TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Spacedrive – an open source cross-platform file explorer

348 点作者 microflash超过 1 年前

37 条评论

Klaster_1超过 1 年前
Decided to try it out. After the installation, it asks to "create the library", share the analytics and log in - not exactly what I expected compared to other file explorers. Next, I decided to navigate to a random directory on one of my drives. After double clicking, nothing happened. Opening a dir with a context menu action did nothing too. Turns out 15k files in a directory make it effectively non-navigable. Total Commander and Window Explorer have no such issues. Spacedrive still has to iron out the basic file explorer features, it seems.
评论 #37841998 未加载
评论 #37841740 未加载
评论 #37842434 未加载
评论 #37846780 未加载
reacharavindh超过 1 年前
I remember looking at it a good long time ago. They didn’t have release packages for me to play with so I told myself that I’d check it out later when they are ready. It looks like they released an alpha version an hour ago - hence this is on HN again.<p>It is a welcome concept. We have blurred the lines between strictly local files and all the cloud storage options these days. I personally maintain those boundaries and almost never mount cloud storage on my Mac, but my wife(as an academic) deals with Dropbox,iCloud drive, Google Drive and whatever Microsoft calls theirs, because the people she works with shares files through them and collaborate with reviews and such. If a solution like this can mask the vendor specific connection hiccups and quirks and provide a transparent file system that appears local but may be backed by $x cloud storage, that would be a nice boost to her workflow.<p>The key is the usability of such a tool. If the latencies are so high that it feels slower than Finder, then its chances are slim.
1udfx9cf8azi0超过 1 年前
Hacker News is not the best crowd for something like this. Everyone here most likely already has their own optimized workflow for something like this, including me.<p>This is probably best suited for digital creative types who use Windows and Mac and aren&#x27;t comfortable with the terminal. Animators, illustrators, video editors, 3d artists, music producers, youtubers, streamers, etc.<p>It&#x27;s not clear to me that that second group wants something like this. To be fair, from your marketing I have no idea what your software does and I doubt that group would either. I get that you&#x27;re trying to communicate this is a &quot;universal&quot; file experience but what does that mean in concrete terms? Users shouldn&#x27;t have to install your software to understand what it does. I also don&#x27;t see them caring that this is open source or works on Linux.<p>At this stage I would totally refresh the marketing and optimize it for that second group. Work with a PR person or marketing expert that understands how to concretely and efficiently communicate the value of what you are building to that second group. I would also take down the source repos and discontinue the Linux version (or keep it private for now, until there is demand) to save your team effort at this super early stage.<p>Good luck
nidnogg超过 1 年前
I&#x27;ve been keeping tabs on this for quite a while. Some feedback:<p>- Indexing one of my localdev directories has taken a robust 35+ minutes so far, and I will likely not wait until the end of it<p>- Like others have commented, latency is an issue (macOS M1 14inch base model). I&#x27;ve added a location and even there it sometimes takes 2-4 seconds after opening a folder to see any files<p>- Am I missing something or are there no tabs yet?<p>- Extremely lean (too much) in the ways of file sorting and grouping (non-existent), although I wager this will be worked upon during development<p>- It does feel like I have to do a lot of work to get to sensible indexing (add lots of locations by hand, and so forth)<p>- I know it&#x27;s local first, but the way telemetry and login work really does not sit right with me.<p>Overall I&#x27;m almost sure it&#x27;s not a fit for me, as interacting with it was a bit disappointing, but I can see an audience and there&#x27;s still ways to go. It looks really good. Best of luck!
评论 #37846011 未加载
lionkor超过 1 年前
Why is this written in React? I understand Rust doesn&#x27;t have any GUI frameworks (like Qt), but is this the way, then? Is it an adversity to learning something new?<p>You can reasonably write a C++ app or with Qt and write your GUI stuff in QML, and even plug in Lua, Python, or JavaScript as a scripting language. Yes, thats work.<p>Using a browser to render is just an easier version of using a GPU API like OpenGL to build your GUI. Your OS comes with gui stuff, use it.<p>Other than that, cool enough, though something like pcmanfm support adding remote locations as well...?<p>Another question, why Prisma?
评论 #37842352 未加载
评论 #37842464 未加载
ShamelessC超过 1 年前
It seems unlikely to me that this repository has as many GitHub stars as it does given the early alpha phase and plethora of (known) bugs. Further, you’re seemingly VC funded which is more confusing to me than langchain or pinecone getting funding- and those projects are AI based whereas your project is very well trod territory.<p>People won’t want this even if it’s free forever. They definitely won’t want it when ads, tracking or a monthly subscription become baked in.<p>Basically, I have no reason to trust you and lots of reasons to distrust you.<p>Nothing personal, but if you haven’t considered this perspective you might want to.
