TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

I hired someone with Asperger's – now what?

115 点作者 rtexal大约 12 年前

26 条评论

fein大约 12 年前
I find it rather annoying that people like myself get lumped into this as well when such broad definitions are being used.<p>Do I prefer to be alone/ in a small group most of the time? Hell yes! It's more exclusive and I get more work done. In a social situation, less people means more signal, less noise.<p>Do I sometimes completely avoid social situations? Of course! But it's solely due to the fact that sometimes, I just can't be arsed to care about dealing with someones trite problems.<p>When push comes to shove and I need to be social with large groups, there isn't an issue aside from the usual inherent "stage fright", but this is a quality that can affect anyone that doesn't spend the majority of their time as a public speaker.<p>Some of us exhibit the "qualities" in the article purely by choice, not by challenge. I'm pretty sure at some point in my youth, some poor misguided soul tried to diagnose me with some placement on the spectrum, but I would say that nowadays this incorrect classification is more common than not. Had someone told me every day that I was an autist, maybe I would have ended up exhibiting more of those behaviors simply by association. Maybe we should make a slight effort to stop telling schoolchildren that they're special or different, and more time letting people fend for themselves a bit first.
评论 #5539421 未加载
评论 #5538992 未加载
评论 #5539113 未加载
评论 #5539776 未加载
hh22大约 12 年前
As someone who was diagnosed with Aspberger syndrome, reading that article made me want to throw up. There can be significant differences between a number of people with the same diagnosis, and generalizing them all under one mocking nickname of "aspie" is disrespectful. My diagnosis is not obvious to anyone talking to me unless I were to disclose it, and I have done very well in school leadership activities; I particularly enjoyed being involved in a debate club. I don't want Aspberger's to define me, and I wish that CNN would be more supportive of people who are working to overcome their disabilities instead of writing a puff piece about how special and disabled we are.
评论 #5538244 未加载
评论 #5538265 未加载
评论 #5538490 未加载
评论 #5538708 未加载
评论 #5538405 未加载
评论 #5541823 未加载
miles_matthias大约 12 年前
A kid in my CS program and my dorms in college had Asperger's and I'd probably hire him, depending on the company. He is an absolutely brilliant person who would read a textbook in a night and immediately have all of it committed to memory and able to use in a problem. He would program in classes because he already knew everything the professor was lecturing on, only stopping to raise his hand and correct the teacher when they flubbed up or weren't totally clear. (By the end of our program teachers were trying to make sure they didn't have him in their classes.)<p>He did a few jobs during school and a buddy of mine worked with him at a software development shop. He said that they put him (my co-student with Asperger's), in an office by himself with a computer and a desk phone and gave him assignments of things to code. His code was awesome, but whenever he wanted to ask someone about a project he was working on, people rarely answered him. Being the genius that he was, he figured out how to hack his office phone to be able to transmit his voice through every office speaker in the entire office without anyone having to pick up their phone. They quickly started answering him more.<p>So my $.02 are the same with working with any individual - understand who they are, what they care about, and give them what they need. My co-student with Asperger's was a total genius in CS (actually he was a CE double major now that I think of it), but ultimately had trouble getting people to just listen to him.
mosselman大约 12 年前
The posed question is kind of offensive and arrogant if you think of it. It is kind of along the lines of 'Will/do you hire someone who is a woman/foreign/handicapped/ugly?' Suddenly the proposed properties are super offensive. "Women are smart", "Women think differently", etc. "Dave Wellman has managed several employees who were women." Eh what?<p>How about asking "Will/do you hire someone who is good for the job?". The question asked here though is more along the lines of "Will/do discriminate in your hiring process and how much?"<p>Furthermore the article is pretty biased, for example: "Aspies are intelligent -- and independent".<p>I have met dumb 'aspies'. I don't know about figures, but I would argue that there are both dumb and intelligent 'aspies'.
