TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Only Apple and Google are skating to where the puck is going

51 点作者 eddielee6大约 12 年前

19 条评论

netcan大约 12 年前
Sony, Asus, and Lenovo are a particular type of company. They make the computers that they think consumers will buy in the next 12 months. If that's low end netbooks, mid range ultrabooks, desktop replacements, whatever.<p>That's not a high margin business model. But it is a <i>valid</i> one. It's also the model which supplies computers to most of the population. Its the model which has brought down the price of computers year after year.<p>It does't inspire cliche images of technological innovators 'building-the-future' by "skating to where the puck will be" but they <i>are</i> an important part of the landscape. To me the tech map looks great right now. Better than ever. We have real competition among OS makers. We have serious innovation in devices. We have competition between chip makers. Competition between commodity component manufacturers is pushing prices down.<p>Sony, Asus, and Lenovo are doing their part. Repackaging the innovations of last year for the mass market at half the price. They're an important part of the mix.<p>It's great that Google are trying this new stuff with ChromeOS. It's great that Apple is out there creating new products and setting the standard in industrial design. But we don't need all companies to be Apple.
评论 #5286798 未加载
cek大约 12 年前
Shockingly short-sighted post. Apple does not make it's profits from feeds &#38; speeds (e.g. Retina display). It makes its profits, and delights its customers through its vertical integration; its excellence at every point of the customer experience from design, to supply chain management, to manufacturing, to distribution, to marketing, to advertising, to retail, to sales, to post-sales, to support, to software, to services.<p>To assert that, from a business perspective, that the "puck" that Google (or Apple) worry about is ludicrous. These two companies do not even compete on the same rink. Their competition is asymmetric. Apple's profits come from 'high margins at retail, paid up front'. Google's profits come from 'the consumer is the product, the advertiser is the customer'.<p>It is fun to try to compare the micro-actions of these companies, but it is not business or strategy analysis.
评论 #5286307 未加载
评论 #5286410 未加载
UnoriginalGuy大约 12 年前
Microsoft are really holding back higher resolution displays.<p>I mean 125% on Windows has now essentially become a requirement to use Windows on any monitor made in the last few years, and we're almost up to the point where 150% is required. However the problem is that 150% seems to break MANY Windows applications (both third and first party).<p>I'm really hopefully that when displays become just slightly higher resolution we will see some third party software which can "scale" Windows up so that it works the same as Retina displays on the Macbooks do (i.e. real resolution and relative resolution aren't locked together).
casca大约 12 年前
TL;DR: high resolution displays are the future of laptop computing. Only Apple has a good one, Google is trying.
评论 #5286495 未加载
martythemaniak大约 12 年前
I use an old MBP that I'd like to replace soon, but there's no way I can get the Pixel - it just doesn't do <i>stuff</i>.<p>I think Chrome OS needs a great virtualization solution - just how chrome handles PDFs and Flash fairly well. I want to be able to open a "windows" tab or an "ubuntu" tab, use them normally.
评论 #5286267 未加载
davefp大约 12 年前
It seems like the author sees where Apple is skating, and assumes the puck must be going there also.
评论 #5286185 未加载
TheAnimus大约 12 年前
&#62;but the old Windows desktop has never supported high DPI displays, and I don't think it's about to.<p>Except it has. I've been using it like that for 7 years on my lounge TV which is scaled to 175%. On my old Z series for 3 years which had a high PPI screen before anyone else was pushing that way (colour rendition suffered a bit I felt).<p>The problem is lots of software doesn't play well, they use dodgy code, assume its always 96 dpi screen. Even VB devs given twips managed to mess it up with hardcoded assumptions all over the place.<p>However, all the main apps I use support it, if one doesn't well you can set that apps option indevidually.
hmottestad大约 12 年前
