TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Poll: How religious is hacker news?

110 点作者 smallegan将近 11 年前
After seeing the top post related to OneBody the open source Church project I found myself curious as to how the rest of hacker news identified themselves spiritually. Sometimes we make assumptions about a particular group of people and this poll seems like a great way to challenge those assumptions and take a closer look at who makes up the hacker news community. So....<p>How do you identify yourself spiritually? (Please comment if you choose Other.)

41 条评论

designNERD将近 11 年前
You can be an Agnostic Atheist.<p>Agnosticism is about whether you believe you can prove the existence of God or not. Atheism and Theism is about actual belief in God.<p>One can be an Agnostic Atheist or Agnostic Theist. Agnostic atheist= I don&#x27;t know whether we can prove God exists but I don&#x27;t believe in God<p>Agnostic theist= I don&#x27;t know where we can prove the God exists or not but I do believe in God.<p>Being an agnostic is not the &quot;I&#x27;m not really sure&quot; category people have made it to be.
评论 #8088530 未加载
评论 #8088547 未加载
评论 #8088513 未加载
评论 #8088518 未加载
评论 #8088641 未加载
评论 #8088554 未加载
评论 #8088537 未加载
评论 #8088597 未加载
评论 #8088520 未加载
评论 #8088605 未加载
seanalltogether将近 11 年前
Having grown up in the church, I have honestly never found a good replacement for the sense of community and support that a church offers. Its a shame that no other non-religious organizations have been able to replicate it.
评论 #8088531 未加载
评论 #8088626 未加载
评论 #8088659 未加载
评论 #8088552 未加载
评论 #8088702 未加载
评论 #8089295 未加载
评论 #8088550 未加载
Udo将近 11 年前
It looks like this thread is being moderated off the front page, but it&#x27;s something that I think is interesting too.<p>I was astonished about the overwhelming response the church software got. Don&#x27;t get me wrong, it&#x27;s a great effort, but the sheer amount of votes it received seems somewhat out of proportion for what you&#x27;d expect a comparable project to get. So I&#x27;m curious if this Show HN maybe released some pressure in that regard.<p>But I do think the poll&#x27;s setup is mistaken, as are people who feel their particular faith should be reflected accurately. It would have been better (and less fraught with squabbling over definitions) if we kept it simple and allowed people to self-identify as non-religious, somewhat religious, and very religious.<p>To me, the intensity of faith would have been more interesting than the precise flavor. I also think there is a community aspect we could have captured as a second variable: &quot;how engaged&#x2F;motivated are you by being part of your religious community?&quot; - I suspect this is a big factor as well, maybe in some cases even more so than the actual belief in the supernatural. Who knows, but I would have loved to get some data on this.
评论 #8089304 未加载
评论 #8088862 未加载
shared4you将近 11 年前
Classifying Hinduism and Buddhism as &quot;religions&quot; in the Western sense of the word is imprecise and misleading at best.<p>You can be a Hindu atheist: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charvaka" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Charvaka</a><p>Swami Vivekananda popularized the Ramakrishna school of thought, but they themselves deny to be called Hindus.<p>Goa deputy Chief Minister considers himself to be a &quot;Christian Hindu&quot;: <a href="http://www.firstpost.com/politics/india-hindu-nation-im-christian-hindu-goa-dy-cm-francis-dsouza-1634437.html" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.firstpost.com&#x2F;politics&#x2F;india-hindu-nation-im-chri...</a><p>Hinduism in not an organized religion like Abrahamic religions. The definition of Hinduism is very fluid in practice.<p>Similarly one can be a Buddhist atheist as well.<p>PS: Also please add Sikhism and Jainism to the poll -- two other major Indian religions!
评论 #8088711 未加载
评论 #8089053 未加载
nemo1618将近 11 年前
&quot;I used to be an atheist until I realized I was god.&quot; - J. Krishnamurti<p><a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pantheism" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Pantheism</a>
评论 #8088671 未加载
robgibbons将近 11 年前
At first, I was an atheist, and I pitied religious folks for their incredible stupidity.<p>Then, I learned about agnosticism, and I realized it better describes what I believe, and that my <i>lack of belief</i> in God is possibly incorrect. I still pitied the religious for their blind faith.<p>Then I realized one day, while pondering the subject, that because it is not possible to experimentally test for the existence of God, nor to derive any conclusion based on logic, then the question itself is in fact &quot;extra-logical.&quot; It cannot be resolved with the scientific method, or any other means of rationalization. To even attempt to do so is itself irrational.<p>The question therefore must be, simply, &quot;Do you <i>believe</i> in God?&quot; This question does not attempt to bring logic, science or rationality into the picture. It is a question purely of faith, of which I acknowledge I have none.<p>So, in the end, I am still an agnostic, but one who now accepts that there can be quite rational, scientific thinkers who <i>have faith</i> in the existence of God.
