TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

A new type of Y Combinator

23 点作者 urlwolf超过 11 年前

6 条评论

gaborcselle超过 11 年前
Having to show results to your fellow founders every week at your in-person meeting is extremely motivating. Doing everything via Google Hangouts doesn&#x27;t allow for the sort of serendipitous encounters that happen at the weekly meetings. Investors come to Demo Day not just to see the newest batch of companies, but also to meet with others.<p>I&#x27;m skeptical that this would work.
monsterix超过 11 年前
Edit: I think PG answered this accurately in just one line above. The following thoughts might help the OP.<p>I think this has been tried before, with nReduce[1]. And failed. Story of taking a company off the ground is not so simple. And that story doesn&#x27;t separate the role of investors and founders in such a discreet unattached manner:<p>&gt; <i>Founders focus exclusively on the startup. Investors care primarily about traction and who else is investing, so these decisions can be made remotely</i><p>No it doesn&#x27;t work like that. Founders and investors together focus on the startup == traction i.e. building something that people want. That sense of togetherness gives the baby startup a chance of survival. Success is not guaranteed even then, mind you.<p>For other points:<p>&gt; 1. Everything is remote.<p>I doubt this is even possible. Incorporation, paperwork is but one moment&#x2F;small step of creating a company. It could be done remotely even today.<p>&gt; 2. Cohorts are rolling.<p>Perhaps this is possible, however it&#x27;s important not to discount the energy, vibe and support system of the batch psychology.<p>&gt; 3. Partners are decoupled. You can book time with anyone and you know exactly what they specialize in, so there are no wasted meetings.<p>I think this would be hard on partners simply because he&#x2F;she would be bombarded and not have enough time to digest and respond effectively. Also there is a saying that <i>when the student is ready, the teacher appears</i>.<p>&gt; 4. Decisions made in 48 hours.<p>Handling anxiety and calm is one great attribute to have in entrepreneurship. That said, quicker decision making is always good unless rushed too soon.<p>&gt; 5. Demo days all over the world. Demo days would be expanded out to metro hubs: LA, SF, NYC, etc. Kickstarter operates well and it’s run entirely online.<p>By &#x27;all over the world&#x27; and LA, SF, NYC I think you mean just America. There could be a solution to demoing all over the world. Getting covered on Tech news and blogs is a form of it. The question is whom do you want to demo to?<p>[1] <a href="http://venturebeat.com/2012/05/28/nreduce/" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;venturebeat.com&#x2F;2012&#x2F;05&#x2F;28&#x2F;nreduce&#x2F;</a>
pg超过 11 年前
The fundamental flaw here is underestimating the value of in-person conversation.
评论 #6383357 未加载
rjvir超过 11 年前
&quot;Decisions made in 48 hours&quot; would be extremely helpful for startups. Since YC only skims written applications for a few minutes and interviews applicants for about 10 min, it seems possible for them to make quick decisions.
评论 #6382993 未加载
tstonez超过 11 年前
Sounds like nReduce.com but don&#x27;t think it worked out. Agree with gaborcselle that bonding would not be the same without meeting in person. Also cohort effects are diminished with smaller rolling cohorts. Starting and finishing something at the same time is a big deal.<p>Think about your best friends. I would hazard a guess they are probably from school and college. Now compare to friends you&#x27;ve made taking MOOCs (i.e., remote) and at work (i.e., rolling cohorts). Over simplified but you get the idea.
ezrasuki超过 11 年前
Yes. And it&#x27;s a stupid idea to constrain an online dating service to let people only meet on Wednesdays. Cohorts should be always rolling and you should be able to meet up anytime you want. Also, to get rid of the bottleneck that is offline meetup, it should let people meet up exclusively through Google Hangouts. This will let people date virtually all over the world.
评论 #6382982 未加载