TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Ask HN: How can I encourage my co-workers to grow further as engineers?

5 点作者 ctb_mg超过 11 年前
I am an engineer at a small software&#x2F;systems engineering firm in the midwest. In terms of competency, I&#x27;ve noticed 3 types of engineers:<p>1. Those who need direct guidance. They perform one task and stop. They don&#x27;t follow through on their analysis of issues or dig deeper to find underlying cause of problems. There&#x27;s no high level thought process or context; rather, high level analysis is limited as they don&#x27;t have the domain knowledge to understand the full system they&#x27;re working on (they don&#x27;t care to find out or don&#x27;t realize the value in understanding the entire system).<p>2. Engineers in between the above and below groups. Usually fairly technically savvy -- can handle typical engineering tasks with competency, but lack motivation or don&#x27;t actively seek out how to grow as an engineer. They stagnate without a great manager&#x2F;tech lead pushing them to the boundaries.<p>3. Engineers who are extremely proficient. Implementing features and finding the cause of problems is not an issue for them -- regardless of the feature, language, framework, whatever. These engineers go and figure out how to get it done. These engineers are only limited by their dependencies and business requirements. If you told them to implement a time machine in software, they would figure out the closest possible way to do it, and provide you with a full technical analysis of how it works -- and what the shortfalls are.<p>As a fellow engineer, how do I encourage my coworkers to move from groups 1-2 into group 3?<p>There is little in the way of technical training at the workplace; if there were, it wouldn&#x27;t teach the core skill of just plain getting on with it -- dig as deep as you can, find core problems, understand your system, grow as an engineer. In general there is a sense of laziness among engineers and a &quot;wait to be told what to do&quot; mindset.<p>Any thoughts or advice?

6 条评论

professorTuring超过 11 年前
This is not a how-to, but have a look at this (I have this very same problem): <a href="https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6920376" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=6920376</a><p>Now my teammates are completely in the path. Motivation is the key point here, they told me at the beginning &quot;you have just arrived here, you will not be so &quot;willing&quot; when you have some years on your back&quot;. But then I showed them I am relentless I have showed the benefits of &quot;doing&quot; and &quot;going further&quot;. How? I don&#x27;t have a clear answer but I believe something like:<p>1. I study a problem or a path.<p>2. I try to speak about it to my boss (and I don&#x27;t usually give credit to what he say since he a &quot;1&quot; type).<p>3. I do what I think it bets better to the enterprise&#x2F;team<p>4. I show it to my boss and colleagues and speak about the issue&#x2F;problem&#x2F;technology...<p>5. They don&#x27;t give a shit about it.<p>6. I continue my path (meanwhile they continue their path) until they realize that my path is simpler, funnier, better, or rewarding.<p>7. They usually want to meet again to &quot;re-speak&quot; about the technology&#x2F;problem&#x2F;issue... whatever.<p>8. They end up learning it and enjoying the path on learning&#x2F;studying...<p>So nowadays they are motivated by this path (just a little bit more, old your horses!) but I notice that they are much happier.<p>But, a BIG WARNING: it might happens that some people may feel threatened about you or your way. When you finish something make them feeling part of the team, congratulate them and so on... This is so much true if you are not their boss (if you are, just fire them).
brudgers超过 11 年前
Assume that each of the categories you have described exists for legitimate reasons and that each individual person has good reasons for optimizing on one of those paths and that their reasons are not yours and that there is nothing broken in them that needs fixing.<p>The most likely problem is that you&#x27;re in a place that does not require everyone to be a rock star ninja 1%er. Maybe it&#x27;s time for you to find a bigger pond. The Harvard of Arkansas ain&#x27;t Harvard.
rprospero超过 11 年前
As someone who is type 2 and is continuously working toward being class 3, I want to know why your coworkers would even want to be type 3?<p>For instance, while I&#x27;m a type 2 developer, I&#x27;m a type 1 musician and a type 1 air hockey player. If I took half the amount of effort I spend on trying to be a better developer and spent it on air hockey and music, I could be type 2 in both of those. I don&#x27;t care about being a musician or being good at air hockey, so I haven&#x27;t done those things, but that&#x27;s just a matter personal taste.<p>If I wake up tomorrow and discover I love air hockey, why should I keep working toward being a type 3 developer?
gyepi超过 11 年前
This is a good question, but based on my experience, I have come to the conclusion that the mindset that characterizes the three groups really go beyond engineering or computing. It takes a certain amount of curiousity, interest, ability, learning and so forth to have a type 3 mindset and some of that simply cannot be externally driven.<p>Having said that, encouragement is good. Share what you learn as you do it, talk about the books you&#x27;ve read and what benefit they provide. Sometimes people just need an example closer at hand to see their own potential.<p>In the end, it really up to each person to decide how they want to approach life.
评论 #7190293 未加载
darkxanthos超过 11 年前
Focus less on: * Comparing them to you * Changing them<p>Focus more on: * Identifying and leveraging their strengths * Position your self as a Silvers type leader. Be a first follower to any of their ideas that you think can be tweaked to hold water.<p>That last one may be non-obvious. Learning to be a first follower promotes humility in yourself, supporting others, and showing others how to lead and follow. When others lead their &#x27;laziness&#x27; (I hate that word) begins to dissipitate.
gesman超过 11 年前
There is a bigger world exist beyond being an engineer. Some of your coworkers are wonder how they can help you to move beyond that mentality.