TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

DOOM CAPTCHA

1316 点作者 denysvitali4 个月前

120 条评论

charlesabarnes4 个月前
I tried to do it the intended way, but found it too difficult. I was able to cheese it by staying in the starting area and killing the enemies that spawned to the right.
评论 #42570319 未加载
评论 #42568888 未加载
评论 #42567589 未加载
评论 #42567164 未加载
评论 #42578803 未加载
评论 #42567116 未加载
评论 #42567198 未加载
评论 #42570253 未加载
评论 #42572686 未加载
评论 #42568491 未加载
anandsuresh4 个月前
+100 for technical chops, -100 for usability. +10 for the trip down memory lane, and the self-realization that I now suck at playing video games.
评论 #42569837 未加载
评论 #42569747 未加载
评论 #42570890 未加载
评论 #42569592 未加载
casenmgreen4 个月前
1. That&#x27;s a tough level, one of the hidden levels IIRC.<p>2. It feels like &quot;-fast&quot; has been used.<p>3. The task is much, much more difficult because you can&#x27;t strafe.<p>Very cute though :-)
评论 #42566678 未加载
评论 #42566651 未加载
评论 #42568443 未加载
评论 #42569603 未加载
评论 #42569525 未加载
galleywest2004 个月前
There are so many monsters, took me 3-4 tries...just like a real captcha!
评论 #42576808 未加载
评论 #42566575 未加载
gamegod4 个月前
What kind of monster doesn&#x27;t give us WASD or at least ctrl to shoot?<p>Awesome captcha though :)
评论 #42566852 未加载
msoad4 个月前
When I try to log into AWS console and have to solve their captcha I always think that the target audience that this is designed to avoid can easily automate it (Some open source models can solve this without all that &quot;AI safety&quot; gatekeeping) while the majority of audience are simply suffering from this &quot;feature&quot;.<p>Apple has proposed a solution to captcha[1] which I can&#x27;t wait to be standardized and widely used.<p>[1] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;support.apple.com&#x2F;en-us&#x2F;102591" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;support.apple.com&#x2F;en-us&#x2F;102591</a>
评论 #42574348 未加载
评论 #42572412 未加载
wheresmycraisin4 个月前
Random trivia: the creators of Doom made sure that they could complete each level starting only with a pistol and 50 rounds by doing it themselves.
vunderba4 个月前
Thank you for doing the right thing and crediting the original Doom Captcha creator on the github repo. My expectations of the software industry in general have been at an all-time low lately, so this was nice to see.<p>The original from a few years back:<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;vivirenremoto.github.io&#x2F;doomcaptcha" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;vivirenremoto.github.io&#x2F;doomcaptcha</a><p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;github.com&#x2F;vivirenremoto&#x2F;doomcaptcha">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;github.com&#x2F;vivirenremoto&#x2F;doomcaptcha</a>
bilekas4 个月前
Well this is hard, guess I&#x27;m not a human!<p>It&#x27;s been so long since I&#x27;ve played doom but without strafing.. it&#x27;s almost impossible!
评论 #42569358 未加载
评论 #42569431 未加载
airstrike4 个月前
This was created with Vercel&#x27;s AI assistant &quot;v0&quot;<p>Here&#x27;s a link to the chat: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;v0.dev&#x2F;chat&#x2F;4X85A52Dzde?b=b_tOXbbZzZPgT&amp;f=0" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;v0.dev&#x2F;chat&#x2F;4X85A52Dzde?b=b_tOXbbZzZPgT&amp;f=0</a>
评论 #42567685 未加载
评论 #42567632 未加载
评论 #42567657 未加载
评论 #42567945 未加载
sira044 个月前
One day we&#x27;ll have the Dark Souls captcha <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=WqnXp6Saa8Y" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=WqnXp6Saa8Y</a>
Bengalilol4 个月前
Open console, type: for (i=0; i&lt;3; i++) {Module.onEnemyKilled();} Done.
threekindwords4 个月前
Ok, so this is the kind of content I show up for.<p>On one hand, it’s a clever and fun way to show off what we can do with the web these days. The way it is presented hits just right... the demo is dead center of the page, with debug tools and more info within reach. I particularly enjoyed reading the &quot;how it&#x27;s made&quot; page to understand how it was put together. I like how all of this extra stuff was not front and center when the page loads. Even the design language of the CAPTCHA box itself felt just right.<p>On the other hand, it&#x27;s a satire of what we have done to the web. The bad guys (like the monsters in the game) have won. I&#x27;m a flesh and blood human, but here I am having to click on fuzzy pictures of random objects before I can do the task I actually wanted to accomplish. Behind the scenes, my human insight gets licensed and used for whatever purpose (nefarious or not). Just like the DOOM demo here, it&#x27;s hard and cumbersome, but for whatever reason we all accept it as the way it has to be. We all shake our heads and say &quot;what a shame, what a shame.&quot;
评论 #42566873 未加载
itvision4 个月前
Solved it on a second attempt on my smartphone.<p>It&#x27;s horrible. 99% of people will give up.
