TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Ask HN: Tablets vs. Laptops? What do other HN parents give their kids?

3 点作者 nunodonato大约 1 年前
I&#x27;m looking for opinions from other parents on whether kids are better off using a laptop or a tablet.<p>My 8-year-old daughter currently uses an old laptop running Linux for basic internet browsing, searching for information, and some email practice to help with her reading and writing skills. While the laptop provides a more traditional computing experience, I can&#x27;t help but feel that she&#x27;s missing out on a lot of great educational apps and the convenience&#x2F;portability of a tablet.<p>On the laptop, it&#x27;s been great for teaching her keyboard skills, file management basics, and getting exposure to a desktop OS environment. One advantage of laptops is the ability to teach some fundamental technology skills like coding. With a laptop, there&#x27;s more potential for hands-on learning about how software and operating systems really work under the hood.<p>However, most kids&#x27; apps and games seem better suited for tablets these days. Not to mention tablets are more portable and have a lower risk of damage if dropped. There&#x27;s a concern that tablets keep kids more in a &quot;consumer&quot; role, while laptops can serve as an entry point into creating technology versus just consuming it.<p>For those with kids around this age range, what has your experience been? Do you feel there are benefits to keeping them on a laptop for now to cement technology skills? Or do the educational apps and portability of tablets outweigh that? Maybe a hybrid approach with both devices is ideal?<p>Of course, this also greatly depends on the kids. And, truth be told, my daughter really hasn&#x27;t picked up and significant interest in tech&#x2F;coding, so I&#x27;m kinda considering that maybe this wasn&#x27;t the best option for her. Adding to that, we recently got an electric piano into our home and she loves it. I realized that there are some great &quot;learn piano&quot; apps for tablets...<p>I&#x27;m really interested to hear different perspectives from other parents. Any insights would be appreciated!

3 条评论

Dalewyn大约 1 年前
Desktops including laptops are for both productivity and consumption.<p>Tablets are primarily only for consumption.<p>My advice? Provide your kids with both (assuming your budget allows) and let them decide which (or both?!) they want to spend more time on. Make sure they are the real deal though, not some kneecapped toys. Also don&#x27;t railroad them onto just Linux or Windows or whatever, rather give them the opportunity to see everything the computing world has to offer so they can decide themselves.<p>Anecdata: Mom and dad got me an entire Pentium 1 desktop tower (circa mid-1990s) running Windows 95 as a (small!) kid to do whatever I want with after I&#x27;d showed great interest in their desktop tower running Windows 3.11 for work, because dad always says kids should get to play with real things rather than toys. I will forever appreciate it because only a few kids ever get opportunities to just dive in to something like that.
eimrine大约 1 年前
I agree with your approach from first to last word. I use to teach kids programming and I work only with those ones who agree to do their homework and everything else on cheap Linux laptop provided by me. &quot;Smart&quot;phones are not helpful in learning stuff at all because their providers want us to learn their ecosystem instead of the other stuff.<p>Another insight is to insist learning Dvorak instead of qwerty, that will be more beneficial in the young age. 8 yo can do it in less than 2 weeks or 10 hours of training.<p>Electric instrumensts are great because of pedals, automatization and easy recording. What about games, try to introduce the kid to cryptocurrency trading, IMO this counts as a modern cool game.
评论 #40208915 未加载
okokwhatever大约 1 年前
Interesting question of yours. My vision about it is: It&#x27;s not the tool, it&#x27;s the use case.<p>I always tell to my kids to be creators not to be consumers. If they find at any point in their life a tablet works better for them because of the form factor to create, learn or whatever it&#x27;s good enough for me too.
评论 #40208803 未加载