TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Is Vine Instagram for Video?

74 点作者 fredsters_s超过 12 年前

15 条评论

jgrahamc超过 12 年前
Vine is the video equivalent of the carefully cropped Facebook photo.<p>The narcissistic services like Twitter and Facebook haven't really had a video equivalent. By limiting the videos to 6 seconds people will be able to post little videos without requiring the talent or effort to make something longer that people will be willing to watch.<p>Just as the reddit front page has become dominated by meme images that require little brain power to consume, Vine will ideal for LOL videos posted by people. I suspect it will be very successful.<p>Also, the OP says "Instagram makes everyone ‘creative’." Seriously?
评论 #5129820 未加载
评论 #5131423 未加载
评论 #5129854 未加载
评论 #5133477 未加载
brianchu超过 12 年前
When I saw Vine I instantly thought of Cinegram [1]. Basically it's like Vine but it allows you to selectively animate portions of the video. This leads to lots of hilarious gif-like clips which IMO are much more shareable (and addictive) than Vine.<p>[1] <a href="http://cinemagr.am/" rel="nofollow">http://cinemagr.am/</a>
评论 #5134120 未加载
pmoehring超过 12 年前
Like the insights and mostly agree.<p>I think you missed an interesting point, though:<p>Can Twitter (or Facebook, or anyone else for that matter) still build the next big thing internally? Are these companies still as 'startup' as they think they are, or are they now too slow and bureaucratic to come up with products unrelated to their own core functionality?<p>A follow question: should they even come up with the new cool thing, or should they focus on their core offerings and simply buy break out successes when they are apparent?<p>In my opinion, both FB and Twitter are overestimating their chances here, like any incumbent always does (see Christensen). The questions "what if Google does this" is dismissed by every founder, because obviously Google is too focused on its core mission to make the success of a new social app the forefront of its development efforts.<p>Both companies are focusing more and more on being platforms for others, rather than building and testing all new paradigms themselves. This is what being the incumbent allows you to do, taking much larger risks, with larger payoffs. Launching a lot of small apps with cool ideas certainly shouldn't be their core business when they need to figure out how to deal with their growing developer ecosystem (again, something both companies are struggling with).<p>Acting on fear, which both companies did with their recent apps, certainly isn't the right strategy. But maybe I'm wrong and Twitter and Facebook are the only companies that can escape the innovator's dilemma?<p>BTW - Google is doing fine on that front with self driving cars and rockets, despite their not so apparent track record in social.
评论 #5130366 未加载
loceng超过 12 年前
Vine is about forcing creativity and curation of the visual world around us. 6 seconds really limits the amount of content you include in order to tell a simple story. The 140 character limit on Twitter, whether purposeful or not initially, also forces this creativity and simplifying a message to give as much meaning possible in as little space possible.<p>Imagine if Twitter had / was able to acquire Instagram. That, plus Vine, and I'd say Twitter would be on their way to helping rapidly kill Facebook; Now Facebook's death with just be a bit slower, and they may own some more assets that might be worth something.
评论 #5129695 未加载
brown9-2超过 12 年前
When people say things like "I thought it would be interesting to unpack Vine’s success so far", what is "success" based on?<p>Is Vine a "success"/popular? How is this quantified?
评论 #5129904 未加载
评论 #5129961 未加载
评论 #5129931 未加载
nasalgoat超过 12 年前
Why no mention of Keek in any of these Vine discussions? It's the closest competitor in functionality and has some serious traction in the microvideo space.
评论 #5130990 未加载
fredsters_s超过 12 年前
One point I didn't explicitly make in the post: Vine is not about gifs, it's about video.
评论 #5129693 未加载
nextparadigms超过 12 年前
Hasn't Apple banned it yet? And if not, why not? I find the double standard appalling.
评论 #5130076 未加载
lukethomas超过 12 年前
I wrote the same thing yesterday. It will be very interesting to see how this battle for video pans out.<p><a href="http://lukethomas.com/vine-is-for-storytelling/" rel="nofollow">http://lukethomas.com/vine-is-for-storytelling/</a>
评论 #5130120 未加载
nazgulnarsil超过 12 年前
Is it another monument to narcissism? Yeah, seems to be.
ErikAugust超过 12 年前
One question: Was Vine completely cultivated at Twitter? Or was it something they snapped up in very early stages from someone else?
评论 #5129833 未加载
lewisflude超过 12 年前
Is there a possibility the whole Vine adult content hiccup was just a publicity stunt?
评论 #5129858 未加载
评论 #5129650 未加载
评论 #5129638 未加载
评论 #5129642 未加载
loceng超过 12 年前
P.S. You're wrong about Google's social efforts bombing. They are filling in a need.
评论 #5129837 未加载
marikachen超过 12 年前
Excellent!
minm超过 12 年前
Vine is a Privacy nightmare