TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Show HN: I taught AI to commentate Pong in real time

207 点作者 pncnmnp12 天前

18 条评论

mtlynch10 天前
This is a fun idea, but I feel like Pong is too simple for the execution to work.<p>I watched the video, and it seemed like everything it was saying, you could have just pre-programmed for the very limited state space of Pong. It reminded me a little bit of the stock John Madden and Pat Sumerall sound bites that would play during 90s &#x2F; early 2000s Madden games.<p>Could you apply the same idea to chess or Texas Hold &#x27;Em? I feel like the additional complexity of those games could lead to more interesting commentary.
评论 #43886961 未加载
评论 #43887626 未加载
评论 #43887084 未加载
QRe10 天前
Fun experiment. Main limitation I see is the delay between actions and commentary because of the whole script generation &amp; TTS overhead. It seems like the commentary can quickly fall behind, especially in fast-paced sports.
评论 #43887696 未加载
评论 #43886533 未加载
isaacremuant10 天前
The idea is very fun and kudos on the author but it definitely feels lacking on the actual game commentary itself. My perception, is that it throws random fillers that don&#x27;t quite feel like apt commentary.<p>If you&#x27;re jokingly imitating filler from bad commentary I understand but I think I&#x27;d like more play by play and less color, but of course pong has a limited amount of inputs to work with for that commentary.<p>One thing that could very well work for the latency issue some commenters post is to just send the events and receive commentary outside of the rendering and playback so that it, within some max delay, can look more immediate and in sync.<p>Very fun idea. Hope to see it with more complex things with more inputs.
croemer10 天前
If you want to skip the demo&#x27;s fairly boring pre-match talk, the fun starts here: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;youtu.be&#x2F;i21wN6CDsE0?si=cdUs_xLCwE8B0ATq&amp;t=153" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;youtu.be&#x2F;i21wN6CDsE0?si=cdUs_xLCwE8B0ATq&amp;t=153</a>
评论 #43888665 未加载
评论 #43886874 未加载
petercooper10 天前
I want this for when I&#x27;m working.<p><i>&quot;Here we see Peter copying and pasting in some generic quick sort algorithm from.. somewhere. Stack Overflow? ChatGPT? Who knows. And he goes for the compile without writing any tests! Let&#x27;s see if it compiles first time. And it&#x27;s a noooooo! Bad luck, let&#x27;s see how he gets out of this pickle. (I told you he should have written some tests.)&quot;</i>
评论 #43886220 未加载
评论 #43886571 未加载
评论 #43889258 未加载
评论 #43887458 未加载
评论 #43886328 未加载
jart10 天前
Do headline games like John Madden do this? That&#x27;s a great use case for LLMs.
评论 #43886803 未加载
评论 #43886047 未加载
评论 #43886245 未加载
blakeburch10 天前
Really fun to see! I&#x27;d love to have something similar for esports, like League of Legends or Rocket League. So much of the commentary feels like filler with stats and statements about a player.
评论 #43887680 未加载
评论 #43887419 未加载
neilv10 天前
Is a lot of the generated commentary pure fabrication?
评论 #43886131 未加载
sim7c0010 天前
ths is so funny my god haha. the intro is a bit dry but when the game is on its fire haha :&#x27;). what an exhillarating match xD
oulipo10 天前
Perfect meta-commentary on why AI is 90% useless stuff. Main use-case of AI in the real-world is really not far from commenting a pong match, eg trying to painfully make something exciting out of something worthless and dull, but not succeeding
smus10 天前
I wouldn&#x27;t say you taught the ai anything so much as wired some API calls together
ayongpm10 天前
Pretty cool. I can see how commentary could make even Pong more interesting. Maybe there’s room for a pro Pong competition, kind of like what Tetris has.
indigodaddy10 天前
How about an alternative commentary to the staring competitions? It must be wry and dry of course, and hard to beat the existing commentary, but might be interesting to see how it turns out.<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;youtu.be&#x2F;SWgg20IqibM?si=xP5ZpcQu8P2V2ZTc" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;youtu.be&#x2F;SWgg20IqibM?si=xP5ZpcQu8P2V2ZTc</a>
pawelduda10 天前
Looks like the idea of Morgan Freeman narrating life in real time is closer to reality than ever
评论 #43888392 未加载
评论 #43886332 未加载
hvardhan87810 天前
I wonder if you can clone the voice and tonality of Peter Drury and even make a game of Pong emotional.
danjl10 天前
What&#x27;s with the circular ball?
评论 #43888020 未加载
MontgomeryPy10 天前
Tom Brady&#x27;s job as a color commentator may be in jeopardy ;)
DonHopkins10 天前
Commentator 1 (Greg “The Swatch Whisperer”): Welcome back, folks, to what can only be described as the pinnacle of human achievement: watching Disney Princess™ Pink paint dry. I haven’t been this excited since the 2002 Home Depot Black Friday Sale when I almost got my hands on a discontinued eggshell Martha Stewart Lavender.<p>Commentator 2 (Marsha “Two Coats” Hernandez): Greg, I still remember the way you wept in aisle 7. But let’s talk about today’s masterpiece—Disney Princess Pink, the shade officially inspired by the collective inner glow of Aurora, Cinderella, and, dare I say, Ariel&#x27;s clam-bikini energy.<p>Greg: Absolutely, Marsha. And look at that glorious semi-damp sheen—like a freshly glazed donut at sunrise. It’s got a dreamy undertone of &quot;your niece’s birthday party at 10 a.m. with a bouncy castle and too much Capri Sun.&quot;<p>Marsha: Oh-ho, what’s this? Is that… yes, I think the lower left quadrant is beginning to matte. Ladies and gentlemen, we may be witnessing the first signs of Stage 3: The Settling of the Pigment.<p>Greg (choked up): My god… I haven’t seen a transition like this since Elsa’s Let It Go phase. Remember that? How she emotionally dried her entire personality over a solo in under three minutes? Iconic.<p>Marsha: Speaking of queens, this paint owes everything to Belle’s bedroom in the lost “Live Laugh Library” deleted scene. That’s the shade they were going to use until someone spilled tea on the concept art. Literally. It was Chip. That kid is a menace.<p>Greg: I’m sorry but—hold on—this is huge. That patch near the window just tightened. We are witnessing micro-shrinkage. It’s subtle, it’s refined, it’s got the attitude of Mulan at a dim sum buffet. She came hungry, and this paint came to DRY.<p>Marsha: Greg, if this drying pace keeps up, we’re on track for a Suburban First-Timer Finish Time. I haven’t seen Disney Pink behave like this since the infamous 2017 &quot;Frozen Themed Daycare Hallway Incident.&quot; They had to repaint in Tiana Teal—the shame.<p>Greg: And oh! There it is! That final middle patch—she’s going matte, folks. This wall is becoming a canvas of completion, a poetic stillness in a chaotic world. I feel like I just watched Cinderella get her slipper and a Roth IRA.<p>Marsha (tearfully): This… is why I do this job. For moments like this. For the shimmerless silence. For the slow, glorious commitment to finality.<p>Greg: And so we leave you, dear viewers, staring into a flat, fully-dry future. The room has changed… and so have we.
评论 #43888052 未加载
评论 #43888206 未加载