评论 #5539276 未加载
molbioguy大约 12 年前
As others here have pointed out, "Asperger's" covers a broad spectrum of behaviors and it's not fair to a) put this label on anyone who displays some of the behaviors (that covers too many people), nor b) try to minimize the diversity of behaviors by focusing on just a few (the diversity is much, much greater). The same thing happens with the horribly named "gifted" label. People only focus on the high achievers and completely miss the fact that not all gifted or Asperger's fit that stereotype. It's just so easy to label people and move on without really considering what's going on. A great article called the "Misunderstood face of giftedness" on this was just in Huffington Post <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/marianne-kuzujanakis/gifted-children_b_2948258.html" rel="nofollow">http://www.huffingtonpost.com/marianne-kuzujanakis/gifted-ch...</a>
catzhang大约 12 年前
Don't worry. Asperger's syndrome will be removed from DSM-5 next month. So next month, the person won't have the syndrome anymore...The syndrome won't even exist anymore...<p><a href="http://www2.macleans.ca/2012/12/04/aspergers-syndrome-to-be-removed-from-psychiatrists-diagnostic-guide/" rel="nofollow">http://www2.macleans.ca/2012/12/04/aspergers-syndrome-to-be-...</a>
评论 #5538627 未加载
评论 #5538661 未加载
DanBC大约 12 年前
The UK has concepts of "Reasonable adjustments". Some things are intrinsic parts of a job. A taxi driver must be able to drive. An accountant does not need to be able to drive. Thus, you can justifiably not employ someone for a taxi driver if their disability prevents them from driving, but you could not justifiably not employ an accountant if their disability meant they could not drive.<p>&#62; <i>As a manager, you should understand how to handle the unique opportunities and challenges that come with hiring an Aspie.</i><p>Wait, what? This is weird. Now tell us what it's like employing Jews.<p>I generally agree with the intent of the article but it comes over a bit "Oh the proud and noble Aspie".<p>&#62; They will never accept "no" for an answer without being told the reason for it.<p>That's probably true, but some people with Asperger's will have given up on asking why, knowing that sometimes people use stupid incomprehensible bizarre sub-optimal reasons. When someone tells me no I tend to just accept it, because I know that asking why leads to a rabbit-hole of bitter argument and disappointment.<p>I sound overly critical of the article. I don't mean to. Oh well.
评论 #5540697 未加载
pessimizer大约 12 年前
Asperger's doesn't particularly exist. IIRC it is being removed from the DSM-V; 99.5% of sufferers are self-diagnosed with information that they found on the internet, and sometimes have confirmed with helpful psychiatrists.<p>The criteria seems to be that one has a terrible personality, is simultaneously high-maintenance and inconsiderate of others, thinks very highly of one's self, but lacks any other connection with the autism spectrum.
评论 #5538888 未加载
评论 #5538966 未加载
评论 #5539741 未加载
评论 #5540569 未加载
评论 #5539715 未加载
评论 #5539120 未加载
MoOmer大约 12 年前
If I was a person with Aspergers, I would be extremely annoyed that the term 'Aspie' is used here. Why not, 'for these people,' type of wording? Coining or perpetuating a term like that only serves to isolate anyone that might otherwise have been just a person with Aspergers.
评论 #5539745 未加载
评论 #5539656 未加载
评论 #5540339 未加载
评论 #5540276 未加载
hjay大约 12 年前
Reading this post makes me wonder if I have Asperger's...it pretty much described me to a tee.<p>Extremely uncomfortable in crowds/parties (actually, I pretty much refuse to attend parties at all), always looking at something else when speaking to someone 1 on 1, "rambling" when describing something or telling a story when someone else would only take 1~2 sentences, speaking my mind and a tendency to avoid small talk, and sensitive in terms of how I react to something (I tend to over-analyze and find a reason for everything that involves me).<p>That being said, does anyone know how accurate his list is?
评论 #5540332 未加载
评论 #5540271 未加载
bradleyjg大约 12 年前
In the US it's illegal for any employee to flat out refuse to hire people with Asperger's syndrome under the Americans with Disabilities Act.<p>Just something to keep in mind before you answer the question in the title!
