TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

A teacher did all he could to keep kids off phones

35 点作者 wannacboatmovie大约 1 年前

14 条评论

banish-m4大约 1 年前
When I was in school, laptops and calculators weren&#x27;t allowed except at certain times and circumstances.<p>The problem is parents and schools must support teachers in screen bans by checking devices into &quot;phone lockers&quot; or a &quot;phone concierge&quot;.<p>A classroom isn&#x27;t conducive to maintaining order and focus with the presence of addictive distractions.
评论 #40401850 未加载
评论 #40401596 未加载
评论 #40401601 未加载
评论 #40401610 未加载
评论 #40401559 未加载
smogcutter大约 1 年前
Speaking as a teacher, the primary things happening here are:<p>1) remote school taught developing brains that when something is difficult or boring you can just check out and play on your phone. For many, it’s not that they don’t want to learn but that they literally <i>don’t know how</i>. This is something that’s difficult for adults who don’t work with children (and some who do) to wrap their heads around. They aren’t just miniature adults.<p>2) This is a failure of the school administration to set consistent rules &amp; expectations. If other teachers and school admin don’t enforce a rule, it’s nearly hopeless to try and be the one teacher who does.<p>As an aside, unfortunately it’s really difficult to have worthwhile public conversations about ed policy. It’s like the story of the blind men and the elephant. Everyone’s got their personal experience as students and parents, wrapped up with all kinds of emotions, memories, ego, politics, etc. Comparatively very few have any experience regularly interacting with children who aren’t their own, let alone attempting to teach them.
评论 #40404711 未加载
arrowsmith大约 1 年前
I find some of these stories astonishing. When I was in school ~15 years ago, if the teacher caught you using your phone in class he didn&#x27;t &quot;ask&quot; you to give it to him, nor did he deduct &quot;participation points&quot;, whatever that means. He just confiscated the device, and you&#x27;d be lucky to get it back within a week. Rules were rules.<p>Also this teacher is complaining about students putting their headphones on during class? What? That kind of behaviour was unthinkable in my school. If I had done that I would have gotten in <i>serious</i> trouble.<p>Haven&#x27;t these educators heard of &quot;discipline&quot;?
评论 #40402800 未加载
chasing大约 1 年前
I dunno, man. I get the frustration, but part of me also feels like this guy is banging his against against a cultural change and just giving up. Rock music. Cable TV. Video games. The Internet. iPhones. Every generation has that thing their parents generation think is ruining them.<p>I have a hard time believing he can’t simply ban their active use in class. If he can’t for some bureaucratic reason, then maybe he needs to figure out how to get educational value out of the situation. Have them do TikTok videos explaining biology topics. Who knows. Times are changing. Gotta change with them…
评论 #40402135 未加载
aurizon大约 1 年前
Schools can use passive Faraday walls&#x2F;floors&#x2F;ceilings. Metal fly screen works quite well. Common aluminum extruded windows, work fine. The brick needs to be shielded, and aluminium foil inserted as an inner layer is very good. In effect a metal &#x27;balloon&#x27; has to be erected so all RF is blocked. I have seen very good shielded enclosures with transparent Faraday windows(not screens) that would use the same clear shielding layer. Quite good stuff, I have used a few of them. Screen is cheap and OK for cellular, but if you want 500+ Ghz blocked, screen is not good enough. Read about it here (no connection to me at all)<a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;jretest.com&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;jretest.com&#x2F;</a> It is easy and cheap to build a faraday plane in the construction phase, with a layer of screen&#x2F;foil made where needed, at a fairly low cost. I see many cases of exam cheating that could be Faradayed out of existence by a wooden frame screen room set up for the exam at whatever size needed. No jamming or emission interruption that would break FCC laws. In fact the cheaters are breaking more laws and I can suggest a few RFI &#x27;sniffers&#x27; like this from JREtest would find emitters. <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;jretest.com&#x2F;product&#x2F;jre-sta-1&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;jretest.com&#x2F;product&#x2F;jre-sta-1&#x2F;</a> At $550 a school could buy one for each invigilator to use to detect cheats as each one will last 10 years or so so the cost per exam approaches zero. A little chat with the owner of JREtest might find he can sense a market and he can work with a school to find the optimal build for that task, because there is a global market for a few hundred thousand RFI Turko-Sniffers every year...
评论 #40402157 未加载
ChrisArchitect大约 1 年前
Source article: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.wsj.com&#x2F;tech&#x2F;personal-tech&#x2F;a-teacher-did-all-he-could-to-keep-kids-off-phones-hes-quitting-in-frustration-753061ca" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.wsj.com&#x2F;tech&#x2F;personal-tech&#x2F;a-teacher-did-all-he-...</a>
tootie大约 1 年前
My oldest is at a pubic STEM school that requires an aptitude test for admission, so maybe a self-selecting bunch, but teachers give kids in-class and at-home assignments that require phones or laptops. Assignments are mostly turned in via Google Classroom. A lot will assign youtube videos to watch. One has his own channel with a substantial number of subscribers. They let kids use a graphing calculator app instead of spending $100 on a ti-82. Kids being distracted on their phones probably would have been doodling or passing notes 30 years ago. I think just leaning in at this point is the only plausible option.
deadbabe大约 1 年前
Is it time to start designing schools so that the buildings are basically faraday cages that block all cell signals? And definitely no Wi-Fi.<p>Yea I know parents might cry “I need to be in contact with my child at ALL times”. But no you don’t and in the public education system you shouldn’t even have a choice, if you need something call the school someone will pick up on a landline and deliver your message. And if there’s a school shooting oh well if your kid dies they die so hug them tightly every morning like it’s the last.<p>Otherwise I just don’t see any way out of this problem.
EricE大约 1 年前
No child left behind was the most disastrous cancer to infect public education. We should absolutely segregate the kids who don&#x27;t want to learn from those who do, instead of dumbing them all down.
评论 #40401581 未加载
评论 #40401657 未加载
评论 #40401597 未加载
评论 #40407930 未加载
derwiki大约 1 年前
While I can identify with the plight, and want to keep my kid as phone-addiction free as possible.. I spent a lot of time using my TI-86 in high school. I got really good at Tetris, learned a bunch of TI-BASIC, and some z80. It was only ever something I did when I was bored&#x2F;knew I wasn’t missing anything, but I guess I’d be saying the same about using my phone if I was a high schooler today.
kkfx大约 1 年前
Actually, for smart kids, I have an answer: give the desktop, FLOSS, teach them how to use their own environment. They&#x27;ll find mobile incredibly crappy, limited and limiting they do not develop much interest for it.<p>Oh, yes, this assume there is money, space, knowledge etc to give a real desktop per child.
评论 #40408798 未加载
talldayo大约 1 年前
&gt; “Now, you can ask them, bug them, beg them, remind them and try to punish them and still nothing works,” he says.<p>If a teacher from the 1700s could read this I&#x27;d wager they wouldn&#x27;t even need to see a cellphone to agree.
Hizonner大约 1 年前
Yeah, so if half your kids are failing your class, that&#x27;s a you problem. Especially if half everybody else&#x27;s kids are <i>not</i>.
karlgkk大约 1 年前
&gt; “I would walk up to kids and say, ‘Give me your phone,’ and they would clutch it, and I would say that’s what an alcoholic would do if you tried to take away their bottle,” he says.<p>I agree there is a problem; but, how wildly condescending that is to say to someone.
评论 #40401620 未加载
评论 #40401555 未加载
评论 #40401599 未加载