn&#x27;t really matter which Roam-like tool you use). I feels like some kind of super power to be able to quickly access all sort of information. What helped me was thinking in projects (prepare conference talk XYZ, write article for tech magazine ABC and of course actual projects). Also I always link persons I interact with when I create notes for a meeting or similar situations. That way you can quickly show all relevant information about a person. Most important though is the ability to write down TODOs anywhere and later see them in an aggregated manner.<p>[1]: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;logseq.com&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;logseq.com&#x2F;</a>
celerity将近 2 年前
Hey, this is exactly why I made obsidian-repeat-plugin [1]. The goal was to have most of my notes surface every now and then, which removes the need for me to do any digging at all.<p>With that said, my non-repeating notes are far from &quot;dead&quot;. First, I have a lot of useful self-made references. Second, Obsidian really makes it easy to spontaneously group tags with its backlink system. Every now and then, I go down a rabbit hole and catch up to notes that would otherwise be dead. I only have to maintain a few &quot;entry points&quot; that mostly have other notes linking to them.<p>[1]: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;github.com&#x2F;prncc&#x2F;obsidian-repeat-plugin">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;github.com&#x2F;prncc&#x2F;obsidian-repeat-plugin</a>
评论 #36155767 未加载
dang将近 2 年前
Discussed at the time:<p><i>Notes apps are where ideas go to die, and that’s good</i> - <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=30344237" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=30344237</a> - Feb 2022 (158 comments)
评论 #36145395 未加载
guico将近 2 年前
Writing something down in order to lose that “weight” is indeed the main goal of note-taking.<p>But most apps make this surprisingly hard… you first need to figure out if you should create a new note or append to an existing one. If new note, then in which folder? If existing note, then which one?<p>It’s too much mental burden when all you want ia jot something down and be sure you’ll find it later.<p>I made an app that’s great at this, just this. It’s basically an infinite page where you write everything down, in one continuous stream. Then it has some basic tagging and search so you can find stuff again.<p>Feel free to try if interested: PaperRoll.app
评论 #36147859 未加载
mo_42将近 2 年前
I tried countless notes and productivity apps. They all didn’t work. Now, I have a folder called zettelkasten. It contains a collection of interlinked markdown files.<p>It’s the first time something like this works for me. I does so because I use it daily to refine, trash, and collect information.<p>Btw: I call BS on the section about Kahneman and loss aversion. Their experimental setup was too narrow to extend it to something like fear of missing out on information.
评论 #36151769 未加载
评论 #36150267 未加载
评论 #36148657 未加载
fastball将近 2 年前
This is something we think about a lot for my note-taking app[1]. We usually call this the &quot;super-optimizer trap&quot; internally, where we notice that a lot of users come to our app after filling up a series of other note-taking apps with data. For some people, this is just because their organization system isn&#x27;t very well thought out and therefore doesn&#x27;t scale well. However, a lot of people <i>do</i> use a well-thought out system. Getting Things Done (GTD) is mentioned in the article, but we find a lot of users that come to our app are trying Zettelkasten[2] or some variation thereof.<p>And yet... many of those people <i>also</i> have an urge to switch once they&#x27;ve used an app for a certain period of time. I think the issue is a note-taking variation of the &quot;Hedonic Treadmill&quot;. Some people are just mentally the type of person that gets a kick out of organizing their notes and thoughts. Eventually those people return to their baseline and need to switch to a new system in order to get that adrenaline fix. More concretely, we have seen that users who say they have come to Supernotes after trying many other note-taking apps are much more likely to churn, regardless of if we have the features they say they are looking for at the beginning.<p>As far as solutions go, I think one common pattern is spaced repetition (Anki being one of the best known apps for this), where the system will automatically re-surface things it wants you to remember (and not just forget). Many in the space are now trying to utilize AI (i.e. LLMs) to give even better contextual info and resurfacing, which is a promising approach. Regardless I think features like this can definitely help make an app continue to feel fresh long after the honeymoon period. We try to solve this by just having your notes be a feed (rather than just a list of documents), which allows you to occasionally find things you forgot about. Definitely a tough challenge with lots of potential solutions!<p>[1] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;supernotes.app&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;supernotes.app&#x2F;</a><p>[2] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;community.supernotes.app&#x2F;t&#x2F;trying-to-decide&#x2F;1644" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;community.supernotes.app&#x2F;t&#x2F;trying-to-decide&#x2F;1644</a>
