TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Moral implications of being moderately successful computer scientist and a woman

64 点作者 thread_id9 个月前

18 条评论

BeefySwain9 个月前
When I read things like this it feels like reading fiction. Not because I don&#x27;t believe it (I do), but because it is so far from my lived experience or anything I have perceived.<p>It makes me wonder if I just so happen to run in circles that are ostensibly devoid of misogyny or if I am blind to it.
评论 #41464072 未加载
评论 #41463642 未加载
评论 #41463559 未加载
评论 #41463785 未加载
评论 #41463607 未加载
dunno74569 个月前
&gt; For example, my very existence as a moderately young, moderately successful computer scientist threatens some men’s sense of identity, thus making them uncomfortable and&#x2F;or lash out.<p>I&#x27;m not a woman, but I faced this soooo many times in my career that now I believe that it&#x27;s just insecure men feeling threatened by other people&#x27;s knowledge or capabilities. Usually these people are hiding something and they are not as smart as perceived. Having someone in the room that can potentially unmask that makes them insecure.<p>You have to address the behavior the first time it occurs by establishing boundaries otherwise it keeps happening more and more.<p>And that is a leadership&#x2F;management failure to address these behaviors. In all occasions the insecure men were so loud and obnoxious that management prefers not to deal with it and take the easy route by firing the target of the abuse, reinforcing the behavior more and more.
评论 #41470227 未加载
scott_w9 个月前
The title initially put me off but I’m glad I read this article as it reminds me that the work isn’t even close to finished when it comes to equality in our field.<p>And of course the first two comments on the article proved the article’s point…
评论 #41463496 未加载
dailykoder9 个月前
This needs more upvotes and is a lot more important than apples latest iphone or the newest AI feature.<p>I can&#x27;t judge any of this because I won the gene lottery and don&#x27;t have to deal with problems like that. It just baffles me that there are humans who get treated like that.
cjbgkagh9 个月前
“The reason that university politics is so vicious is because stakes are so small.” Henry Kissinger<p>Many things kept me out of academia but the number one was not wanting to spent my life arguing with people who do little else. The politics in these orgs are insane and it would be of no surprise that the petty assholes are also misogynistic. But take away the misogyny and they’re still petty assholes which while less bad still isn’t very good. I’m not sure how to fix it. I think this structure of research org is not destined to last anyway so the point is probably moot. Perhaps we will see an era of independent scientists.
评论 #41464694 未加载
nxpnsv9 个月前
A short, worthwhile read. A mostly irrelvant comment: I think that when writing, it is fine to use ≠ and =. We can be reasonably sure that = means equals and not assignment.
Sakos9 个月前
&gt; Men, do better! If you are in a position of power and want to be an ally, educate yourself by reading Entitled [3] and doing training on inclusive governance [5]. Even if you think you are a nice guy, there are plenty of other guys out there that are not so nice and dealing with the aftermath is much worse than preventing the harassment in the first place<p>I find statements like this frustrating. I do all I can to counter-act sexist behaviour and speech around me. There&#x27;s not much else I can do. I&#x27;m not in a position of power. The people who need to do better are never going to read this and they aren&#x27;t going to care. So they continue being assholes and I continue to get to share in the blame. It&#x27;s just demoralising. Whatever I do is never enough.
评论 #41466295 未加载
评论 #41464230 未加载
mr_mitm9 个月前
I had a short consulting gig in Istanbul once. The meeting room that became my temporary office was right next to their dev department. To my surprise, it was almost entirely comprised by women, including the department manager. I wonder if that was a fluke and if it wasn&#x27;t, what is the reason why computer science is dominated by men in our culture.
评论 #41463743 未加载
评论 #41463715 未加载
benterix9 个月前
Having read the article, I still can&#x27;t relate to the choice of the adjective in the title and subtitles (&quot;moral&quot;). The author also uses the term &quot;moral framework&quot; for some outdated views. These are societal stereotypes and expectations, not moral norms or frameworks. Can someone explain this particular word choice?
评论 #41463515 未加载
JackSlateur9 个月前
Many of this also applies to men, as individuals. Or maybe I am an exception ?
te_chris9 个月前
Excellent piece. Read and absorb, then consider, fellow men.
throw383848489 个月前
Articles like this are the reason why I become nonbinary. It is the only way not to be part of patriarchy, and not to oppress anyone!