评论 #42570374 未加载
acidburnNSA4 个月前
Thank God the cheat codes I have memorized still work.
irusensei4 个月前
Really cool. I’m all for cool and interesting captchas if there has to be captchas at all. Aparently this one is made to be really hard uh? Gave me some wicked idea about a captcha where you have to survive a few seconds in a 2hu fight.<p>You can argue that’s bad for accessibility and you are correct but let me use this opportunity to talk about that hostile “put things into orbit” thing big I noticed Microsoft and X using. Recently I’ve installed windows 11 on a laptop and had to create an MS account for testing purposes. During the captcha phase the OS was installing drivers in the background so the resolution changed to 4k during the challenge but the UI didn’t scaled. With no way to reconfigure the display I had to strain my eyes to finish it and I suffer from miopia and astigmatism.
jordigh4 个月前
Aw, monster in-fighting kills don&#x27;t count? That&#x27;s my favourite kind of kill. In-fighting is a basic Doom skill, kind of forgotten in modern FPSes.
mrcwinn4 个月前
No WASD?! CAPTCHA fail — I can tell no human created this.
评论 #42579854 未加载
throwanem4 个月前
Pistol-starting E1M9 &quot;Army Base&quot;, the first episode&#x27;s massive difficulty spike of a secret level, on a <i>touchscreen?</i> Not that I don&#x27;t appreciate the massive vote of confidence, but...
econ4 个月前
Just shooting without moving shouldn&#x27;t solve it. The ammo is excessive.<p>Mobile needs a better interface and landscape mode.
Dwedit4 个月前
It took me using Debug Mode to realize there was supposed to be a confetti animation that plays after winning, it loads from a third party site. I have third-party javascript blocked by default.
econ4 个月前
Do you have a version that requires more kills?<p>At 20 or so it would be a useful admin login challenge.<p>To make it less hackable it could perhaps submit which monsters were killed and&#x2F;or the time between kills or some other pattern. If the set roughly matches the previous attempts it could make for quite the challenge to brute force.<p>The &quot;hackers&quot; are already complaining that the challenge is to much for them :p I think you are onto something.
Andrew_nenakhov4 个月前
How am I expected to kill monsters if I can&#x27;t strafe, goddamit?!
评论 #42573900 未加载
评论 #42573755 未加载
bstsb4 个月前
reading the chat with v0 was interesting. the last time i tried v0 it generated really basic tailwind templates but the first image generation was actually really good for an LLM.
评论 #42567314 未加载
评论 #42566889 未加载
magic_smoke_ee4 个月前
IDSPISPOPD, IDKFA, and IDDQD work but the only weapons that work are the chainsaw up to the rocket launcher.
评论 #42570382 未加载
mazone4 个月前
on mobile phone. Just back up directly from the start to the door behind you so you dont get shoot then snipe them from a distance. captcha solved.
tnvmadhav4 个月前
I tried moving and I died. Stay at the spawn point and keep shooting anything that moves :)
评论 #42567424 未加载
foo-stuff4 个月前
I wonder how long this would need to train in order to pass the Captcha...<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;github.com&#x2F;apollopower&#x2F;DOOM-AI">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;github.com&#x2F;apollopower&#x2F;DOOM-AI</a>
评论 #42567113 未加载
LinuxBender4 个月前
I think my machines too slow and resolution too low. I died a few times, only got one monster. I could imagine folks in a NOC all trying to log in at the same time with speakers enabled. Some management types would have a meltdown. People on the phone would be like, <i>yeah sure you&#x27;re getting to my issue...</i> haha I do like the idea though. Needs a quick mute and a boss button that switches to TPS reports.
anta404 个月前
Failed on 1st attempt, then beat it on 2nd attempt (I&#x27;m on Macbook Air). Very amusing idea. Perhaps I&#x27;ll implement this for my personal project... well because why not? :p
mishkatronic4 个月前
I did this on mobile which was challenging. I ended up hugging the left hand wall and taking out enemies as they came into my line of sight.
aydgn4 个月前
I figured out how to solve this captcha with a bot! :) The trick is to strafe left immediately after spawning and continuously press the spacebar. Then, just wait for the enemies to move in front of you and get eliminated. :)
fuzzy_biscuit4 个月前
Pro strat is to peak forward a smidge and then pop off the few zombiemen and shotgun guys that are drawn in.
pshirshov4 个月前
1) Extremely annoying on smartphones<p>2) Exclusive, won&#x27;t work well for many of those who need accessibility
alexandrehtrb4 个月前
Very cool.<p>Suggestions:<p>- Make the player immortal by default. Also all weapons by default.<p>- Add strafing, if possible.<p>- Make the player go to the level exit to finish the captcha (maybe a custom short map?)<p>- A simpler version for mobile could be the original 3x3 captcha square with enemies attacking you. Tapping on enemy squares would kill them.