评论 #36146933 未加载
评论 #36157441 未加载
dmingod666将近 2 年前
I think the blame should go to a lacking process where you review, reorganize your notes.<p>A regular stocktaking of planned action and choose to do or dropped stuff you wanted to do<p>Author misses a category of notes that are actively created as personal documentation for things you don&#x27;t do often or keep forgetting. Those are human equivalents of a bash script<p>Say: &quot;Install k8s on redhat 8.x&quot;<p>Open this doc you&#x27;ve written, blindly follow steps you&#x27;ve done before, there is tremendous value in this.<p>Your future you and you are slightly different people, learn to keep the conversation going, don&#x27;t blame the tech
phforms将近 2 年前
It really makes a night and day difference when you are taking notes for studying, research, designing or other kinds of focussed mental activity that require things like pulling information together, resurfacing past insights, (re)evaluating ideas, (re)contextualizing findings, seeing&#x2F;drawing the overall picture, etc.<p>Modern note-taking tools help our brains with their limited capacity to manage greater complexity, discover obscure connections and, of course, safely forget to free working memory for other things.<p>However, if you just write down some ideas from time to time that are not really related to each other or stash resources like interesting weblinks without making an effort to organize and connect them in meaningful ways, fancy new apps and features won’t really provide much value beyond just using a plain old notebook.<p>Overthinking really seems to be an issue with users of networked notebook apps and it can waste a lot of time and money. We should stop building elaborate systems or focussing on complicated workflows unless we really have a strong motivation, such as deep, long-term research and study. Serving this motivation will then be the actual focus of our efforts, not the tools or workflows themselves. It can be fun to explore “tools for thought” on their own, but they will not magically change our lifes if they cannot solve a problem that is meaningful to us.
sideproject将近 2 年前
I bookmarked this just in case I need to read it later. :)
throwaway_ab将近 2 年前
I use digital text notes and digital paper notes (using a Remarkable tablet in the past, now using Supernote instead)<p>However for much of my life I still struggled to get more out of the system than the mere act of committing the note, which often is enough to make something stick in my memory for longer. (Especially writing a physical note on my Remarkable tablet)<p>So just that committing of a note was worth it.<p>Still, notes were one way for me for me, ideas and thoughts did not get revisited.<p>A few things changed all of that for me.<p>For my digital text note system, Logseq.<p>I finally found a system where I am able to amend, see, change, work with all my existing notes when creating new notes.<p>Now a new note uses blocks from other notes, I revisit old info more and more.<p>My mind works wonderfully with this.<p>Logseq is an infinite outliner, a bi-directional note system that allows for true in place transclusion (put editable excerpts of notes into other notes always editable)<p>Also Logseq has an incredibly flexible and powerful query language that is just nuts. I love it.<p>And then recently I switch my physical handwritten notes from Remarkable to Supernote.<p>Why?<p>Oh my God<p>Supernote let&#x27;s me create inter note links!<p>My own handwriting, I can just select the vector text, and link to any page of the note or any other note I have to make a link.<p>It&#x27;s such a powerful addition now my notes are becoming so much more powerful.<p>Links are great, they let me easily revisit old info when adding new which I find is awesome.<p>The Supernote is kind of on a wiki level with its link capabilities which I used to think was top tier but since Logseq bidirectional linking blows wiki based out of the water. However I can&#x27;t see how to add bi-directional to Supernote easily? They are making a Linux based version soon so perhaps when they do if I upgrade I could write a script to add that functionality?<p>Anyways. Going back to Remarkable or paper without any handwritten note links is not possible. I&#x27;ve been spoiled.<p>Also I am working on a script to auto convert and retain links to my Supernote and integrate into Logseq but haven&#x27;t succeeded yet. One day!
nomilk将近 2 年前
I strongly disagree with the premise (that the only utility from note-taking is being able to forget about it). I take copious lists and notes, and am surprised how frequently I can find some incredibly apt (but very obscure) reference I stumbled upon and noted 4 or 5 years ago. The exception are links to youtube videos, which often vanish.