评论 #5538834 未加载
ambiate大约 12 年前
Coming to a blog post, why most computer specialists relate to autism. It is very important to keep in mind there is a broad spectrum. Holding two strong relationships with a total of three children with Asperger's or high functioning autism (ages: 3-6, 7-9, 10-12) and a few here and there, it has really broadened my view on the subject.<p>First, language is a barrier. Social awkwardness naturally follows that barrier. Trained social reflexes and loosely coupled connections and relationships. From an industry perspective, computer specialists seem to form a deeper relationship and bonds with the logical machine.<p>Social skills are a technical trait that can be trained... 'why are you looking at me while I use the urinal?' In my experience, these children live on rules, and the rules define them as an adult. Computers are rule based too.<p>Zoning, stimming, and hyperfocusing seem to be common characteristics in the spectrum. Countless hours spinning objects, humming notes, doing routines, slightly ocd to an extent. Much like the caffeinated nights at the terminal for endless hours.<p>Multitasking as an obvious detour from an objective. Focus on a, achieve a, move on to b. Multitasking skills are found in the ADHD varieties, but interestingly, my observation has been a determined rigorous approach to solve solutions. Tinker until it is done. Modify. Read the rules manual word for word XOR ignore it completely. We see this behavior in our field.<p>Egos and emotions. Nothing more to say.<p>And I too have Asperger's syndrome. I have never been formally diagnosed with testing, partly because it was unheard of in my time. I visited a psych last year and she was shocked that my symptoms had not been tied to the spectrum. Yet, I am a trained individual, hyperfocusing my way to my goals and have been without guidance. My main issues stem from processing/speaking language. I am strong willed, persistent, introverted, curious, clever, quirky, and shy. I've self medicated my Asperger's and ADD with depression and anxiety... ruining my social reflection to the world.<p>The computer is my relationship. It is my mind, body, and soul. If something goes wrong, it is either my fault, someone's fault, or fixable. No quirky social rules to interpret and apply to the problem. Phone conferences in the phreaking days and IRC had my friends for the longest time.<p>The question 'is will/do you hire someone with Asperger's syndrome?', and the answer is: 'if they are qualified.'<p>Some of you will be parents soon. If you see the signs, get your children enrolled in a speech therapy program.<p>Peak their interests with gears (KNEX), LEDs and motors and batteries, circular/cylindrical objects, simple math/chemistry in the home.<p>The sooner the rules begin to form, the less the fear applies, grabs hold, and ruins the experience. Warn them about the quadratic equation, Bayes', matrices... years in advance. Eradicate the fear, spawn the curiosity.
评论 #5538481 未加载
评论 #5539886 未加载
评论 #5540593 未加载
评论 #5540016 未加载
评论 #5540812 未加载
评论 #5540232 未加载
AndyNemmity大约 12 年前
Sounds like a lot of us here fit the description pretty well.<p>I'm not convinced this is anything more than the various styles of potential people. Take for example that I don't read or watch fiction. I haven't been able to cope with it my whole life. I read non-fiction and much prefer it.<p>Is that a preference? Is that some meaningful indication about who I am?<p>I don't know. I am hearing the spectrum answer from a lot of people. That sounds like an answer with no way to refute it, so the value of it is meaningless.<p>I really don't know much about this topic, and haven't given it the time to learn. My input is not particularly valuable in this discussion.<p>However my best guess is that this is trying to explain the range of human possibility with a diagnosis as opposed to simply thinking that there are different people with different traits, and that's all okay.<p>I used to be "unable" to do a lot of tasks of a business professional and just coded and worked alone.<p>Then I was promoted until I was unable to do what I was good at, and has to learn how to do the business tasks. Now I am doing them.<p>It wasn't that I was unable. I just didn't desire to do it on my own, and wasn't in a position where I had to regardless.<p>I sort of think of all of this like ADHD. The majority of parents I know tell me their kid has ADHD, and many are on medication for it.<p>And I watch them feed their children coke regularly.
评论 #5541190 未加载
lutusp大约 12 年前
If the consequences weren't so tragic, I would laugh out loud at all this about Asperger's. Consider the following points:<p>1. Human evolution is still going on, and in the long term, Asperger's might represent a positive evolutionary adaptation, especially in a world increasingly dependent on technology. Only nature knows, and nature doesn't reveal her secrets willingly.<p>2 After a recent epidemic of overdiagnoses, psychologists are reluctantly abandoning the Asperger's diagnosis -- it's being removed from the DSM. The reason? Too many people wanted the diagnosis -- it was the first truly fashionable mental illness. After all, Isaac Newton, Albert Einstein, and Bill Gates are/were thought to have this "disease".<p>3. There is a positive psychological trait called "Grit":<p><a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grit_(personality_trait)" rel="nofollow">http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grit_(personality_trait)</a><p>People who have "grit" tend to focus on a few objectives, or just one, for months or years. It's a "good thing™" -- psychologists say so. But the exact same behavior can lead to an Asperger's diagnosis. Have psychologists resolved this contradiction? Not remotely.<p>As far as I'm concerned, and in the opinion of an increasing number of psychologists, Asperger's refers to something real, but it shouldn't have been categorized as a mental illness -- unless intelligence should also be listed.<p>If psychology was a science this might all be different, but there's little hope for that.<p>More on this topic: <a href="http://arachnoid.com/building_science" rel="nofollow">http://arachnoid.com/building_science</a>
malaporte大约 12 年前
Hmm I sometimes wonder if I might not have this thing. I do share quite a lot of characteristics they describe...