评论 #41466842 未加载
评论 #41463578 未加载
评论 #41463650 未加载
评论 #41463597 未加载
评论 #41463805 未加载
semiinfinitely9 个月前
insightful article but I can never tell whether this line is sarcasm:<p>&gt; because men are famously good at emotional self-regulation
评论 #41463352 未加载
评论 #41463592 未加载
评论 #41463566 未加载
bbarnett9 个月前
I have zero issues with raising this sort of dialog, and shining light into cracks that shouldn&#x27;t exist.<p>One problem I have though, is presumed sexism. An example is, this article states:<p><i>Now that I have managed to make men feel embarrassed and insecure, they blame these feelings on me. No one else has made them feel this way before, and because men are famously good at emotional self-regulation, I must be the problem.</i><p>Now first, I 100% agree than in <i>some cases</i> there may be an innate, sexist response here. <i>Some</i> cases. But at the same time, <i>men arguing with men</i> can elicit a response in this way! &quot;No, you&#x27;re at fault for challenging my ideas! And successfully! How <i>dare</i> you!&quot;<p>My point is, I very much believe some of these interactions are laced with sexism, even unrealised or unknown to those perpetrating the act. Yet at the same time, it can just be two humans interacting, and one taking the outcome poorly. Again as a male, I&#x27;ve seen this type of response when established ideas are challenged... including the established hierarchy in a workplace somehow blaming me. Often, I&#x27;ve been told I was too &quot;blunt&quot;, or that I &quot;shouldn&#x27;t publicly embarrass someone&quot;. Meanwhile, that embarrassment was derived from someone <i>trying to shut me down</i>, and I simply responded moderately in kind, with fact, not emotion.<p>(I&#x27;m a contractor, so I engage in new workspaces often, as a being not integrated into the social structure of that workplace.)<p>I&#x27;m sure this has happened to all of us. Human interaction is not an API with strict protocols. It&#x27;s very squishy.<p>Another issue here is that some humans are just assholes. We&#x27;ve all met them. In such people their assholish behaviour comes out as whatever is most direct and upsetting. With a woman, it&#x27;s probably targeted as sexism, a place to &quot;hang their attack&quot; on. With a man, it&#x27;s still there... just personal attacks of a different narrative. You can almost see such asshat&#x27;s brains working, trying to find the best button to push, the best place to lay a personal attack... because <i>that&#x27;s all they have</i>.<p>I guess what I&#x27;m saying is, if you&#x27;re a woman and currently being hit with what appears to be a sexist narrative, try to keep in mind the &quot;asshole&quot; component, or &quot;things that seem sexist but are just people interacting poorly&quot; aren&#x27;t sexism.<p>And I say that fully without blame. Any human hit over and over and over with something such as sexism, is going to naturally default to this as a reason. But when I read articles like this one, where the dialog is <i>patriarchy</i> and <i>innate male culture</i>, it really doesn&#x27;t help. It doesn&#x27;t help, because many men do their best to police such behaviour around them, and in themselves.<p>And there are more of us than you think.<p>If there weren&#x27;t, all of the attempts at legislating equality would never have happened.<p>So take some solace in this, if you&#x27;re a woman. We&#x27;re trying. Some of us, in fact many of us are, so much so that we try to pass laws, we try to stamp things out.<p>Take comfort to know it&#x27;s not all of us.
评论 #41463771 未加载
评论 #41466885 未加载
cmilton9 个月前
This reads like a male hit piece. It seems the author’s goal is to fight misogyny with misandry. Pot meet kettle?<p>Gender nor race are requirements for these experiences. They likely emerge from corporate bureaucracy and human insecurity.
mock-possum9 个月前
I think, when you’re not a bigot, and you’re not the target of bigotry, it is very very difficult to really get a sense of how perniciously powerful bigotry is, precisely because <i>it makes no sense</i> - bigots can’t <i>really</i> believe what they claim, can they? They won’t really go so far as to act on those beliefs, will they?<p>And even when they do, if they don’t do it to you, or do it while you’re watching, you find yourself incredulous that someone would really go and do such a thing.<p>Anyway. This is the sort of situation that births subreddits with titles like “are the straights okay?”
Xenoamorphous9 个月前
&gt; If only I got a penny for every time someone said: you don’t look like a computer scientist<p>I’m a guy and I’ve been told multiple times I don’t look like a software developer. I think it can happen to anyone who doesn’t fit the stereotype of nerdy person portrayed in films and TV.
评论 #41463188 未加载
Garvi9 个月前
The death rattle of a community.
评论 #41463881 未加载