TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Audiobooks vs. Printed Books: a debate as a reader and an author

32 点作者 zeristor大约 1 个月前

21 条评论

silves8928 天前
Can I read a physical book when I&#x27;m running? Can I read a physical book when I&#x27;m doing house work? Or throwing pots in my studio? Or knitting? Or cooking? Or driving?<p>Can I stay focused if I&#x27;m just sitting and listening instead of reading? Absolutely not.<p>There&#x27;s no &#x27;vs&#x27; here. They occupy different spaces. All hail text, whatever form it takes.
评论 #43704195 未加载
评论 #43703147 未加载
评论 #43702823 未加载
reify大约 1 个月前
Its not cheating, some books can only be read, while others are improved with audio.<p>I prefer reading books, there is something special about holding a book in your hands, insering a book mark or jotting down something illegible in the margins.<p>I have read a massive amount of books in my time as a psychotherapist for 25 years.<p>For me, it is far better to read books to fully understand and examine the theories, concepts and methods illustrated by the authors. Marginalia comes to its fore.<p>However, I do listen to my fair share of audiobook. My main gripe with audiobooks is the readers voice. I cannot stand the squeeky, high pitched, robotic, nasally, sounds like AI, might well be AI, especially american female voices. Being British, just one paragraph and I am immediately put off and turn them off.<p>I have recently tried to listen to &quot;Into the Into the Deep Wood 01, The Witch by Polina Volkova&quot;. I had to stop listening after a few paragraphs. If only the reader had a british voice.<p>I find switching back and forth between pages to find something you remember reading a few days ago is too difficult with an audiobook. No marginalia with audiobooks.<p>Do authors select who reads their books. maybe they do not. They should have readers from different countries and different languages.<p>My favourite audiobook reader is David Thorpe. I have the entire series of Mark Dawson&#x27;s; John Milton, Beatrix Rose, Isabella Rose, Group 15, plus the novellas and more recently the Charlie cooper series.<p>I do not experience the same excitement reading those books.
评论 #43707304 未加载
评论 #43702637 未加载
评论 #43702509 未加载
makeitdouble28 天前
I feel we&#x27;re in the golden age where the format matters so much less.<p>Taking &quot;99% invisible&quot; for instance, the content in the podcast, on the web or in a book are fundamentally the same level of quality and interest.<p>Then light novels are pushing the boundaries of what novel literature should look like and we get hundred page books formated as SMS conversations or with ASCII art like layout without much issues.<p>And on the other end interview and reporting shows are becoming way more researched than the bog standard columns in printed magazines.<p>Patreon is behind a lot of this change, allowing money to flow to creators whatever their medium, and I&#x27;m all for it.
isaacremuant28 天前
I don&#x27;t understand what&#x27;s the debate unless you&#x27;re assigning some higher value to the written form, like people who think reading makes you more disciplined or a better person than others in some way.<p>If you remove that and realize reading is a form of communication then it doesn&#x27;t matter how you make it happen. There was a time when stories and knowledge was mostly shared verbally so it&#x27;s not like reading is &quot;the truest form&quot;.<p>Do what you like&#x2F;works for you.
zeristor28 天前
Amazon is trying hard with Audiobooks, but they seem to be extremely expensive to me, maybe that’s their way of making a lot more money than kindle format.<p>I spend my listening time just trying to catch up with podcasts.<p>What audio book formats are there, and services. Dare I say it are there any open source ones?<p>There are many podcast players, are the many audiobook players?<p>Is there anything really useful in an audiobook player? I guess going through chapters, maybe linking into the actual text.
评论 #43702655 未加载
评论 #43702626 未加载
评论 #43707076 未加载
评论 #43703156 未加载
grokgrok28 天前
Well narrated audio contains an interpretation, a layer of sublexical meaning that transmits value judgement, emphasis and often the narrator&#x27;s imagination as to the nature of the character&#x27;s voices. Often desirable, but sometimes we want our own interpretation, unique and uninfluenced by the narrator&#x27;s biases.
4ndrewl28 天前
They&#x27;re two different things, that employ different senses and are neurologically demonstrated to provided different experiences.<p>We don&#x27;t need them to battle it out unless for the clicks.
