TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

"Final Usonian Home" by Frank Lloyd Wright Completed in Ohio

69 点作者 rmason大约 1 个月前

11 条评论

brudgers大约 1 个月前
<i>The house has received pushback from official Frank Lloyd Wright organisations such as the Frank Lloyd Wright Foundation (The Foundation) and the Frank Lloyd Wright Building Conversancy</i><p>From a practical standpoint this usually means that if you put this house in a publication about Wright, the Foundation and Conservancy will deny you use of their archival material and photographic access to their sites.<p>Their behavior is why you rarely see Wrights work at Florida Southern College in books on Wright despite Florida Southern being the largest collection of Wright designed buildings anywhere, one of a few examples of his commercial work, absolutely amazing designs, and actually in ordinary use…worth a visit if you are passing by Lakeland on I4.
评论 #43617126 未加载
评论 #43624226 未加载
Animats大约 1 个月前
Usonian homes were supposed to be for &quot;middle income&quot; people. What did this one cost?<p>Of course it would need some structural improvements. Wright had some problems on the structural engineering side. Fallingwater is currently getting major structural upgrading.[1] There are arguments about whom to blame in the original construction, but it&#x27;s clear that the aggressive cantilevered design didn&#x27;t have enough safety margin.<p>[1] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.architecturelab.net&#x2F;fallingwater-undergoes-7-million-restoration-to-address-structural-and-water-damage&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.architecturelab.net&#x2F;fallingwater-undergoes-7-mil...</a>
评论 #43623470 未加载
wnissen大约 1 个月前
I&#x27;m curious what, specifically, the foundation claims is contrary to the plans. It&#x27;s not like Wright himself built the houses (or did the drawings, for that matter). There&#x27;s always been a process of modification when the contractor gets onsite and builds something. When Wright was alive he (or his secretary) would review pictures of the the resulting home and award a glazed red tile with Wright&#x27;s signature engraved. That was the official recognition that you had a Frank Lloyd Wright home. Perhaps with all the litigation (such as with the Jean-Michel Basquiat authentication committee) the foundation is scared to get involved.<p>I saw Riverrock over Christmas when it was 95% complete, and it does look really cool. Similar in a lot of ways, especially the living room, but quite a different floor plan. I hope the doors are a bit wider than the Louis Penfield house on the same site; even folks of normal width have to rotate sideways. Toilet in a narrow alcove, narrow cushions on the furniture, etc. Absolute commitment to design integrity, not always comfortable. Still a fascinating place to stay.
评论 #43616912 未加载
defrost大约 1 个月前
Of etymological interest:<p><pre><code> The word Usonian appears to have been coined by James Duff Law, a Scottish writer born in 1865. In a miscellaneous collection, Here and There in Two Hemispheres (1903), Law quoted a letter of his own (dated June 18, 1903) that begins &quot;We of the United States, in justice to Canadians and Mexicans, have no right to use the title &#x27;Americans&#x27; when referring to matters pertaining exclusively to ourselves.&quot; He went on to acknowledge that some author had proposed &quot;Usona&quot; (United States of North America), but that he preferred the form &quot;Usonia&quot; (United States of North Independent America). </code></pre> ~ <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Usonia" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Usonia</a>
评论 #43624378 未加载
Pxtl大约 1 个月前
It&#x27;s beautiful, but fundamentally I&#x27;ve always found Wright&#x27;s Usonian ideal - the US population living in rear-facing cottages in the forest - to be repulsive.<p>I like forests. That&#x27;s why I think they should be protected, and the best way to protect them is to not smear the entire population across them like very fine jam and carve infinite roads through them to provide them with transportation and government services like garbage collection.<p>The idea of presenting a bare facade to the street and turning the front entrance inward only makes this vision even more antisocial.<p>The man could make beautiful things but the planning principles needed to provide that beauty were fundamentally ugly.
AStonesThrow大约 1 个月前
In the early 90s, my parents undertook and completed an ambitious project to expand our home, after owning it for about 20 years. Without adding a third story or encroaching too much on our open yard space, we managed to double the kitchen and expand&#x2F;renovate several other rooms and the results were really wonderful.<p>However, the process was painful for me as a young adult. I recall first a controversy over whether a professional, licensed architect should be retained, or if the contractor himself should draw up the plans. We were told that architects often had ivory-tower type plans that were impractical, expensive, or needed modifications by the contractor anyway. I can&#x27;t actually remember which side we came down on.<p>Mom and Dad also permitted me to specify a bunch of elements in my own room, and being a rebellious goth in the throes of PTSD I made some really bad decisions, before permanently moving out two years later. My dad has the room now: it&#x27;s got pitch-black carpeting with an incense burn in it, the miniblinds are also charcoal black with dark-grey accents in weird middle stripes, and two windows may be cranked open for fresh air, but one is ridiculously narrow, and I suspect that the design intent was &quot;prevent AStonesThrow from jumping out of this one&quot;. (Well I did climb out of windows, but more for exploration&#x27;s sake than self-harm.)<p>The demolition was also mindblowing as I got a taste of just how sturdy our original construction was. It was a tough &quot;chicken-wire&quot; lath embedded in plaster&#x2F;stucco, and it was a Faraday cage fortress that took weeks to tear down. They replaced it with ordinary gypsum drywall, and I was incredulous about the sheer quality difference, but it was clear that matching the original style would need to be superficial unless we were spending millions of bucks at that point.<p>It really turned out well despite all my efforts at sabotage. I&#x27;m not sure about my parents&#x27; motivations; I believe it was mostly Mom who received a really awesome modern kitchen, and a modicum of &quot;keeping up with the Joneses&quot; because that decade saw so many of our neighbors adding stories and Granny Flats and renovations, commensurate with rising property values. Yay!
jmclnx大约 1 个月前
What Beautiful a House. I wonder if any of his Usonian designs are still being built these days.<p>Edit: Just found the reference and I need to learn to read :) So yes is my answer
dylan604大约 1 个月前
&quot;According to Dykstra, who served as a general contractor on the project with her mother Debbie, the three-bedroom, two-bedroom house in Willoughby Hills, Ohio was built using plans of Wright&#x27;s Usonian called Project #5909, or Riverrock.&quot;<p>Assuming 2-bathroom house? Why oh why has editorial review just become such a joke? This seems like such an obvious thing to catch.
评论 #43626853 未加载
jamincan大约 1 个月前
@dang Surely this is mistakenly flagged? This is interesting and hardly seems controversial or inflammatory.
nothercastle大约 1 个月前
Beautiful and completely unlivable like most architecture works
评论 #43623854 未加载
评论 #43624025 未加载
avonmach大约 1 个月前
This is awesome, they do tours of one of his houses near me, thanks for sharing
评论 #43623506 未加载