评论 #36146016 未加载
vigneshwaran将近 2 年前
Why stop with writing notes and forget?<p>A better way is to combine your notes tool with Readwise. If you use Notion, then save the page link under a custom book titled Notes.<p>You’ll get reminded once in a while. Just click the link, review the notes like flash card.<p>Or just use the static reminder feature in notion if you want more control over your reminders.
rtpg将近 2 年前
I do get the disillusions with building up huge amounts of structured data and finding it&#x27;s not &quot;worth it&quot;.<p>I&#x27;ve been pretty happy with paper notes on this front because you can quickly give up on structure and write things as fragments. You&#x27;ll &quot;know&quot; it&#x27;s there, and end up finding it eventually.<p>I think if you&#x27;re using something like Notion or Roam, trying to keep stuff pretty flat (Search function exists!) is very helpful, as it lowers the cost of writing things down and means you don&#x27;t get as burnt out.<p>&quot;Old notes are worthless&quot; is like... pretty glib though. I actually look back at notes relatively often! But it&#x27;s often not a structured activity, so it&#x27;s hard to say the notes are part of some generalized process. But there is a liberation in deleting some older notes, just like there is in deleting older projects.
jkingsbery将近 2 年前
Is this really how other people operate?<p>I really on my old notes all the time. People mention &quot;oh, I was going to look into X,&quot; and I do a quick search through my notes to send them some links to the investigation I did earlier on X. People ask a question &quot;What are you planning on doing on Y?&quot; and I find in my old notes &quot;subject matter so-and-so says: Y? I wouldn&#x27;t worry about Y.&quot; Especially in engineering, there are lots of things that I think are not important at the time because I lack context to understand it&#x27;s importance, and I only understand it&#x27;s importance because I wrote down unimportant seeming things, go back and read through my notes and realize &quot;Oh, 3 different people told me Z is a big deal. I didn&#x27;t realize, I should go learn more about Z.&quot;
评论 #36146866 未加载
dheera将近 2 年前
I don&#x27;t agree with this.<p>A lot of my ideas are dependent on timing and that&#x27;s why I write them down.<p>Like I have photography ideas for winter but it&#x27;s not winter yet. Or something I want to do or eat the next time I go to a certain city but I don&#x27;t want to fly to that city for that reason only.<p>Or vacation project ideas, but it&#x27;s not convenient to take PTO right now, but when I can take PTO I hit a mental block about what to do with it, and it&#x27;s nice to have a &quot;menu&quot; of ideas I had thought of before and pick one.<p>Timing-dependent ideas is one of my primary use of notes apps.
joelegner将近 2 年前
I tend to agree that I rarely, if ever, read any of the copious notes I’ve taken. However, I find the iOS notes app is a good middle step in a workflow from reading to remembering.<p>What I like to do is read a chapter of a book, scientific article, or blog post, let’s say, and then write a summary in a note. I can distill the message down and integrate it with existing knowledge by noting similarities.<p>After that step, I create Anki cards from the notes to remember the key points. By this approach I go from reading material to permanent memory.
