I follow a YouTube channel Gamma1734 [1] where the creator who runs it plays a bunch of piano sheet music from the past, a lot of it in the Romantic style. The artists played on the channel are all obscure to me. None of the names I consider "masters" from that period or style. And to be frank, the average quality of the compositions is not great.<p>My own opinion, as an amateur musician with no classical training, is the music I heard on this AI generated page would not have stood out to me compared to the rest of the pieces on that channel. I would wager that in a randomized test of these average middle of the road composers vs. an AI score generated by NoteGen that almost no average person would be able to distinguish them.<p>That leaves two categories. The highly trained individuals (e.g. professional composers or well educated amateurs) who may be able to tell a difference (I would love a real study on this and not just "vibes"). And the master composers (Beethoven, Chopin, Brahms, Liszt, etc.) which stand above the average human composers of their own times.<p>I would admit the pieces composed by the AI aren't at the level of the master, but they do feel indistinguishable to me from the average.<p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/@PianoScoreVids" rel="nofollow">https://www.youtube.com/@PianoScoreVids</a>