评论 #42568645 未加载
评论 #42568512 未加载
tomaytotomato4 个月前
This is really cool, I even tried to get monsters to frag each other but it didn&#x27;t count towards the required 3 kill count. &lt;clap&gt;<p>Also using cheats, kills with the rocket launcher aren&#x27;t registered on the app.
deeviant4 个月前
I feel this faster than the average &quot;click on all pictures of x&quot;.
评论 #42567509 未加载
pg54 个月前
Pretty cool, but a little on screen pad would be good for mobile users.
评论 #42566533 未加载
评论 #42566834 未加载
评论 #42566538 未加载
notcrazylol4 个月前
Why is this level this hard? or am I just bad at the game?
评论 #42572519 未加载
kmeisthax4 个月前
Can&#x27;t move or shoot on my iPad Pro with Magic Keyboard.
评论 #42567093 未加载
lomkju4 个月前
Toughest captcha I have ever solved in my lifetime.
discoinverno4 个月前
I couldn&#x27;t win without cheating ^:) It&#x27;s crazy how ingrained in my memory is the code tho, could remember it automatically after maybe 25 years
m11174 个月前
I&#x27;m glad I&#x27;m so old and remember iddqd idkfa
Beijinger4 个月前
Nice. But I would prefer this as a Captcha: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;play-cs.com&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;play-cs.com&#x2F;</a>
评论 #42567450 未加载
elliotpage4 个月前
Guess I&#x27;m not a human, I got owned by the imps because I assumed left and right would be strafing instead of turning.
mosquitobiten4 个月前
I broke it, I can enter the menu in firefox with F1, get put in the first level, I shoot the barrels and it counts as monsters killed.
thrillgore4 个月前
Starting me on E1M9 with the arrow keys and a pistol on what I&#x27;m told is Nightmare difficulty is a dick move.
quotemstr4 个月前
Funny, but thanks to RL, I&#x27;d expect this to actually be an ineffective CAPTCHA. DOTA was solved years ago, yes?
评论 #42567134 未加载
ckrailo4 个月前
Hold down the spacebar and let the enemies run in front of you. Might take two tries. No movement needed.
indigoabstract4 个月前
Ouch, the puzzle is too hard. Maybe the next step could be an automated tool for solving wicked CAPTCHAs? :)
tumsfestival4 个月前
I see people here having trouble with this, be thankful this isn&#x27;t Plutonia on Ultra-Violence.
to11mtm4 个月前
The fact it&#x27;s always E1M9 means it is fairly solvable unless they changed Doom&#x27;s RNG in a meaningful way.<p>=(
grahamj4 个月前
Clearly from comment comments here some humans can do this, but are we sure that bots can’t?
lokimedes4 个月前
Is this an anti-human captcha? It only allows for Alpha Zero or better to enter.
tomw18084 个月前
without idkfa and iddqd I cannot pass. Its the strive left&#x2F;right thats missing for me (not sure if that was in the original version actually), but it really throws me off that I need to use arrows and not asdw.
评论 #42579951 未加载
cydmax4 个月前
It took me 3 retries. I’ve forgotten how to strafe and just moved a bit to the right…
zghst4 个月前
I just started shooting because I kept dying, they appeared and I was able to pass!<p>Pretty difficult…
LarsDu884 个月前
I can see why the next generation of shooters made A and D strafe rather than turn
theendisney4 个月前
On mobile you have to stop walking to turn. It needs 8 directions to really work.
Raed6674 个月前
How is this a captcha ? how does the server verify you killed 3 monsters?
puttycat4 个月前
Cool, but why is this a CAPTCHA? That is a very broad definition of the test.
评论 #42569612 未加载
abbabon4 个月前
This CAPTCHA requires some serious cheating (IDDQD &#x2F; IDKFA) to solve.
mansilladev4 个月前
Glad you’re not refactoring my 2FA. Took me 4 attempts to kill 3 monsters.
rickreynoldssf4 个月前
Kind of hard without strafe.
alexshendi4 个月前
I couldn&#x27;t do it. I suppose I&#x27;m a Russian CyberBot! дружба!
davewasthere4 个月前
I learned I can&#x27;t play Doom if I can&#x27;t strafe. I&#x27;m a bot!
ai_ja_nai4 个月前
Crazy difficult, but I guess a RL AI could learn how to beat it
wruza4 个月前
Can’t strafe on mobile, that’s can shooting range and you are the can.
entropie4 个月前
Its awesome, but actually quite hard without arrow keys on a HHKBpro.
ngneer4 个月前
Strange. Wouldn&#x27;t computers be better at this than humans?
michaelsshaw4 个月前
This would be way cooler if this wasn&#x27;t so fucking difficult!