评论 #36148316 未加载
DubiousPusher将近 2 年前
The search in Google Keep is fantastic and thus I do not use my notes in this way. Before embarking upon any project I search my notes for keywords related to it and often turn up measurements, material suggestions and instructional links that I&#x27;ve previously collected when thinking about the project in years past.<p>This has changed how I make notes as well. I have learned to make them searchable. I often think, &quot;what will future me search in order to find this note&quot; and this sprinkle in a few extra keywords.
jeron将近 2 年前
I actually disagree with this. For me, I find notes apps help me reflect on things. I daily journal into Notion. If you ask me what I did exactly seven days ago from today, I could tell you a rough idea from the top of my head but my Notes app would allow me to recall and tell you an answer. That, and it helps me flesh out ideas that I want to explore. If the idea was bad, I would jot it down and forget, but if it was really good I would definitely go back to it
kstenerud将近 2 年前
Here&#x27;s how I write notes:<p>For ideas:<p>1. I time box thinking about the idea I&#x27;ve had. If after 10 minutes I don&#x27;t feel like it&#x27;s particularly useful, I just forget it.<p>2. Write it in one of the markdown files I keep in my Documents directory (partitioned by broad category).<p>3. Skim through the rest of the file and see if the other things in there are still interesting. If not, delete.<p>For designs:<p>1. Usually while I&#x27;m working, I keep a temporary file in an editor that keeps a backup of open files (it won&#x27;t even have a file name). Everything I think of goes in there roughshod, in between separators. Completely free-form.<p>2. If I need to switch to something else for an extended period of time, I save the file to disk.<p>3. Once I&#x27;ve built the project or feature, I close the unsaved file (i.e. throw it out).<p>For writing:<p>1. One markdown file per piece, done in a similar fashion to the design documents. The bottom-most section of the file is for the current draft, and everything above it is free-form rough ideas.<p>2. Either post it, throw it out, or put in long term storage depending on what it&#x27;s for and how I feel about it.<p>-<p>Search is done with grep.<p>Backup is done with rsync over SSH (I just have it mirror my home dir).<p>No notes apps, no special systems. Just markdown files and directories so that I can access it from anywhere with anything.
witzna将近 2 年前
Expressing our thoughts through writing can go beyond a mere brain dump. Journaling and reflective writing have been found to offer opportunities for self-discovery and generating insights. Research in psychology supports the idea that writing can have therapeutic benefits and contribute to personal growth. Studies by Pennebaker and Beall (1986) and Smyth (1998) have shown that expressive writing can improve physical and psychological health, while Baikie and Wilhelm (2005) found that it enhances self-awareness and promotes personal understanding. By exploring our own writings and analyzing patterns, emotions, and themes, we can gain a deeper understanding of ourselves and our experiences. Writing can be a valuable tool for introspection and self-reflection, leading to psychological insights and personal development.<p>I have no idea who is working on this and how old but if the claims are true it could be interesting: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.aphanmiz.com" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.aphanmiz.com</a>
l33tbro将近 2 年前
Of course some notes you write down become outdated (as author mentions), but other ideas you write down are almost timeless.<p>I&#x27;d be screwed without Notes. It&#x27;s a repository of so many abstract thoughts that I have no place thinking about all day. There&#x27;s simply too much going on.<p>Having things written down in shorthand like a prompt is so handy when I have some time to go back and browse the gallery of good and bad ideas.
评论 #36145838 未加载
sunday_serif将近 2 年前
I mostly agree with the message of this article. I rarely ever reference the knowledge and information I captured in a note. Nor have I experienced a major revelation by seeing all of my notes rendered in the structure of a particular notes app.<p>However, I believe there is a benefit to notes kept over a long term which is being discounted. I believe that notes allow you to see how your thinking on a topic has changed over time.<p>They allow you to cast your mind back to your thinking when you first encountered a new topic, or back to a time when you were struggling with an idea that now seems obvious to you. They are a way to observe the progress and velocity of your learning.<p>I think that notes can be for active learners what a lifting journal is to a power lifter, or a mile and pace log is to a runner. Those logs are objectively not that interesting, but they allow you to measure and reflect on your progress.<p>An aside: I personally find that audio recordings are the best form of notes. Hearing your own voice explain an idea or concept carries so much more information than can easily be captured with text.
samsquire将近 2 年前
My first journal document has 3700 stars on GitHub, so if you share your thoughts in the open, you can spread your ideas wide.<p>I use GitHub README.md for my journals and journal in public. GitHub I hope shall be around in 10 years.<p>I&#x27;ve had 10 years of free hosting on GitHub and in theory shall have 10 years more.<p>I don&#x27;t keep my ideas to myself, writing is thinking and improves the world.
