I actually did find the "nightmare dilemmas" on the site more interesting.<p><a href="http://www.thebigquestions.com/2012/03/22/another-nightmare/" rel="nofollow">http://www.thebigquestions.com/2012/03/22/another-nightmare/</a><p>--------------------------------<p>--------------------------------<p>Today’s Dilemma
In front of you are two childless married couples. For some reason, it’s imperative that you kill two of the four people. Your choices are:<p>A. Kill one randomly chosen member from each couple.
B. Kill both members of a randomly chosen couple.<p>All four people agree that if they die, they want to be well remembered. Therefore all four ask you, please, to choose A so that anyone who dies will be remembered by a loving spouse.<p>If you care about the four people in front of you, what should you do?<p>--------------------------------<p>Argument 1. For goodness’s sake, they’ve told you what to do. If you care about them, of course you should respect their wishes. Choose A.<p>Argument 2.Once the killings are over, Option A leaves two grieving spouses, whereas Option B leaves one relieved couple. Surely two dead plus two happy is better than two dead plus two sad. Choose B.<p>Which argument do you buy? And what’s wrong with the other one?<p>--------------------------------