评论 #5538267 未加载
评论 #5538246 未加载
lnanek2大约 12 年前
Reminds me of working at Noom. The management were complete crooks. They'd lie in job ads and justify it by saying they get more people to apply, agree to things in public company wide meetings then quash them in private when it didn't look as bad, pirate software then toot their PR horn saying if any employee needs any software for their job they'd buy it, frequently forget to pay you or pay too little unless you fought for the right amount, etc.. Very difficult culture for someone who likes logical connection between things and details that all make sense put together.
johnrgrace大约 12 年前
I believe, without hard date to support, that the more HR people a company has in general, the less likely they are to hire people with Asperger's. And if those same companies do hire an employee review process that becomes very political/subjective/social is going to filter employees with asperger's out.<p><pre><code> If you have a job that fits their skills and don't ding them for not say golfing with the "team" I think there are opportunities to pick up highly talented people that other companies are not chasing who will stick around.</code></pre>
swayvil大约 12 年前
I'm a sperg. I'm getting better. Meditation, vipassana. It uncramps your soul, unravels deep habits of attention, or something. It's miraculous.<p>Anybody here relate?
评论 #5539943 未加载
p6v53as大约 12 年前
"I have Asperger's: I am just like you"<p>Um, not to hate or anything, but there is a reason it is called autistic syndrome. Autistic people lack the ability to form a "theory of brain", which means they just do not understand other people's intentions that well. You can't ignore this fact and hope it will go away.
评论 #5538545 未加载
评论 #5539051 未加载
brian_wendt大约 12 年前
<a href="http://www.ted.com/talks/temple_grandin_the_world_needs_all_kinds_of_minds.html" rel="nofollow">http://www.ted.com/talks/temple_grandin_the_world_needs_all_...</a><p>This TedTalks takes an interesting approach to Autism in the professional world. Enjoy.
nichols大约 12 年前
You might need to adjust your leadership style. For example, use hand puppets rather than giving instructions directly. Also start referring to yourself in the third person; that usually helps.
websitescenes大约 12 年前
Do I have Aspergers if I fit the description of one almost exactly? The author seemed to be describing me.. I am pretty socially capable and I can look people in the eye, so I don't know.
评论 #5539731 未加载
评论 #5539702 未加载
cwbrandsma大约 12 年前
According to this article, I have Aspergers. Or maybe I'm a low functioning dyslexic. Or maybe I'm a high functioning autistic.<p>Oh forget about it. I'm going back to work.
pmelendez大约 12 年前
This is relevant:<p>Simon Baron-Cohen Autistic Spectrum Test<p><a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LYys7rhRcDU" rel="nofollow">http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LYys7rhRcDU</a>
michaelochurch大约 12 年前
This brings me to one of the ways in which humans fail. People understand that ethical character is important-- far more important than talent-- but it's also hard-to-impossible to assess at an individual level based on real-world imperfection of information, so they fall back on social polish and low-signal bullshit that might even be negatively correlated with genuine moral decency, autism and psychopathy being opposites of a certain spectrum.<p>People just don't have the tools to assess others' intentions or real character. Instead of admitting that their machinery for doing this is error-prone, they come up with stories about other people that have no basis in reality. The socially marginal or unskilled get screwed.<p>If anything, I think that people with Asperger's are, on average, slightly better (morally speaking) than the general population. Most people get stuck at Kohlberg's Stage 3 of moral development (although, in the corporate world, they speak a Stage 4 language, dressing social smears up as "performance problems"). People with Asperger's tend to skip Stage 3 (because they fundamentally <i>don't get it</i>) and land early in 4, which means they have an above-normal likelihood of progressing to 5-6.
guard-of-terra大约 12 年前
How do you know you haven't already? It's not that they walk with "ASPERGER" painted on their backs.
评论 #5540288 未加载