stared将近 2 年前
Yes, forgetting gives space to focus on new ideas. But the author paints it as if the fear of losing information was irrational. It isn&#x27;t. Exactly with the same arguments, the author could persuade us that:<p>- HDD is unnecessary - just use RAM.<p>- Git history makes no sense.<p>Most ideas aren&#x27;t new or they don&#x27;t make sense. And even if they do, we may never have time to put them into action. But this 1% (or maybe 0.1%) of ideas actually make sense. We may never revisit 90% of our thoughts and ideas, and 9% revisit without our gain, but for this 1%, it is still worth it to take notes. All discoveries, startups, books, and works of art come from this tiny fraction of ideas that were actually good. And on a more mundane level, think about all well-thought-out gifts.<p>It is super naive to claim that since most ideas are of little value, then all ideas have no value.
peteforde将近 2 年前
While I am on-side with the idea that there&#x27;s value in forgetting, you would have to yank my Workflowy from my cold, dead hands. If I had to choose between giving up my calendar or my lists, I would give up my calendar every time.<p>I believe that &quot;forgetting&quot; is really the wrong lens, anyhow. Aside from simplicity, Workflowy&#x27;s primary draw for me is that it can help me rapidly (a few 10s of ms) find any keyword in my massive, 10+ year, 75k+ node list-of-lists. I can relax and &quot;forget&quot; because I trust that what I need is there when I go to search for it. This is the exact same mechanics at work in Inbox Zero, which is also something that helped me reclaim my life.<p>Workflowy has literally allowed me to forget more than most people know about the topics I&#x27;m expert in. If that&#x27;s not a solid pitch, I honestly don&#x27;t know what could be.
jimsimmons将近 2 年前
Evernote context seemed great when I used it briefly with my premium subscription.<p>Bubbles up relevant notes automatically without having to link them like in Obsidian or something.<p>I think apart from that or an Anki like system there’s no way to solve this.<p>On the other hand maybe note taking is more about thinking and catalysing an idea and less about using in later
monkeydust将近 2 年前
Early on in my career I used to take copious amounts of notes at work, had note books filled with them. I then moved onto apps and got obsessed with trying the latest one to make me more productive, or so I thought.<p>I stopped doing this around 5 years ago as an experiment and never looked back, I am probably more productive now and I sense my memory is sharper. My colleagues comment about how I can recall things from months back without looking at notes (sometimes to their annoyance).<p>I have found myself instead thinking a lot more and actually talking to myself quietly to process concepts and ideas, this is a bit weird I know and few colleagues commented on it.<p>Also instead of taking notes from meetings I mark expected actions from them in my diary to hold others and myself accountable to time.<p>I also religiously follow the &#x27;two minutes rule&#x27; by James Clear.
评论 #36148160 未加载
mercurialsolo将近 2 年前
If you are writing anything detailed and in-depth, often times writing is also a way to get things out of the working memory for us to find space to expand the original idea. We can revise, condense better when we can see and visualize things rather than hold the idea in the entirety in high fidelity in our working brain.<p>I am super skeptical of organizing notes though, if your working memory has not managed to process the idea and come up with an outcome which is shareable in a given window, its unlikely that revisiting it, linking it upto concepts in a document ever brings the rewards.<p>Would love to see someone publish an MRI of the brain as we are writing versus the phase before it. Do we see increased activity in some centers and do we see that activity reducing post writing? Is that true for any creative endeavour?
maxs将近 2 年前
I agree with this. This is why every note I add must be repeated in spaced repetition style. This way I remember what is in my &quot;mind palace&quot; and keep ideas alive (or explicitly delete them &#x2F; reduce their repetition period if they are bad). I use Obsidian with the repeat plugin.
