TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

You Can't Fix People

25 点作者 blackhole超过 11 年前

18 条评论

StandardFuture超过 11 年前
Hmmm. The hypocrisy is blatant. He apparently hates the way &quot;people&quot; are. Yet, at the same time he hates other people who also hate the way people are i.e. sexists and racists?!?!?<p>I apologize for the following but: Are you fucking kidding me?!?<p>Does he truly believe that he is alone in dealing with people? Do we not all deal with people? Is this not a core component of life and of <i>cough</i> growing up <i>cough</i>?!?!?<p>Have not many individuals over the ages dealt with their differences in various ways? Some dealings being better than others?<p>&gt;I can never escape these problems, because they are people.<p>Why are &quot;people&quot; the problem? Why do you overgeneralize so easily? Yet, you ask so hypocritically:<p>&gt;How do you get people to stop making terrible assumptions about other people?<p>This article should not be upvoted. If you are &quot;tired&quot; of dealing with people, as the author, I can almost guarantee that you have not spent enough time searching. Don&#x27;t end your search to find good people with premature conclusions that sadly this author has jumped too.
评论 #6270043 未加载
评论 #6270299 未加载
angersock超过 11 年前
I think that one of the most frustrating aspects of dealing with people (at least for myself, as I&#x27;m loathe to extend my experiences to others) is that they fail several key things:<p>People are not:<p>* linear time-invariant<p>* rational<p>* abstractable<p>By the first, I mean two things. People do not react proportionally to a change in input--raising your voice slightly or disagreeing somewhat harder may suddenly get you punched in the nose instead of just yelled back at somewhat more, or being even nicer to somebody may not return any change whatsoever. Moreover, the same input applied at a later time may completely change the reaction of a person--a harmless text message repeated at a later date could set a person off.<p>By the second, I mean that people simply do not follow a logical chain in most situation. Given a set of rules and inputs, you&#x27;d think that a person (and even their mental state) would behave predictably; this is obviously false if you&#x27;ve ever done business or sold to consumers or dated.<p>By the third (possibly the largest), I mean that people can&#x27;t be reasoned about at a high level. You simply <i>can&#x27;t</i> ignore or approximate all of the little minutiae that make up that person&#x27;s background, and if you try you&#x27;ll find that everything falls to pieces. &quot;Every girl likes compliments&quot; fails, &quot;every customer wants the cheapest goods&quot; fails, every abstraction falls over in contact with the enemy.<p>EDIT:<p>People seem to be reacting negatively to the opening statements of the article. When I read it, I interpreted it as the author trying to express the idea that even massively difficult technical problems are still amendable to standard problem-solving techniques, in implicit contrast to &quot;people problems&quot; which the author finds elusive.<p>A correct reading, I suggest, would be that the opening is more an attempt at example than braggadocio.
评论 #6270017 未加载
georgebonnr超过 11 年前
What&#x27;s a problem solver to do? To put it crudely, stop being so judgemental. And stop viewing people as problems. Stop defining persons&#x27; entire identities by one (admittedly awful) behavior or attitude they exhibit. People are more complex than that. And you&#x27;re not just a &quot;problem solver.&quot; You&#x27;re many other things... Some good, some bad. Some probably as bad as being a sexist or a racist, depending on how you look at things. Life is not math. In all seriousness the best suggestion I have is to try to maintain an attitude of extreme charity towards all people, and to constantly re-focus on the things that you and they hold in common as human beings with needs, wants, intentions, and desires.
RyanZAG超过 11 年前
You can&#x27;t fix people, but you can fix a person. It&#x27;s the same as saying you can&#x27;t create a usable UI that allows any possible data to be entered, but you definitely can create a usable UI for some specific data. So the reason you&#x27;ve come to the conclusion that fixing people is impossible is because you&#x27;re trying to fix everyone at once, and each person needs their own solution.<p>Even better, some people don&#x27;t even need fixing. Devote your time to just a few people and the problem disappears.
评论 #6269942 未加载
rdegges超过 11 年前
Oh man, I really enjoyed reading this because I&#x27;ve felt the exact same way most of my life (as a matter of fact, I still do feel this way quite often).<p>Dealing with people is incredibly hard because everyone has biases, experiences, and lives of their own -- and regardless of how much you try to put yourself into someone else&#x27;s shoes -- to understand why this person is the way they are -- there is simply no way to ever truly understand how someone feels and acts.<p>People can be hateful, ignorant, and mean to one another -- but at the same time, people can also be kinda, loving, and compassionate.<p>I&#x27;ve found that the best way to get around the constant anxiety that goes along with wanting to help and <i>fix</i> everyone I come across is to try my best to be accepting of people the way they are.<p>Nowadays when I meet new people, I try to have no expectations: instead of building up a mental image of this person in my head, and assigning them an identity (this person is nice, or this person is smart, or whatever) -- I instead try to be fully <i>present</i> in the moment and let things happen as they will.<p>Not only does this help me deal with social anxiety a lot, but also helps me relax and feel more comfortable about myself, knowing that I&#x27;m constantly trying to live in the moment, accept reality (and people) as they are, and live my life the way I choose regardless of outside influences.<p>It&#x27;s incredibly hard to do this, but all the effort pays off (at least it does for me).<p>Thank you for sharing your story.
