TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Landlines are dying out. But to some, they're a lifeline

35 点作者 grubbs大约 1 年前

6 条评论

dghughes大约 1 年前
Here in SE Canada my 85 year-old uncle has a land line phone and it&#x27;s been there forever it was there when his mom my grandmother lived there for 65 years.<p>Hurricane Fiona hit my region and all the phones eventually died cellphones, new landline &quot;voip&quot; (I guess?) but not my uncle&#x27;s phone. It was the old style wired directly to the exchange a few blocks away.<p>I lost power for nearly two weeks he didn&#x27;t. My home land line is the newer type not the old style so the modem had no power. My cellphone lasted a few days but the cell towers ran out of fuel for the generators.<p>I was completely isolated communication-wise for about a week and a half. If I had the old land line type I would have had a phone.
评论 #39878365 未加载
评论 #39878609 未加载
评论 #39878162 未加载
wrp大约 1 年前
Landlines also have greatly better sound quality. Having a conversation is so much nicer when both ends are on a landline.
m463大约 1 年前
I&#x27;ve noticed a new apartment complex nearby has gbit ethernet included with each apartment (you have to pay them), and you can&#x27;t put in your own cable&#x2F;phone&#x2F;etc
评论 #39878360 未加载
fortran77大约 1 年前
My 91 year old mother can&#x27;t use her cellphone well, the user interface of even the simplest flip phone confounds her. She forgets to charge it, loses the charger, etc.<p>I don&#x27;t know what she&#x27;d do without a landline. It&#x27;s already become much less reliable because the NY Telephone company doesn&#x27;t care about the old copper lines so we switched to sevice over FIOS. If the battery in the main unit fails--and she can&#x27;t hear the beep that warns that the backup battery needs to be replaced--her phone goes dead.
评论 #39879578 未加载
评论 #39878846 未加载
评论 #39878620 未加载
bitwize大约 1 年前
My parents&#x27; &quot;landline&quot; has 5G backhaul now. Landlines are like X11: vanishingly few people know how to maintain them, and nobody wants to anymore.
评论 #39878199 未加载
评论 #39878430 未加载
throwaway8526大约 1 年前
The constant attempts&#x2F;threats&#x2F;path toward removing landlines can be quite troubling. I know rants are discouraged. So, please don&#x27;t read the below as overly ranty; it&#x27;s just an attempt to detail and characterize some concerns, really.<p>If power or internet goes out, wired VOIP phones won&#x27;t work. Both the power and the internet have way worse reliability than the copper wire telephone where I live in a top 1% part of California.<p>If cell phone service goes out (or if cell phone batteries get exhausted and can&#x27;t be recharged), then mobile phones won&#x27;t work.<p>A landline is a very, very reasonable &quot;emergency line&quot; or even &quot;regular line&quot;. The data and power connection to it will not be unexpectedly severed, for the most part.<p>I can very easily imagine an &quot;extended outage&quot; for whatever reason of power, internet, and&#x2F;or mobile phone service, take your pick. In any of these cases, I would expect to basically be able to use the landline phone to call a relative, friend or co-worker pretty much anywhere in the world. Ok, maybe some disasters take out copper wire telephones, or maybe sometimes copper wire telephones have issues (rare but possible), but this is still a pretty good backup&#x2F;emergency&#x2F;constant connection.<p>If you really have got your sh* together, you have a landline, IMO.<p>There is a copper contact running all the way to some box, and to some substation, which has utility-managed diesel backup generators and switching and all that jazz. I don&#x27;t care if it&#x27;s digital and so forth behind the scenes. It&#x27;s managed! It works from their system to mine, end of story.<p>We have a residential elevator. It has a phone line for emergencies, like if you get stuck in the elevator by yourself. That goes to a copper wire telephone wire. I do NOT want to rely on the unreliable California power utility to not have a scheduled or unscheduled outage, causing the elevator fail, and also shutting off power to a cable box powering some VOIP service. Really?<p>Sure, I could add backup batteries. Sure, I could add automatic diesel power generators. But, the phone company already has those! Do I need a secondary and&#x2F;or tertiary ISP as backup as well, and somehow join them together? (Some will say, &quot;yes, of course&quot;.)<p>What are they going to do next, ban standard incandescent light bulbs? Oh, wait, they already did that! Alexander Graham Bell and Thomas Edison must be spinning in their graves!<p>I get the idea is to cut costs or something, but I think this is a safety issue, no?<p>If we can&#x27;t have real light bulbs, and we can&#x27;t have real telephones lines, is there a name for that? We used to have more or less &quot;additive&quot; technologies. A new one would go add to the list of available technologies, not really fully replacing any. Just adding to the list of what you can readily have&#x2F;do. But this concept of &quot;removing&quot; solid technologies for arguably &quot;worse&quot; ones--I think it&#x27;s not merely enshittification. This seems like a whole &#x27;nother branch of weird.<p>Maybe there&#x27;s some state that will reverse some of this stuff; one can hope, can&#x27;t one?<p>If you use one or more copper lines: what is your plan for the post-telephone-line world, if it comes to it?
评论 #39835302 未加载
评论 #39878127 未加载
评论 #39878266 未加载
评论 #39878273 未加载
评论 #39840018 未加载
评论 #39877918 未加载
评论 #39835788 未加载
评论 #39916920 未加载
评论 #39877986 未加载