writingfm将近 2 年前
&gt; ...some of the stuff&#x27;s really good... [but] then you try to relocate a note, only to find that your favorite app&#x27;s search doesn’t seem to be as good as you thought it was.<p>This is precisely why you need an inbox[0] for your ideas that you <i>do</i> sort through regularly.<p>Sure, you can treat your Notes app as a trash bin that never gets emptied. That&#x27;ll work fine for collecting quotes and facts and musings.<p>But when you get an idea you know you might want to take action on (not just hoard), you need a visible place to stash it -- if only so you can decide later that you won&#x27;t take action on it after all.<p>[0] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;writing.fm&#x2F;you-need-an-idea-inbox&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;writing.fm&#x2F;you-need-an-idea-inbox&#x2F;</a>
nologic01将近 2 年前
A note-taking could easily do the exact statistics of how many times we go back and check our notes.<p>The result probably varies a bit, depending on the note taking style and one&#x27;s needs but my n=1 insight is that the few times I do, it is indispensable.<p>So its not a placebo, note taking works by giving you a few precious hints as to what was your state of mind. Its a digital long tail extension of the mind. Not somebody elses mind. They would literally make no sense of my notes.<p>A key consideration is how much time it takes. Too detailed and its probably a waste of time, too sketchy and it might not capture enough hints.<p>So the endless discussion about note taking apps feels like an obsession. Maybe we feel there is something dramatically empowering <i>just</i> beyond reach.
Mathnerd314将近 2 年前
I never really took notes in school. Read the textbook, learn the material, and then forget it after the final exam. Sometimes when there was an open-note exam I&#x27;d go back through the textbook and write down the important definitions. But now that I&#x27;m doing research I take lots of notes. I organize it like I&#x27;m writing some papers: files with abstracts, definitions, comparisons, and a bibliography. The goal eventually is that they&#x27;ll be published, either in scientific journals or as a book if there&#x27;s not enough novel material. I&#x27;d say, form follows function, so if you don&#x27;t know what your notes will be usable for in the future they probably will be useless.
lolive将近 2 年前
For me, Obsidian really made me jump into the note-taking bandwagon. So all the points raised in the article are almost old story.<p>My next challenges are: how to organise a note, regarding its granularity and refactoring.<p>To elaborate a little bit, the question now for me is really when I reread a note about a topic I did not know well when I first wrote about it, and now I need to add new (more advanced) content.<p>Should I keep my newbie vision of the topic? Or replace it with the vison from the more advanced me? Won’t that make my note unreadable by a newbie, then?<p>I wonder how Wikipedian contributors handle that problem (especially when dealing with new pages, or pages about fast-evolving topics)
johndhi将近 2 年前
I wrote about 1000 words of journaling per day for three years (stopped recently) and have kind of no idea what&#x27;s in there. I&#x27;d love some way to mine and understand and represent it in graphs.
评论 #36147148 未加载
评论 #36147152 未加载
emodendroket将近 2 年前
My most frequently used notes system is a literal notebook on my desk. I just write on whichever page is open. I don&#x27;t make any attempt to organize it. Notes about work, notes about a contractor I spoke to do some landscaping, notes about what I&#x27;m going to make for dinner, it&#x27;s all jumbled up. Eventually when it fills up I page through to see if I still need anything. Almost invariably the answer is no.
lolive将近 2 年前
Off-topic: I really wonder if the point of taking notes is to actually browse those notes [by following links]. For me, searching notes and iframing notes one inside the other [to make kinds of self-contained reference meta-notes, à la Wikipedia] really are the top most important features. Linking notes and exploiting that graph is not that much valuable for the moment in my own workflow. [call me a document-based person ;)]
drannex将近 2 年前
I&#x27;ve always thought this was the case for writing notes. Notes and notes apps have always been referred to my &quot;Brainlog&quot; or my second brain. They are a place I can put my thoughts that I no longer want to actively take the time to remember, or to create a log of activities that I&#x27;ve taken that I would have forgotten anyway.<p>I don&#x27;t write notes to remember, I write notes so I don&#x27;t have to.
hugozap将近 2 年前
I replaced my Obsidian workflow with a one big Google doc and it&#x27;s been the best decision. No need to sync, offline support and reduced complexity.
