TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

CancelQuora

75 点作者 WhowasFired超过 1 年前

18 条评论

jfengel超过 1 年前
Huh. Interesting perspective. Quora has tried to reinvent itself several times, and coming to it during the pandemic has missed most of them.<p>Quora was founded by a bunch of Facebook refugees hoping to replicate the model of attracting a lot of users, [magic], profit. They were particularly intent that [magic] was not going to be &quot;show ads to eyeballs&quot;, and they tried lots of other things. Turns out there was a reason none of those other models were in use by anybody else. Some of them were truly horrifically bad (like paying people to ask questions, which produced exactly the crapflood you&#x27;d expect.)<p>So it&#x27;s in a funny position. They spent a ton of time attracting really good writers, some of who actually hang on. But monetization turned out to be exactly the same thing as every other social media site because that&#x27;s what works. They don&#x27;t think of themselves as social media... but they&#x27;re not really anything else.<p>Personally, I think the Q&amp;A format is fundamentally limited in that the low-hanging fruit gets picked early and what&#x27;s left is too specific to be answered meaningfully. StackOverflow manages it, by running itself on a shoestring, and being the definitive site for a specifically lucrative market (computer techies).<p>As it is, Quora&#x27;s next turn is towards AI, and they may end up ditching the human beings altogether. I see no sign that they&#x27;ve got any particular secret sauce for AI, but they&#x27;ve tried everything else.
评论 #37811404 未加载
评论 #37813854 未加载
评论 #37811179 未加载
fortran77超过 1 年前
In the early days of Quora, it was a lot of fun. I remember asking questions and getting answers from Olympic athletes, college professors, and other true experts.<p>I actually made friends on Quora.<p>Then they tried to monetize it in various ways (and I don&#x27;t mind paying for things!) and it went downhill fast. Just junk questions and answers, and a lot of fringe political ideas and topics, and people promoting their MLM businesses.
评论 #37811585 未加载
评论 #37811987 未加载
sparcpile超过 1 年前
Before Stackoverflow, they were pretty good. Once they started the anti-pattern of requiring registration to view answers, the quality went down hill pretty quick.<p>In the last few years, my workplace added them to their blocklist. I didn&#x27;t realize that one of the reasons was Quora is very spammy with emails.
评论 #37811087 未加载
评论 #37811202 未加载
theodric超过 1 年前
Somehow I ended up on Quora&#x27;s spam list, and despite my many requests, they refuse to unsubscribe me. What I see come through as the <i>subject</i> of those daily e-mails is a constant trickle of inflammatory pseudo-questions, and not infrequently paedo-&#x2F;incest-adjacent ragebait, intended to provoke engagement. Someone or some algo that someone owns is curating this crap and believes that it&#x27;s OK that it goes out as the &quot;face of the company&quot; to whoever is on their spam list.<p>Examples:<p>- 3 Sept: &quot;I caught my 13 year old daughter using pads for her period without my permission. What do I do now?&quot;<p>- 24 August: &quot;My 15-year-old son punched his pregnant baby sitter’s belly and she punched him back. She now has a miscarriage and my son has a bruise. Is she wrong for this?&quot;<p>- 23 August: &quot;My 15-year-old step daughter told me to wash her back in the shower. What should I do?&quot;<p>- 21 August: &quot;I caught my 14-year-old son and his friend’s 41 year old dad holding hands. Should I be concerned?&quot;<p>This site is garbage, and some of its users clearly are, as well. Go ahead and cancel it, for all I care.
评论 #37811489 未加载
评论 #37811134 未加载
skilled超过 1 年前
&gt; Quora is a hunk of shit to be avoided. Hopefully it will go under soon.<p>Unlikely. Google recently added more than 100M search traffic to Quora[0] (and Reddit, and LinkedIn and other garbage UGC sites) because they don&#x27;t know how to address the &quot;people appending reddit&quot; problem.<p>They literally threw legitimate content creators under the bus and are now _forcing_ searchers to go to Quora and all these are low-quality sites that, in the the majority of the cases, do nothing but link out to answers that are found in actual blogs&#x2F;articles.<p>[0]: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;i.imgur.com&#x2F;vZXHgBO.png" rel="nofollow noreferrer">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;i.imgur.com&#x2F;vZXHgBO.png</a>
评论 #37810692 未加载
评论 #37811748 未加载
spamizbad超过 1 年前
I can remember when both Quora and Stackoverflow (Stackexchange) were first on the scene, and it was interesting to see that battle unfold.<p>For me, it was the first time I noticed a cultural division between capital and labor. If you spoke to builders, Quora was a non-entity or seen as a joke; whereas Stackoverflow was a productivity supertool. However, when talking to VCs, influencers, and people &quot;up the food chain&quot; they saw far more potential in Quora. They didn&#x27;t look down on Stackoverflow, but they just saw it as another tool, like a screwdriver: very useful, but it was nothing more than a better mousetrap.<p>I suppose ultimately the Quora crowd was both right and wrong. Right in recognizing Stackexchange&#x27;s influence ceiling but wrong in recognizing Quora&#x27;s reach and impact. And I think, in part, it&#x27;s because Quora needed something that Stackoverflow had in spades: Quality content and a less hostile interface. Quora truly inherited the crown of Yahoo Answers, but unfortunately took all of its warts (low quality content) with it.
