TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Ask HN: How do apps get into Apple App Store pretending something they are not?

25 点作者 cosmorocket9 个月前
Being a bit into the adult industry, I sometimes see some kind of &quot;creative&quot; ways developers&#x2F;publishers use to push their adult-oriented apps and services into Apple app store for iOS, and this is something that seems to happen quite regularly.<p>For example, just today I saw a commercial on YouTube of an app, which clearly said &quot;1 on 1 chat, have fun, let&#x27;s do it together, blah blah blah&quot;. The ad shows some nice lady in a video chat smiling and showing her boobs blurred. Ok, I click a link to see how this app looks in the app store, because I understand it cannot be the same there, and 99% it pretends to be something else than an adult-oriented video chat.<p>So, I click the link &quot;Install&quot; and get to the app store. There, it makes its best to pretend as a kind of a book reader with recommendations and ability to share your &quot;interests&quot; with your new &quot;friends&quot; over the app. Screenshots show a bookshelf, then some screenshots looking like a social network, nothing you could suspect in doing anything &quot;seditious&quot;.<p>The description is also completely unrelated to anything chat-related, videos, 1-on-1 having fun with ladies and so on.<p>I am doing the next step and installing the app to see if it really looks as a book reader on the start or not.<p>When I install and open it, right from the start it shows a gallery with ladies I can &quot;contact&quot; and &quot;have fun&quot; if I topup my account and pay by minute.<p>Now, my question - how does it happen this way when developers create some clearly fake app page in app store, then get reviewed successfully with their shady app and finally get published in the app store? As far as I understand, reviewers have to install the app and see how it actually works and what it really does.<p>Why does it happen this way? Do developers send some nice-looking app to the review then somehow replace it with their actual app in the app store?<p>Thanks for your input!

6 条评论

scoodah9 个月前
I can’t speak to the apps in question of your post, but this did bring to mind how Uber hid app behavior from the App Store team:<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.theverge.com&#x2F;2017&#x2F;4&#x2F;23&#x2F;15399438&#x2F;apple-uber-app-store-fingerprint-program-tim-cook-travis-kalanick" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.theverge.com&#x2F;2017&#x2F;4&#x2F;23&#x2F;15399438&#x2F;apple-uber-app-s...</a>
评论 #41496913 未加载
benoau9 个月前
The judge in the Epic case said they had a 70% profit margin on their App Store fees, ignoring that multiple other groups of people are also funding the iPhone ecosystem and by the time these fees are being collected from users several hundred billion dollars in other revenue has also piled up. They said Apple wasn&#x27;t investing anything in app moderation.<p>&gt; At other points, she says Apple “does a poor job of mediating disputes between a developer and its customer,” and it’s been “slow either to adopt automated tools that could improve speed and accuracy or to hire more reviewers” for its app review process. “Apple’s slow innovation stems in part from its low investment in the App Store,” the ruling elaborates.<p>They have had famous goofs too, like Schiller complaining is anyone watching the App Store, after they <i>featured</i> a very low quality clone app so it&#x27;s not necessarily a deception on the developer&#x27;s part.<p>Meanwhile Apple claims to have about 500 app reviewers doing 100,000 reviews per week: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.apple.com&#x2F;app-store" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.apple.com&#x2F;app-store</a><p>So I guess the answer is, they just keep all the money and aren&#x27;t liable for squat.<p>But maybe they just need Patreon, xCloud and WeChat users to give them hundreds millions more each year before they can afford to do the job they demand they have to do, that they invented for themselves, that they fought viciously world-wide to prevent anyone else doing lol.
评论 #41500919 未加载
nfriedly9 个月前
I&#x27;m assuming they show something different to the reviewer than what they show their users.<p>My first guess is that the app is essentially a wrapper around a website, and after it&#x27;s approved, they change the website.
unsupp0rted9 个月前
There&#x27;s one pretending to be Claude, in app store countries where it&#x27;s the first&#x2F;ONLY option in the app store, because genuine Claude is not supported.<p>I tried to warn Apple about it, but their reporting form requires me to have downloaded an app before I report it. Nuts to that.
lapcat9 个月前
&gt; Do developers send some nice-looking app to the review then somehow replace it with their actual app in the app store?<p>No, that&#x27;s impossible. But if the app connects to the internet, which mosts apps do, then it&#x27;s trivial for the developer to release the app and then flip a server-side switch that tells the app to change its behavior. The logic would already be built-in to the app.<p>Incidentally, this is exactly how Fortnite got through review and then got banned by Apple.
评论 #41497129 未加载
评论 #41499287 未加载
chunkyguy9 个月前
Can you not simply use a feature flag that you control remotely to toggle the app between fake and real modes? You just need to toggle the flag on when submitting for review