评论 #42568814 未加载
midnight_shaman4 个月前
Great idea, looking forward to seeing it on production websites ;)
ricardo814 个月前
Excellent, though I&#x27;d have liked it more with a bigger gun
评论 #42567366 未加载
评论 #42572865 未加载
MB-EU4 个月前
only thing I&#x27;d change is put shoot as CTRL :) - Good work
moonlion_eth4 个月前
Ironically robots are better at captchas than humans
EGreg4 个月前
I think it’s nearly impossible on a mobile phone hehe
评论 #42569901 未加载
slumberlust4 个月前
RIP to those of us with tenkeyless keyboards :(
ugh1234 个月前
Strafe while holding &#x27;option&#x27; on Mac
cyanydeez4 个月前
Aren&#x27;t you afraid you are training AI?
ProofHouse4 个月前
Make it 10000x easier and I’d use it haha
oncethishappens4 个月前
I must be human,I died pretty quick.
make34 个月前
you would have to randomize spawns otherwise they can just record a playthrough and repeat it to unlock
rootedbox4 个月前
doom is deterministic so does not make a good choice for a captcha.. that being said.. this is cute
EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK4 个月前
No BFG 9000 :(
评论 #42572874 未加载
Sparkyte4 个月前
Incredibly difficult but I love it.
bithead4 个月前
Takes less time than other CAPTCHAs
dvngnt_4 个月前
didn&#x27;t google&#x27;s ai genie use automomus agents to play doom to generate training data?
tom_4 个月前
Well at least it wasn&#x27;t E4M2.
jiffygist4 个月前
I hate the borked sounds so much
mobilio4 个月前
fun mode - iddqd and idkfa works!
评论 #42567077 未加载
mattcantstop4 个月前
Difficulty level: 1000&#x2F;100<p>But I love it!
ulrischa4 个月前
Does not work on a smartphone
评论 #42567288 未加载
joshcsimmons4 个月前
This is so metal. Great work.
slightwinder4 个月前
I hate it! Good CAPTCHA.
pratikshelar8714 个月前
too hard...I will never pass this captcha...And I am a bot
hackersrussia4 个月前
#HELLO-WORLD
yobid204 个月前
Doesnt work on mobile.
评论 #42568402 未加载
martinbaun4 个月前
I just died. I guess I am getting old and need to play more strategy games hehe.
评论 #42570414 未加载
mrlonglong4 个月前
BFG9000, here I come!
snarfy4 个月前
the controls are ass
ybbond4 个月前
it&#x27;s too hard, I bet only bot can accomplish this
评论 #42567659 未加载
layer84 个月前
Not very accessible.
m3kw94 个月前
it&#x27;s not possible to win without strifing
jokethrowaway4 个月前
The sad thing is that this is easier than some captchas I&#x27;ve seen.<p>I remember some crap from hell with hcaptcha
lazide4 个月前
Compiling? [<a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;xkcd.com&#x2F;303&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;xkcd.com&#x2F;303&#x2F;</a>] so archaic. Now I’m playing Doom so I can login to the console.
bogrollben4 个月前
today I learned I really suck at Doom.
mambodog4 个月前
just to be that guy<p><pre><code> Module.onEnemyKilled();Module.onEnemyKilled();Module.onEnemyKilled() </code></pre> probably should run part of the game on the server if you want to prevent bypassing the captcha easily
stuckkeys4 个月前
Thanks satan.
barfolomew4 个月前
I died
tw0fac34 个月前
Wow
pseingatl4 个月前
idkfa doesn&#x27;t work
anthk4 个月前
Now do it with Nethack&#x2F;Slashem.
rarirurero4 个月前
That&#x27;s pretty hard, especially without side-strafing lol
rmac4 个月前
do diablo
rkagerer4 个月前
I managed to make one enemy kill another, does that count?
75w4 个月前
See also rudecaptcha.xyz
tobyhinloopen4 个月前
Lol why is it so absurdly hard
super_normal4 个月前
beat the captcha first try on a pixel 6. true gaming legend signing out, el oh el oh el...
doctor_radium4 个月前
I&#x27;ve rolled my eyes for years over when this sort of thing would happen for real: &quot;score 3000 points at Pac Man and <i>maybe</i> we&#x27;ll let you view our web site&quot;. +1 for the technical achievement, but I turn and run at Cloudflare tick boxes.
mensetmanusman4 个月前
This will work until agents are common. I bet the best bot farms are first adopters of agents though.