solistice超过 11 年前
Well, we don&#x27;t have a framework for fixing a person, no state where a person is considered whole.<p>Imagine you&#x27;re fixing a car. There&#x27;s a (relatively) clear spec on when it&#x27;s considered fixed, and you strive to get there. You can get there by following instructions, or you can get there by experimentation.<p>Without knowledge of what is considered fixed, you&#x27;re making shots in the dark. A lot of people are, and you have a chaotic system.<p>Comming up with a framework for what a person should strive to be is technically a job for philosophy, but that&#x27;s not working, is it? We seem to be naturally change averse, and a lot of philosophical works boil down to rationalizing what you are doing is right. Kant reads like the bible of irresponsibility (What is the &quot;Kathegorischer Imperativ&quot; exept absolving responsibility to a higher mandate?), and Nietsche reads like he&#x27;s trying to give you a free pass for everything provided you&#x27;re the Supermensch (and who doesn&#x27;t class themselves that way?).<p>No, creating frameworks is a dangerous game, and I&#x27;ve stopped trusting anyone to do a proper job at it. All religions I know of failed at it to various degrees (look at that track record for gods sake! They&#x27;re still being used to justify murder). Most philosophers had their ideas tried out (as far as that was viable), and those approaches again didn&#x27;t work out perfectly.<p>And here we&#x27;re sitting, no idea how to do things, but hellbent on doing something. It&#x27;s amazing we figured out science, which is why we can figure out those problems easily. But philosophy? We don&#x27;t seem to have progressed there.<p>So yeah, fixing people is about as futile (right now) as physics has been before the scientific method.
afhof超过 11 年前
From a completely selfish standpoint, shouldn&#x27;t you try fixing yourself first rather than &quot;fixing&quot; other people?
评论 #6270058 未加载
kor023超过 11 年前
Former Ku Klux Klan leader Johnny Lee Clary on Enough Rope with Andrew Denton <a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IqV-egZOS1E" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=IqV-egZOS1E</a><p>Just as a counter point..
mynameishere超过 11 年前
The cascading narcissism is ridiculous, but then the paranoia shows itself...<p><i>They will do everything in their power to destroy all my efforts at building a better world</i><p>...and it just becomes kind of pathetic.
评论 #6269910 未加载
gulfie超过 11 年前
1) In this case fixing seems to be behavior(or thought) modification. 2) We fix people all the time. 3) Industries are built on it. 3) Fixing people is what pays for the internet of today.<p>$557 Billion USD, of fixes just this year alone.<p><a href="http://nielsen.com/us/en/newswire/2013/global-ad-spend-grows-3.2-percent-in-2012.html" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;nielsen.com&#x2F;us&#x2F;en&#x2F;newswire&#x2F;2013&#x2F;global-ad-spend-grows...</a><p>We fix people all the time.
quasque超过 11 年前
Not that I agree with the connotations of &quot;fix&quot; as used in this piece - but why do you want to fix people in the first place? It&#x27;s not your responsibility.<p>If certain people bother you, then the best you can do is try to change your own outlook and circumstances to deal better with the negativity you feel towards their behaviour.<p>Or to put it another way, the only person you&#x27;re responsible for fixing is yourself.
level09超过 11 年前
This brings back to my mind the popular blog post by Aaron swartz: Fix the machine, not the person : <a href="http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/nummi" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.aaronsw.com&#x2F;weblog&#x2F;nummi</a><p>I personally think only few people can be fixed, those who are very intelligent and who know how to get over human nature and their cognitive biases.
ckevinc超过 11 年前
Appears to be down.<p>Google&#x27;s cache of the article: <a href="http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:Ti31eUMHA00J:blackhole12.blogspot.com/2013/08/you-cant-fix-people.html+&amp;cd=1&amp;hl=en&amp;ct=clnk&amp;gl=ca" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;webcache.googleusercontent.com&#x2F;search?q=cache:Ti31eUM...</a>
dylangs1030超过 11 年前
You could have done without the first three paragraphs.<p>Other than that...I&#x27;m not sure what else to comment. Of course you can&#x27;t fix people. If we could, we&#x27;d live in a utopia where everyone was happy and operated efficiently.
ChrisAntaki超过 11 年前
You can talk with people.
评论 #6269917 未加载
gulfie超过 11 年前
The comments were better than the article.
ramgp超过 11 年前
What happen with article is now down?
st8ic超过 11 年前
&quot;people r dum&quot;, writes self-righteous neckbeard.
评论 #6270065 未加载