moelf超过 1 年前
The first screen after &quot;welcome&quot; is a login<p>why do I want to login a file explorer man this timeline is weird
评论 #37843725 未加载
评论 #37849032 未加载
jmbwell超过 1 年前
A searchable, browseable meta-index of all my disparate cloud and local, mounted and unmounted file repositories is certainly interesting and has been a bit of a holy grail for some time.<p>Digital Asset Management is nothing new, but it is not a category currently flush with options. Things like Portfolio and &lt;waves hands&gt; Adobe’s tangle of things offer a lot of this, with less emphasis on cloud repositories and more emphasis on workflow and metadata.<p>These days I would have to consider yet another cloud-dependent service very carefully. Self-hosted&#x2F;on-premises could be an absolute requirement, considering the potential sensitivity of “all files, including local and offline.” If accounts are required, I would want integration with existing identity management through OIDC or SAML (which, you know, does what this does but for accounts). I would also be looking at continuity facilities… if I build workflows around this and it becomes an essential single pane of glass over all my files, I’ll want to be confident in its availability.<p>Keep at it. Nobody has solved all this yet. Good luck!
评论 #37864922 未加载
getcrunk超过 1 年前
Project looks amazing! Love the ambition. Have a few notes.<p>1. Please have one clear toggle for any WAN access. And another one for sending analytics or any sort of usage data be OFF by default. Better yet make them compile time flags too. There was this new terminal called warp(?) that was so sexy but sent data over the net by default and that became a hard no for many.<p>2. Take some inspiration for Windirstat and everything. Especially everything. Use their search performance as a performance goal!<p>3. I noticed it in your road map but worth saying again. TABS!<p>4. Consider moving away from prisma. They really insulate you from your db and a lot of magic. And a part of me maybe unjustifiably is weary that they will do a license switch some day.
CivBase超过 1 年前
Can we stop treating &quot;written in Rust&quot; as a feature? It&#x27;s one of the first things in the README. Whenever I see that I don&#x27;t think &quot;more stable&quot;, I think &quot;someone&#x27;s pet project&quot;.
评论 #37849691 未加载
smcleod超过 1 年前
It’s a neat idea with potential - but why the need for a login? That makes it feel like my files are now someone else’s.
wongarsu超过 1 年前
I like the idea. The vision is similar to Window&#x27;s Explorer: seamless integration between offline files and online resources like Google Drive, Dropbox, OneDrive, Webdav, Samba, etc; fast, cached thumbnails; an indexer for fast search; encryption, backup etc. Of course in Windows Explorer all those features suck to varying degrees, some so hard they might as well not exist. So seeing an alternative implementation is nice, especially if it tries to take all these concepts even further. Most other file explorers stop far short of that vision.
EarthAmbassador超过 1 年前
Now if there is a way to identify dupes and consolidate, plus a way to instantly preview and dispatch photo libraries to new locations, these features would really answer the need to wrangle data.
评论 #37850219 未加载
darkest_ruby超过 1 年前
Can someone describe a proper usecase for this software? I couldn&#x27;t understand from the readme
评论 #37843018 未加载
评论 #37841608 未加载
评论 #37841694 未加载
评论 #37849306 未加载
quyleanh超过 1 年前
&gt; After 15 months of development we are extremely excited to be releasing the first version of Spacedrive as an early public alpha. [1]<p>[1] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;github.com&#x2F;spacedriveapp&#x2F;spacedrive&#x2F;releases&#x2F;tag&#x2F;0.1.0">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;github.com&#x2F;spacedriveapp&#x2F;spacedrive&#x2F;releases&#x2F;tag&#x2F;0.1...</a>
piyush_soni超过 1 年前
Ok, I don&#x27;t know if I&#x27;m doing it correctly, but there is no way to type some letters to jump to the folder starting with that name right? Also, no Cut&#x2F;Copy&#x2F;Paste&#x2F;Delete yet I guess. Also, the one reason I run away from Finder on macOS is that it has no way to set &#x27;Enter&#x27; to open or &#x27;Delete&#x27; to delete files, and refuses to simply add a &#x27;Cut&#x27; and paste option for files and folders (I know how to &#x27;Move&#x27; after &#x27;copying&#x27;, but that&#x27;s not the point, the point is that it&#x27;s just stupid). Please make sure you don&#x27;t do those mistakes. Keep whatever defaults you want, but at least have an option to enable &#x27;Cut&#x27;, &#x27;Open&#x27;, and &#x27;Delete&#x27; with their expected buttons.
