TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Are journalism schools teaching their students the right skills?

22 点作者 _pius大约 11 年前

9 条评论

tsunamifury大约 11 年前
I sit on the boards of two Journalism schools and attended the top Masters program just before the journalism crash of 2009. I am on these boards mostly because both schools think that some guy in Silicon Valley has insight into what journalism students should be doing. Its not true.<p>The problem was that massive disruption of print media really came to a head due to the great recession, when low media buys plus a real uptick of traction from ad networks put a final nail in a lot of print journalists careers.<p>Looking back its easy to think if they were more tech savvy they could have somehow survived -- but thats just not the case. Tech and journalism are more closely related than ever, and specifically scripted languages and knowledge of markup (CSS and JS Libraries) can improve the final product&#x27;s production quality, but journalists are not programmers no should they be. Its similar to saying journalists should know how to roll their own print presses in the 50s -- its not their job.<p>The problem lies more in the fact that we simply can&#x27;t fund journalists to do their job anymore. We charge them with both doing investigative reporting, staying neutral and coming up with a sustainable business model for it -- and you know what? Its just too much to ask. Local news stations are slowly dying out, local newspapers are already mostly thinned out and upstarts like Patch (flawed as it was) were not able to fund real journalistic work.<p>After a few years going back and forth on this I have come to believe that a BBC like model in the US would do the nation great deal of good. Funding journalists to do their job and keep up the good work without pressuring them to make compromises is essentially to keeping voters informed.<p>I hope we can get over our mindset that all things need to be privatized at some point in the near future and begin funding PBS, NPR, and local news to keep doing what they are doing.
评论 #7664365 未加载
InclinedPlane大约 11 年前
Um, no. Next question.<p>The very idea of journalism schools is that the most important aspect of journalism is journalism specific knowledge. Knowing how to write in just the right way. Knowing how to keep your word count down. Knowing how to write on a schedule. Knowing how to mold the material into a familiar shape.<p>But most of that is bullshit. It produces a grey ooze of pablum, and it reinforces the conceit that journalists are more knowledgeable than they truly are and, more importantly, that by following the &quot;news&quot; we can become educated in the important topics relevant to our time.<p>Nothing could be further from the truth. The reality is that most of the time it takes someone who is truly an expert (or at least a very enthusiastic amateur) in a given field to be able to understand it at a holistic level and to be able to educate the public about it. The most important factor is knowledge, not style. Typically the skills necessary to pass on that knowledge to the public are comparatively easier to pick up than the expertise itself, and not requiring of a degree in journalism.<p>If you look at the vast bulk of material that comes out of j-school graduates you notice the same things. Bland, boring copy designed to spoon feed the tiniest amount of new knowledge, often poorly understood by the writer themselves, to the public. This I would not count as a great service to humanity.<p>Edit: the crisis with j-school educated journalists today is not that journalists are insufficiently tech savvy, it&#x27;s a mistake to think that way. The issue is that journalists are becoming disintermediated. That&#x27;s what the internet does, and what it will continue to do. At the end of the day journalists are middle men. Back in the early 20th century we needed an army of middle men to collate news from around the world and format it correctly and in the appropriate terms so that it could fit and be understandable in the medium of printed newspapers. Today none of that is necessary because now transmission and storage of data is nearly trivial. We don&#x27;t need an army of formatters, we need a much smaller force of knowledgeable experts who are good at communicating. We don&#x27;t need folks rewriting the same story for hundreds of news outlets and ending up with a hundred different largely similar versions.
评论 #7664563 未加载
pervycreeper大约 11 年前
The biggest sources of bad&#x2F; inaccurate journalism that I can think of are:<p>1-Ignorance of statistics, and of how they are frequently misused.<p>2-Lack of awareness of how good arguments are conducted, and what logical fallacies commonly appear.<p>3-Insufficient awareness of how the media can create or contribute to cultural or individual biases.<p>4-A lack of an attitude of open-mindedness or fairness.<p>5-General scientific illiteracy
评论 #7666895 未加载
评论 #7664385 未加载
puppetmaster3大约 11 年前
No you are not, you are a journalist.<p>Also, If you do recruiting, you are not in tech. You are in recruiting. And so on. Else tell me something technical about graph (a data structure) search vs linked list search.<p>Outcome: when a recruiter and a marketing person argue at a python tech conference, the tech conference is just a location of their argument. They are not tech.
评论 #7664197 未加载
评论 #7663445 未加载
ProAm大约 11 年前
I think this is true of almost any profession these days. It&#x27;s hard to think of some that do not need tech skills to work. Maybe chefs? Even comedians needs to be versed in tech.
return0大约 11 年前
That&#x27;s what they said when the Telegraph, Radio, TV transformed the media landscape. They &#x27;re still not considered tech workers though.
aet大约 11 年前
Seems like that stuff should be more OJT rather than taught in school.
MrZongle2大约 11 年前
If Betteridge&#x27;s Law of Headlines doesn&#x27;t work for you, a review of what constitutes &quot;journalism&quot; these days probably will.
return0大约 11 年前
Someone wants a pay raise ....
评论 #7664098 未加载