评论 #36148485 未加载
评论 #36146271 未加载
Mizoguchi将近 2 年前
Bookmarked, will read it later.
评论 #36145943 未加载
评论 #36146376 未加载
FpUser将近 2 年前
I use notes to keep links with short descriptions or sometimes full articles on subject that interest me now or might interest in the future. Most of them never revisited but sometime I remember that I had the info do a quick search in my notes and voila. So I find it very useful even though the ration of ballast to revisited info is not very good.
lannisterstark将近 2 年前
I have approximately 35000 OneTab tabs &quot;saved&quot; to &quot;visit them later.&quot; I haven&#x27;t yet. (Dw, safely backed up in case I ever need to).<p>I also write stuff down in todo lists or notes apps etc and never revisit them, or revisit them weeks later. It&#x27;s...annoying. I relate to this so much.
评论 #36149051 未加载
SnowHill9902将近 2 年前
Ideas prove their worth by fighting back.
djmips将近 2 年前
CLickbait using the phrase &#x27;go to die&#x27;.<p>It&#x27;s just the old idea of relieving your mind of remembering everything.
Nevermark将近 2 年前
Maybe we saved all those snippets, bookmarks, links, and notes because one day, one bright shiny day, we will feed them all as one big prompt to our new personal multimodal super-intelligent brain-interfaced skull-surface-wrapped self-augment subsystem.
jbverschoor将近 2 年前
Not just notes..<p>Everything these days is either archived, or gets lost in “the feed”.<p>I really miss the concept of a Desktop. A place where current work is done.<p>Unfortunately, people think that the filesystem is not for the endusers.. everything is solid per app, and hidden in it.<p>Ahh BeOS, where everything was a file.
评论 #36145492 未加载
评论 #36145890 未加载
hardwaresofton将近 2 年前
Hard disagree, it’s like investing for retirement :)<p>All those rainy day projects are just waiting for a rainy day.<p>Also I happen to send a bunch of my best startup ideas out as a newsletter, so that’s something. Viewed cynically, I guess that’s just from my notes app to yours.
评论 #36147113 未加载
jupake将近 2 年前
This hits home for me. I am a serial idea-writer-downer. Maybe its time to cold delete all my programming notes. And free my brain to focus on things that matter, and not an endless stream of unfinished side projects. Good read.
vladsanchez将近 2 年前
This is one of the best essays I&#x27;ve read in recent memory. Great writing [Matthew Guay|<a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;twitter.com&#x2F;maguay" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;twitter.com&#x2F;maguay</a>]!
dunnononot将近 2 年前
Little side-Note (comic-strip in german):<p>&gt; &#x2F;&#x2F;i.postimg.cc&#x2F;nLYLfpnY&#x2F;12592-6-WIDER-BESSEREN-WISSENS-STATT-DES-GLAUBENS-FINAL-Mail.png<p>Hint: Yesterday i read trough the first third of the post... (-;
kelseydh将近 2 年前
I have a section in my notes app that highlights interesting excerpts, sayings and pieces of wisdom. It&#x27;s always a pleasure to go back and read what my old self thought was cool.