Just a quick check on komplett.no, a leading online dealer in Norway for computer equipment.<p>- Laptops with ssds start at 6000 nok (1057 USD).<p>- Laptops with IPS screen start at 6000 nok (1057 USD).<p>- Small screen (11.7") laptop with IPS &#38; full hd (189 dpi) &#38; SSD starts at 9795 nok (1718 usd).<p>- Macbook retina 13" starts at 11490 nok (2015 usd).<p>A year ago there were hardly any laptops with IPS screens or cheap laptops with SSDs. A lot has changed. I still love my retina macbook pro 15".
kevinconroy大约 12 年前
Some context for non-hockey fans:<p>"A good hockey player plays where the puck is. A great hockey player plays where the puck is going to be." - Wayne Gretzky
评论 #5286041 未加载
评论 #5286328 未加载
评论 #5286348 未加载
评论 #5286509 未加载
stevenameyer大约 12 年前
Apple and Google are able to take risks because the companies are all but guaranteed revenue every year. Google specifically does not really need a lot of their hardware to succeed because of their massive revenue from search. They are able to make risks on products that would result in more people online if they succeed because if it works they make more money off search, and if it fails they have a lot of revenue to fall back on. Companies like Sony, Asus, and Lenovo (while I do maintain that they are innovating in their own ways) can't take these risks because if they get a rep for making bad laptops they have nothing to fall back on. Hardware is an expensive game and it's difficult to justify taking risks in it if you have no solid revenue stream to fall back on if it fails.
kayoone大约 12 年前
The mass market for which Sony, Asus etc are producing is not really interested in super high resolution displays. However, they all offer 1080p displays in their top the line laptops which i find more than enough on a Laptop.<p>Most people are fine with their 24inch display sporting 1920x1200 resolution but then suddenly on a 13" notebook or even a smartphone 1080p isnt enough ? Its ridiculous!<p>I have used a Macbook Retina and to me it was not much of a revelation. Yep, the display is nice, text is super sharp and everything is crystal clear but i didnt have the feeling that i would absolutely need this, and i would consider myself a hardware geek and pro user.
snowwrestler大约 12 年前
Hi-res is the future of laptops because the future of laptops is to become specialty tools for content creators. Everyone else will be using phones and tablets for mobile computing.<p>So I don't understand the purpose of a hi-res "cloud" laptop. The hi-res screen is ideal for high-end photographic and video work--the two areas of content creation that are still struggling to move to the cloud.
jfb大约 12 年前
tl;dr: The low-margin OEM business is different than the high-margin software/integrated systems business.
guard-of-terra大约 12 年前
Other laptops can't use high definition displays because Windows would not look and feel nice on them.<p>MS behaved as if they can ignore the display progress forever, and now it's finally bites them and their minions in the rear, which is lovely.
gibbitz大约 12 年前
Do we really need retina displays? Or are they just trying to make something new for us to spend money on? Right now Sony ASUS and Lenovo are doing fine. Nice headline. You got me to read the first paragraph or so.
评论 #5287608 未加载
DrinkWater大约 12 年前
tl;dr: this article wastes your time
Gotttzsche大约 12 年前
can't one just install a different OS? or is the chromebook pixel using some weird hardware?
评论 #5286084 未加载
评论 #5286083 未加载
recoiledsnake大约 12 年前
&#62;Sony, Asus, and Lenovo all have notebooks at similar prices, but none have a high density display and none have only solid state storage.<p>Huh what? A lot of ultrabooks have only SSDs, has the author been in coma for the last year?<p>Sony has a Vaio Duo 11" with a 1080p display. Lenovo and Asus also have or are about to have high density displays.<p>All in all, an empty uninsightful fluff piece.<p>Also, please get some contrast and test how your blog looks on the machines that aren't (retina) Macs.<p><a href="http://contrastrebellion.com/" rel="nofollow">http://contrastrebellion.com/</a>
评论 #5286107 未加载
评论 #5286390 未加载
评论 #5286087 未加载
OGinparadise大约 12 年前
How did this end with so many votes? It has nothing to do with the puck, but with money. Pay up and they'll add a 42 inch screen to your Windows 8 laptop, battery hour 36 seconds :). They are many tradeoffs, that's all.
评论 #5286251 未加载