Night_Thastus超过 1 年前
A file explorer that could work as a replacement for the Windows native one. You&#x27;ve got me interested. I am curious how much utility it has for those not needing the distributed parts. I&#x27;d also love to know if there&#x27;s any performance uplift or hit for typical operations, like opening folders with either many files, large files, or both.<p>I don&#x27;t suppose Spacedrive could (one day) show a &#x27;details&#x27; view, but with the column widths ALWAYS correct? I get tired of having to do &quot;size all columns to fit&quot; constantly. Especially because it only considers the rows that are currently visible. Drives me up a wall.
ysw0145超过 1 年前
A cross platform file explorer that has a nice UI and plugins is awesome. Many people have more 2 devices runing with different OS. But still, Web techs maybe not a good fit for system tools, for its heavy stack.
kwhitefoot超过 1 年前
I downloaded the .deb file and installed on Linux Mint 21.1 Vera on a Lenovo T460s<p>$ spacedrive spacedrive: error while loading shared libraries: libssl.so.1.1: cannot open shared object file: No such file or directory
评论 #37842356 未加载
Hamcha超过 1 年前
I don&#x27;t wanna rag on this project and all the bugs since it&#x27;s clearly in its super early days, but I keep wondering if there&#x27;s something I&#x27;m missing:<p>Why no miller columns? Not a question just to Spacedrive but really any file manager, it&#x27;s the main reason I pay and use OneCommander and it&#x27;s surprising to me how few of them actually implement it, everything else feels a downgrade to me.
评论 #37849058 未加载
miduil超过 1 年前
Super nice someone working through this, as it&#x27;s the perfect target for Tauri, the motivation inside the GitHub makes it an exciting project that goes beyond just a regular file browser.<p>Since it has some glorified web app functionality, a non-tauri web demo with a remote `core` daemon would be super nice.
评论 #37849090 未加载
netbioserror超过 1 年前
File explorers really should be one of the simplest tools available in a given desktop environment. Really, there are many tools getting the Electron treatment which should be vastly simpler than this insane upward ratchet of complexity JavaScript dominance has introduced into the equation.
Mockapapella超过 1 年前
Tried it out. Made an account. Looks like syncing between Mac and Windows at least isn&#x27;t working correctly, on the same network. Really like the idea and am eager to hear about future development.
aidenn0超过 1 年前
The HN title really buries the lede; perhaps the full title was too long?
apitman超过 1 年前
Anyone know how this compares to odrive[0]?<p>[0]: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.odrive.com&#x2F;homepage5b" rel="nofollow noreferrer">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.odrive.com&#x2F;homepage5b</a>
ehutch79超过 1 年前
Does this intentionally have almost the same icon as orbstack?
评论 #37851719 未加载
kwanbix超过 1 年前
I am a heavy user to Total Commander on Windows, and Double Commander everywhere else. I highly recommend both.
评论 #37853617 未加载
meatjuice超过 1 年前
I&#x27;ve been following the project for a long time but we still need to package the software by ourselves.
_1tan超过 1 年前
Finally, congrats on launching!
edrxty超过 1 年前
So what&#x27;s this get you over something like syncthing?
评论 #37841944 未加载
brianhorakh超过 1 年前
What is blocking android release. Keen to beta.
lbltavares超过 1 年前
spacedrive-bin on aur is exactly 69.69MB
unixhero超过 1 年前
I love the name.
tanaylakhani超过 1 年前
That&#x27;s a really neat product. Starred it.
woodylondon超过 1 年前
The old age problem of having an open project where people don&#x27;t understand what an alpha is.<p>You give this out to the world for feedback and people moan its not working.<p>I am old geek and back in the day you knew an Alpha was just for the playground to kick around - most likely will crash, worse case will destroy you PC but you have a play &#x2F; provide some feedback and wait for the next release.<p>A lot of other projects do everything in the dark and do a big ta da at the end - and missed the opportunity for the community of &quot;alpha&quot; or &quot;beta&quot; testers to provide some feedback along the way.<p>Keep going - its added to my list to take look once in beta as I prefer to play in that playground rather than the alpha one these days.<p>I like the idea!
评论 #37842934 未加载
评论 #37847184 未加载
评论 #37849519 未加载
sandebert超过 1 年前
It seems to me that an alternative could be to simply pair FUSE with any standard file explorer.<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;github.com&#x2F;libfuse&#x2F;libfuse">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;github.com&#x2F;libfuse&#x2F;libfuse</a><p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;github.com&#x2F;libfuse&#x2F;libfuse&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Filesystems">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;github.com&#x2F;libfuse&#x2F;libfuse&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Filesystems</a>
评论 #37842676 未加载
评论 #37842666 未加载
评论 #37844323 未加载
评论 #37843840 未加载
评论 #37849532 未加载
hobofan超过 1 年前
It was kind of inevitable that after VC-funded terminals, mail clients, launchers sooner or later there would be file explorer.<p>As someone on Linux (popOS), I also gladly welcome it, as even the best file explorer I know (nemo) could use niceties that you find on Windows or macOS.<p>I&#x27;m highly skeptical of the economics of it though. The only way I would see it working out, if their planned &quot;sync&quot; product would be able to overcome the entrenchment of iCloud&#x2F;OneDrive&#x2F;Dropbox, which seems like a tall order. As a user I&#x27;d pay ~$50&#x2F;year, but that would take a lot of customers to sustain even the current team size.
评论 #37842174 未加载
评论 #37842253 未加载
评论 #37842637 未加载
评论 #37845286 未加载
评论 #37849525 未加载