swaggyBoatswain将近 2 年前
I have different note apps for different purposes<p>I&#x27;m a strong believer in &quot;one app, one use case&quot;. It&#x27;s easier to mentally remember what note app is used for what specific need I have<p>One app i use is designed to &quot;forget&quot; and revisit at a different point of time, mostly around personal challenges I&#x27;ve had in life. This is my private journal - i do not write anything technical here, i do not bookmark anything - and i only write it from my phone. Sometimes I want to go back and see how far I&#x27;ve come, to understand and remember what single life was, how I felt moving to a new city for the first time, etc. It&#x27;s my private space to forget thoughts and move onto bigger things in life. I sometimes write in third person to basically give advice to myself here too. These notes are more emotionally driven. There can be many notes here<p>Another note app I use is designed for purely private technical note taking. These are bookmarks predominantly for work related wikis that only I look at. I keep a few notes for organized bookmarks - and keep chrome bookmarks as a bookmark wasteland. All notes here are purely factually driven - and I archive things i no longer work on. I limit the number of active notes made here<p>I use Google docs predominantly ad a form of collaboration with others&#x2F;sharing or planning travel trips with friends etc. It&#x27;s mostly just a one time use doc for quickly iterating planning<p>My blog posts are for public works of reflection, which I start the writing process in a different note app. These are memorialized accomplishments<p>I use a physical notebook to learn from courses or break down concepts on paper. If I constantly retrieve it - I&#x27;ll create a blog post or a project based on those idea to reference later<p>My todo lists are just sticky notes on my paper and calendar reminders. I believe in keeping systems really simple so you don&#x27;t get into productivity gardening<p>Camera photos are also designed for me to forget things, but sometimes I print pictures and memorabilia to remember things.<p>In my case, some note apps are where ideas go to die - to feel comfortable in forgetting - to do a brain dump. Other apps were just there for organizing thoughts on paper for a short duration, or planning things out Collaboratively etc<p>I do have trouble remembering things long term sometimes because i use so many tools for different reasons. It becomes a crutch. Kind of how for people who rely heavily on GPS systems for driving won&#x27;t remember specific street names or how to navigate as easily without it
juliushuijnk将近 2 年前
happy user of my own (free, no ads, no account, all locally stored) android app Idea Growr, and I have ideas in there that are many years old that I revisit. including the first entry, Idea Growr itself.<p>Why let go of old ideas? in a year you&#x27;ll have a different perspective and a bad idea can become good or inspirational. I believe in quantity.<p>The app is for ideas only, so easy to retrieve. Most if not all my &#x27;pet projects&#x27; started inside that app.
husamia将近 2 年前
I thought about using twitter as notes app. they say it&#x27;s the new google. but I wish they didn&#x27;t hide my own notes from me
xmdx将近 2 年前
I just bookmarked the website to show others later and realized I just did it again. I will never go to that site again.
emoprincejack将近 2 年前
Jeez, notes are for remembering... how could anyone question that? What even is this article? I could not disagree more.
tpmx将近 2 年前
Bah humbug. The premise of this article is extremely shallow.<p>E.g. TextEdit.app (change default to plain text in settings) + saving text files to <i>one</i> particular directory with reasonable file names + regular maintenance (like twice a year) + Mac full text indexing&#x2F;search works pretty well for me.<p>The thing is: After 6 months it&#x27;s actually interesting to go through your old notes. The Finder preview makes it a matter of one keypress per file.
评论 #36145555 未加载
theycameback将近 2 年前
Finding the right process for keeping notes is as important as finding the right application&#x2F;tools IMHO
crvdgc将近 2 年前
In rare cases where I really need to remember something, I make an Anki card instead.
cynicalsecurity将近 2 年前
One of the most pretentious and nonsensical article I&#x27;ve ever read.
peter_retief将近 2 年前
This must be why there has never been a successful todo list app!
hiimshort将近 2 年前
This has been a challenge for me to overcome as well. Notes never really worked for me and, of course, simply remembering everything is neither possible nor productive. Personally, I&#x27;ve struck a middle ground that I&#x27;ve called [1]&quot;Boomerang Thoughts&quot;. The idea being that the default stance is to let ideas go, expecting the good, compelling ones to come back. It&#x27;s seemed to improve my ability to focus on important projects in the present and have a more limited, curated list of things that I am driven to act on next.<p>[1] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;bytesize.xyz&#x2F;boomerang-thoughts" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;bytesize.xyz&#x2F;boomerang-thoughts</a>
lawrencehook将近 2 年前
self promo: I made a notes app ;) lawrencehook.com&#x2F;ws<p>It&#x27;s a browser extension that lets you write sticky notes on top of websites.
langstonzac25将近 2 年前
That was very interest.
jwmoz将近 2 年前
Bookmarked this post.
chaostheory将近 2 年前
Ideas also die at the domain registrar
timacles将近 2 年前
Read the article waiting for some keen insight. Absolutely no coherent point made.