评论 #43702542 未加载
dwighttk28 天前
The experience is different but the Venn Diagram is not two separate circles.
maxglute28 天前
Why cling on the book label? It&#x27;s 2025, it&#x27;s visual content vs audio content. I&#x27;d like listening to my content. Rather I like doing both, listening at 3x speed robot voice while reading text, be it a book or transcript. I&#x27;ll adjust playback speed and attention if the content pleases me.
wintermutestwin28 天前
Why is there no Spotify for audiobooks? Audible’s pricing model is stupid. I guess the bean counters know better than I, but I imagine there are a lot of people like me who just shrug and listen to what I can get for free through my library’s Libby access. I would gladly pay 15$ a month for unlimited.
评论 #43702931 未加载
评论 #43703358 未加载
评论 #43703276 未加载
评论 #43704036 未加载
numpad028 天前
I prefer to read books literally multithreaded. Different parts of my brain gets the pages through the bus or through different paths and do each their things.<p>I can&#x27;t be alone. I get that being able to finish a book anyhow is nice, but isn&#x27;t that also like leaving half a steak cut on the plate?
cafard27 天前
A while back, our neighborhood book club read <i>Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow</i>. One of the members said that she couldn&#x27;t stand the jumping around in the narrative sequence of the book. It hadn&#x27;t bothered me, and it was only later that I remembered that she habitually listens to books.<p>Listening was how most of humanity consumed literature for most of history. But the written word has its advantages as well.
yuvadam28 天前
For me, the difference is being able to listen to - and finish - an audiobook, versus having dead tree sitting on the shelf and never even starting to read it.
评论 #43702605 未加载
timonoko28 天前
There should be better text-to-speech readers by now.<p>Human readers are now little bit better, but when AI recognizes characters and narrators, the came is over.<p>Worst thing on text-to-speech readers is when you fall asleep and dreams and text get weirdly mixed and you have search afterwards where you dropped off and started dreaming. AI might help on this also because smartwatch recognizes sleep stage quite well.
pnutjam28 天前
I don&#x27;t see anyone else saying this, but I don&#x27;t like audiobooks because of the voices and over production. If I want to listen to a book, I use TTS, it&#x27;s gotten very good. I can pick the voice and I just hear the story. I can also switch back to reading without trying to figure out where I am since the Text to speech is using the same epub I&#x27;m reading.
评论 #43704252 未加载
scary-size28 天前
I really liked John Green&#x27;s take on audiobooks [1].<p>&gt; ...the point of reading is to ingest someone&#x27;s words and ideas in the most transparent way possible...<p>For some that&#x27;s reading, for others that&#x27;s listening.<p>[1] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=80SCl6n0TEo" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=80SCl6n0TEo</a>
zeristor大约 1 个月前
I’m curious as to what people think about Audiobooks?<p>They just seem so expensive to me, and the concept still feels like cheating to me.
评论 #43702627 未加载
评论 #43702394 未加载
评论 #43702899 未加载
评论 #43702426 未加载
评论 #43703408 未加载
评论 #43702622 未加载
评论 #43702517 未加载
评论 #43703357 未加载
评论 #43702472 未加载
alok-g28 天前
As such, both print and audio have worked well for me.<p>Lately, font sizes for printed books has become an issue. I getting old and cannot read with small font sizes.<p>Meanwhile, publishers seem optimizing for lower prices (less paper) and younger people it seems.<p>Someone recently told me that hardcover editions tend to have larger font sizes.
shelled28 天前
You don’t &quot;read&quot; audiobooks. You <i>listen</i> to them. Big difference - not better or worse, just not the same. When it comes to listening, I Love podcasts - esp. with multiple hosts&#x2F;guests. Solo ones work too, if they feel like conversations and not recitals.<p>Audiobooks are not for me. I’ve tried. Reading hits different. But sure, for self-help, productivity, coding and shit you need to use them, so you use them. Interestingly, the biggest audiobook junkies I know are also heavy <i>readers</i>. They know the difference—and they don’t mix the two.
评论 #43708990 未加载
dhosek28 天前
46 comments at this point and <i>nobody</i> clicked the link where the author’s thoughts are behind the paywall and instead argue a point that she explicitly says she’s not going to address!
pimlottc28 天前
The full essay appears to behind a subscription paywall, anyone have a link?