philihp超过 1 年前
The design of Quora is awful. It&#x27;s like Yahoo Answers, but instead of an inane unqualified answer, you get a dubious answer surrounded and camouflaged by answers to sponsored questions you didn&#x27;t ask.
评论 #37811474 未加载
hdarshane超过 1 年前
Quora probably had the most beautiful mechanism of all these Web 2.0 Social apps. you ask a question, and then there&#x27;s a good chance it reaches an authority in that particular subject and is subsequently answered. that&#x27;s incredible.<p>it&#x27;s not even about the monetisation part. imo it all went downhill when they started to allow incredibly low-quality content onto the site. I open my feed and it&#x27;s filled with stuff like &quot;what&#x27;s your favorite food&quot; &quot;what scares you&quot; &quot;what are some common tech hacks etc. etc&quot; it&#x27;s incredibly annoying.<p>I&#x27;m still pretty hopeful about Quora and I think they can still turn this around as there&#x27;s a sizeable population of subject experts on the website who keenly answer questions and share insights.<p>Quora&#x27;s one of these counter-intuitive cases when a product could&#x27;ve been better off with a dozen or so people working on a shoestring budget instead of raising venture capital and trying to do 10 things at once as they in fact did.
评论 #37811463 未加载
jasonlotito超过 1 年前
For those of you who have been here long enough, it is indeed 2023, and we are still talking about Quora. I just wanted to post this here because I know someone is going to completely wonder if it&#x27;s not a decade ago or more. Has anything changed? No, not really. You aren&#x27;t missing anything.<p>Maybe something has changed? Younger people who were only recently made aware of Quora are being roped in, and they are learning things we&#x27;ve taken for granted.<p>But you aren&#x27;t crazy, it&#x27;s 2023, and you can just ignore this. You already know the story.
chiefalchemist超过 1 年前
I was into Quora 10+ years ago. In fact in 2012 I made their Top Writers list. It was fun. It was exciting. It was interesting.<p>As they added features I lost interest. I go back from time to time. I don&#x27;t recognize it. Not sure if it&#x27;s good or bad. Maybe I&#x27;m not longer their target market? I just feels overwhelming and less quality driven. Just me?
评论 #37810591 未加载
评论 #37809872 未加载
ericflo超过 1 年前
Whenever I think of Quora, I think of their giant party in SF around a decade ago, which stands out in my mind as the height of that era of tech.
评论 #37811592 未加载
chollida1超过 1 年前
Oh, wow I dind&#x27;t know Quora was still around.<p>My experience with quora is probably like most peoples.<p>- You find out about quora<p>- read some interesting questions and get some answers that provide new insight and mental models that update how you think<p>- find some interesting and famous people replying to questions taht you read.<p>- Day 2 find out that there are just only so many interesting questions that can be asked and the site doesn&#x27;t have alot to bring you back.<p>- after a week, realize that this is a site that you&#x27;d want just a monthly summary of interesting questions and answers to read.<p>- after a few months realize that even that is too much as there just isn&#x27;t enough interesting content being generated to keep you interested.<p>You start to realize that most questions aren&#x27;t really that interesting.<p>one of the typical ones was &quot;what&#x27;s something that&#x27;s cool for rich people to do but trashy for poor people to do?&quot; and you realize very quickly that the answer is a very basic, everything.<p>And all the answers boil down to, the poor person does these things because they have to but the rich person can do these things and then go back to being rich.<p>&quot;Wear teh same clothes for a week&quot;. If you&#x27;re rich, you&#x27;re toughening up and becoming stoic, if you&#x27;re poor its because you have no choice.<p>The difference is always the rich person has a choice and can always just revert back to being rich at any time.<p>It&#x27;s not a bad site, but its the perfect example of a site that should be 4-5 people maintaining and running from an add supported boot strapped model.<p>If that site ever takes venture capital they&#x27;d be in trouble as there isn&#x27;t a revenue model that makes sense for such a small and niche site that I can see. They&#x27;d have to start locking answers behind a paywall or making certain &quot;luminaries&quot; answers pay only which would break the site.
评论 #37810593 未加载
评论 #37811848 未加载
booleandilemma超过 1 年前
Do people actually use Quora?
评论 #37810830 未加载
catlover76超过 1 年前
Most of us don&#x27;t use Quora for anything anyways, even if we did so in the past. It&#x27;s bad--what&#x27;s the big deal? Why does this merit a ranty blog post like this? The post comes across as kind of unhinged.
initramfs超过 1 年前
I tend to find more answers on stack Exchange &amp; Overflow.
shauryamanu超过 1 年前
Used Quora long back. Their feed is very hard to navigate.
commandlinefan超过 1 年前
No worse than reddit.
m1r超过 1 年前
The site has ZERO moderation. Everyday I find open calls of violence against specific groups and blatant misinformation.
评论 #37810906 未加载