TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Ask HN: Is fulfilling but lower-paying work worth it?

4 点作者 pcloadletter_12 个月前
Find myself resenting my big tech job and wondering if it is worth it to look at doing more noble work like non-profit or even government services. Is the grass just greener?

15 条评论

beezlebroxxxxxx12 个月前
It depends. Low paying but fulfilling can come about in a lot of different ways. Benefits can exist in other ways than pay. Many low paying jobs are nonetheless prestigious, highly sought after, and fulfilling, because they have lots of benefits that exist outside of the pay. Many &#x27;elite&#x27; cultural jobs are an example.<p>But you could also end up in low paying and fulfilling that nonetheless make it hard to live off of. Ironically, again, many &#x27;elite&#x27; cultural jobs are an example. There is a reason why, in general, people from wealthy families end up working in those jobs. Sometimes they aren&#x27;t even advertised. Other times they don&#x27;t pay at all. Your average lower-middle class person can only work in low paying non-profit cultural jobs so long before taking an exit ramp for the for-profit world and higher pay.<p>Non-profit work is extremely org and team dependant. Lots of orgs will take advantage of people doing non-profit work. They will use the idea of &#x27;doing good&#x27; as an excuse to force overtime, pile stress on people, and use theoretical better pay as a carrot on the end of a stick. Non-profits can also be extremely donor dependant, which is a side of the &#x27;industry&#x27; that leaves a sour-taste in many mouths; there&#x27;s a lot of sucking up to wealthy people.<p>Government work can be extremely fulfilling and, relative to the median wage of people in America, can actually be quite well paid. The benefits are usually also amazing. It can also be slow, bureaucratic to levels you simply cannot believe, and depressing, however; working in government requires a certain mindset and expectations that some people simply don&#x27;t have.
muzani12 个月前
My theory is there&#x27;s a bell curve. The bottom end is the zone where you&#x27;re using WhatsApp as source control. The top end is where you&#x27;re competing (yes, competing) with people who easily got a double degree at Harvard and MIT.<p>The middle is just nice. There&#x27;s a lot of these curves though. If you can only work in Japan, then there&#x27;s probably a top tier Japanese company that absolutely sucks, and it&#x27;s probably easier to get an O-1 visa for some mid tier job in the US or something. There&#x27;s also some overlap between top tier tech giant and lower-mid tier startup founder. Lots of people do startups because it&#x27;s easier to sell a company for $30m than get a $1m salary.<p>I think Ask HN lies on the upper end of the curve which is why you see &quot;how do I deal with burnout&quot; posts every other month, or cynical responses by clearly intelligent people (key symptoms of burnout). So keep that in mind. Reddit is probably squarely in the middle globally and you&#x27;ll get different job advice.<p>When I came up with this theory, I was in a group that was saying $50k annual is being too ambitious and they should stick to a $36k job.
评论 #40419488 未加载
h2odragon12 个月前
Depends on what you&#x27;re bringing to the table. Having a lifetime&#x27;s effort stolen from you by a nonprofit hurts as much as it would if they were a traditional company.<p>Sure &quot;it was good to do the works we did&quot; helps. And them bastards walked off with hundreds of thousands of dollars whilst others burnt their health running the shop on a shoestring.
toldyouso202212 个月前
From what I gathered + my personal experience, most of the times not only low pay work pays less but it sucks too. I think it applies to gov and non-profit too
ActorNightly12 个月前
From a purely objective standpoint, working at Big Tech and saving every possible cent until you have like 1-2 years worth of expenses saved up, is the most optimal strategy. You end up with a lot of flexibility so you can try different things if you feel burned out.<p>From a psychological point of view, fulfillment usually comes from doing something that is challenging, which means that the challenge has to align with what you perceive as value, which is a very personal thing. If work takes up a significant chunk of your time and energy, but its something that you don&#x27;t see as valuable, you are probably going to burn out.<p>However, depending on your skill level and ability to figure out how to move internally to better teams, big tech work can be very easy, which means you aren&#x27;t going to get burned out, which gives you both money and time to do things that are valuable.<p>For example, I used to work in Amazon, standard team that owned a few backend services. I dunno if it was just me, but I never had a hard time implementing features in fraction of the time that everyone else did, mostly because I knew and understood things beyond code (like for example, nobody on my team even knew that you could capture traffic with tcpdump and see the json request and responses directly). So as a result, I only did about 6 hours of actual work per week, but my &quot;output&quot; was the same or greater than teammates. Never got burnt out. My current job is pretty much the same pay, just actually part time contractually, because I really wanted to focus on improving my fitness for longevity which takes a bunch of dedicated planning and training - and this is the part that is challenging for me that I also find great value in.
desperatecuban12 个月前
Try low-paying and unfulfilling. I make $800 a month writing cruds and dealing with awful legacy code.
toast012 个月前
It all depends on if you personally have a realized concept of enough, and if the noble work can pay you your level of enough.<p>If your noble work won&#x27;t satisfy your desires for pay, then that&#x27;s going to cause stress and resentment, and the fulfillment won&#x27;t be enough, IMHO. There&#x27;s also the possibility that your noble work is a real drag. I&#x27;d strongly prefer a not particularly noble job where I can work the way that works best for me over a noble job where I had to work in ways I don&#x27;t like.
Desafinado12 个月前
What do you care more about? Money or purpose?<p>For some people, money is the only thing in their field of vision. For others, spending their lives making a positive impact carries more, and real, weight.<p>Speaking as someone who works for the public sector, making moderately good money and helping real people everyday, I can tell you that I&#x27;d much prefer that to working for FAANG. Actually, I wouldn&#x27;t be caught dead working for Meta.<p>It depends on who you are and what you value.
romerocarlos12 个月前
Whether fulfilling but lower-paying work is worth it depends on your individual circumstances, priorities, and values. The decision depends on your individual situation and what you value most in your life and career. It&#x27;s essential to carefully weigh the pros and cons and consider both short-term and long-term implications before making a decision.
bilsbie12 个月前
Generally higher pay is better. It comes with more dignity and better treatment. As an extreme I tried volunteering and they didn’t value our time at all and didn’t even provide enough resources for everyone to work so half the people were waiting around.<p>I’d actually prefer a 500K per year job with 450 going to charity than an 80k job.
helph6712 个月前
I would expect that it could provide significant benefits for your long term health. Altruism can work that way. <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Altruism" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Altruism</a>
shivc12 个月前
If you get paid enough to cover your expenses and have very little let over but the work is fulfilling then 100%<p>But if it causes anxiety about bills every couple of weeks then very soon the work stops being fulfilling.<p>IMHO
markus_zhang12 个月前
If it is fulfilling then definitely yes. But we need to make sure that it is really fulfilling and you don&#x27;t have financial trouble after switching jobs.
atmosx12 个月前
It&#x27;s a spectrum. Where you sit on that spectrum, at any given point in time, depends on your situation. No one can answer that for you.
austin-cheney12 个月前
Yes!!