TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

What the Heck Is Happening in Turkey? A FAQ for the Rest of Us

25 点作者 richeyrw将近 12 年前

2 条评论

diminoten将近 12 年前
Democracy has always struck me as an interesting form of government, precisely for the reason being shown here: If the voting wasn't rigged, and we have no reason to believe it was, then Erdoğan was indeed voted into office according to the laws of Turkey, and thus has about as legitimate a reason to do what he's doing as anyone in his position would, at least if you buy into how a representative democracy works.<p>So then a man who was ostensibly elected by his people starts taking actions that <i>some</i> (it's not all) of his people disagree strongly with, and they attempt to show that disagreement in the form of protesting. So far so good, right? The system is working, about as well as it can. There is a vocal minority attempting to gather numbers by protesting the actions of an elected official the minority disagrees with. That sounds like a country I'd like to live in, right?<p>But then the oppression begins, and here is why this got so bad, from what I've just read: out come the tear gas and the riot shields. This goes from a beautiful process of democracy in action to what we in the US would call a blatant violation of First Amendment Rights (capital F, A and R). Now you've got a national incident, which grows as the mistreatment grows, and soon it's an international incident that looks a <i>little bit</i> like what many other countries in the area have gone through, which lead to the ending of a government. But it's not that, because what would you replace this government with? A democracy? That's what got them to this point in the first place.<p>So what exactly happens now? By all rights, Erdoğan should remain in office for the remainder of his term. How can the protesters ask for anything else? He is, after all, a fairly elected leader of their country. I honestly don't know what the alternative would be. I keep trying to imagine how this would go down in America, and I can't imagine a President stepping down because of violent protesting in NYC or D.C..
评论 #5816492 未加载
cup将近 12 年前
That article was much more informattive than most that have been posted on HN but it still misses a lot of issues. For instance it leaves out the fact that Erdogans party first came into party with 35% of the votes. That shows that theres been a steady inccrease in support for his party over the years.<p>I think HNs need to realise theres more to this than a simple park and underlying social tension. There are a lot more issues at play. There are political parties taking advantage of these protest tto cause social tension. There is unacceptable police violence which is fueling protestor anger and there is a constant superficial narrative as to why these protesst have started and continued. This is a very complex issue which isn't black and white and which can't be summed up in a 140 character tweet!