TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

That wild ass recruiting idea

42 点作者 davecheney将近 11 年前

5 条评论

shutupalready将近 11 年前
I&#x27;m going to offer the contrary advice that hiring by employee referral is not a good approach, for these reasons:<p>1. Your genius employee does not necessarily know lots of other geniuses. In fact, he might not know anybody. Yes, there are brilliant programmers and engineers who are well-connected, but there are ten times as many brilliant programmers and engineers who are solitary, independent types. If you press them for a referral, you&#x27;ll get a referral to his brother-in-law who took some computer courses or the guy that was nice to him in university but hasn&#x27;t found a job yet.<p>2. Friends hiring friends leads to cliques. For a startup, two or three friends working together is ideal. But for a larger enterprise, you want to avoid that. Of course, cliques will form by themselves, but why create them from day 1.<p>3. It&#x27;s very cynical to say this, but chances are that your employee is not going to recommend someone smarter or harder working than he is. Why make himself look bad? (One of Paul Graham&#x27;s articles says that this is true of mediocre programmers, but not of the top ones. Perhaps when you&#x27;re starting out, you want to work in a room full of geniuses, but what if you are the top dog in the room? Are you going to bring in someone that can obviously show you up?)<p>Many hiring methods lead to negative quality direction. Example: Making all your hires from Monster.com would be a negative trend. But a lot of people seem to believe that hiring based on employee referral is a positive. I&#x27;m sure it&#x27;s not the worst way--and it&#x27;s probably much better than relying on Monster.com for instance--but I think that employee referrals lead to quality <i>loss</i> over time.
评论 #7926806 未加载
jzwinck将近 11 年前
We should acknowledge the second edge of this sword. When a company invests in its employees&#x27; networks, it not only expands its ability to recruit more people directly, it also expands its employees&#x27; ability to find new jobs.<p>This may still be a net win for everyone, but it&#x27;s complicated. Imagine you run a company and have identified a few bad employees. Surely you should not reward them by sending them to conferences, right? But wait, maybe you should, because then not only might they spend time learning, recruiting, and doing other things that might be more productive for your company than whatever they&#x27;re currently screwing up, but they might also find a new job which is both better for them and solves your problem of how to get rid of bad employees without undue liability.<p>So send your best, most loyal, most enthusiastic employees out into the world to meet other people and spread the word about your company. And send your worst ones too!
评论 #7926700 未加载
was_hellbanned将近 11 年前
Here&#x27;s a wild ass idea: have you engineers do all the resume reviews, screening calls, and interviews. Leave HR and most of management entirely out of it.<p>Then just hire people who can intelligently speak to a relevant resume, and who get along well with your group. If they don&#x27;t work out, fire them.<p>People spend entirely too much time obsessing over how to hire people, usually mumbling some nonsense about how they&#x27;ll destroy their team or be sued out of existence by a bad hire. Personally, I think it&#x27;s a combination of desperation to cover one&#x27;s own ass at all costs, and providing an illusion of control. If they&#x27;d focus on improving the workplace and their own communication rather than fretting about voodoo hiring theory, they&#x27;d be much better off.
评论 #7928721 未加载
lukasm将近 11 年前
Cronyism is the main problem. How do you solve it?<p><a href="http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/FindingGreatDevelopers.html" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.joelonsoftware.com&#x2F;articles&#x2F;FindingGreatDeveloper...</a><p>Employee referrals: may be slippery when wet
评论 #7926687 未加载
jonathanjaeger将近 11 年前
Seems like a poor prescription to ONLY go off of referrals. The bigger the company gets, the more likely people will not want to bring in talent that they might view as competition. I know that&#x27;s cynical, and perhaps placated by referral bonuses, but it could happen. Also, what about people straight out of college that find you on LinkedIn and apply to a job posting (which I did in NYC since I knew no one), and end up getting trained to be a senior employee? There are just too many scenarios where you&#x27;re limiting your pool of prospective employees, why not try everything and double down on what works without discounting new opportunities to bring talent in.