评论 #8088818 未加载
morganvachon将近 11 年前
I chose &quot;other&quot; because even though I do believe in God and follow the teachings of Jesus, I don&#x27;t align myself with modern Christians who seem determined to be the opposite of what he taught. Hate, especially irrational, pointless hate, is something I simply don&#x27;t understand and don&#x27;t want in my life. I know a lot of it is politics instead of faith, but that&#x27;s no excuse; in fact that makes it even more despicable.
java-man将近 11 年前
The data is clearly not representative. Take a look at number one post in Show HN titled &quot; OneBody Church Directory software I&#x27;ve been hacking on for 7 years&quot;. This post has 740 points | 203 comments, clearly very popular (number two has 77 points | 46 comments).<p>Does it mean atheists are more open responding to polls about spirituality?
评论 #8088651 未加载
评论 #8088772 未加载
评论 #8088645 未加载
sillysaurus3将近 11 年前
<i>Sometimes we make assumptions about a particular group of people and this poll seems like a great way to challenge those assumptions and take a closer look at who makes up the hacker news community.</i><p>HN polls haven&#x27;t been trustworthy for years. Too many people giving too many false results. Pg noticed this when there was a poll asking about the age of HNers and a bunch of people responded with &quot;Over 80.&quot; He mentioned he&#x27;d make their fonts extra huge so they&#x27;d still be able to read HN.
评论 #8088549 未加载
评论 #8089426 未加载
评论 #8088913 未加载
beefsack将近 11 年前
The idea of religious engineers has always been one that fascinates me.
评论 #8088594 未加载
评论 #8088739 未加载
评论 #8088572 未加载
评论 #8088611 未加载
评论 #8088584 未加载
评论 #8088607 未加载
评论 #8088654 未加载
STRiDEX将近 11 年前
I feel like atheist and agnostic are too concrete.<p>I view it like non-Americans view thanksgiving. You can read the wiki page and it makes sense, but I&#x27;m not going to go out of my way to do it too. It&#x27;s not really something that applies to me.
georgemcbay将近 11 年前
I grew up in a family of catholics, went agnostic, went militant atheist, and then realized the universe is so fucking weird and likely beyond our ability to ever truly comprehend it that &quot;who am I to judge others for believing in ridiculous things?&quot;.<p>Which is to say, I think all religions we have that claim to have any kind of historical meddling from a &#x27;creator&#x27; are rather obviously fictional and borderline ridiculous, but I don&#x27;t have any better answers to &quot;the big questions&quot;, so I&#x27;m fine letting people believe whatever they like without opposition or debate so long as what they believe doesn&#x27;t result in the oppression of others.
shkkmo将近 11 年前
I believe that there is commonality between referents for the term &#x27;god&#x27;. I believe that there is wisdom to be found in most religious systems of belief. I call myself omnignostic.
eof将近 11 年前
Other - Using standard nomenclature in a non-standard way I&#x27;d call myself a &quot;Spiritual Atheist.&quot;<p>I had been an atheist of the &quot;cold&quot; variety: life spontaneously arose from non-life in an undefined fashion, and everything relevant to the conversation evolved from this first life.. only the &quot;observable&quot; could be real.<p>Seemingly non-local consciousness-connections (a dream where something bad happens to someone and they die that night, you think of someone in that moment they call you, esoteric initations into new-agey meditation [law of attraction, remove viewing], they way the universe seems to be inscrutably &quot;nicer&quot; to me the more buddha-like it is [e.g. when regularly meditating])<p>The reasons my metaphysics changed are nearly ineffable; and are certainly not objectively verifiable (at least by me). The ramifications are easy to grok:<p>- The universe is a holy playground - The universe has some sort of intention - The more your intentions fall in line with the intentions of the universe, the more satisfying life is.<p>There are also some non-obvious (but ultimately important) &quot;actionable&quot; ramifications: primarily that sometimes the best way to solve a corporeal problem is to get the spiritual aspect (ie, the interface between you and the universe) in line.
评论 #8088768 未加载
ChikkaChiChi将近 11 年前
I don&#x27;t identify myself spiritually nor do I use it as any sort of litmus test in any community I am a part of.
评论 #8088514 未加载
flatline将近 11 年前
Really, only one other Buddhist? I guess that makes sense with only 13 Christians as of this posting. I took the precepts, don&#x27;t know that I particularly consider myself religious but I still subscribe enough to check the little up arrow.<p>Edit: nevermind, poll took off;)<p>Edit 2: zenjzen, you also appear to be hellbanned.
评论 #8088546 未加载
SoftwareMaven将近 11 年前
So do Mormons get to check two boxes? Mormons are Christian.
评论 #8088579 未加载
评论 #8088539 未加载
评论 #8088532 未加载
评论 #8088524 未加载
评论 #8088555 未加载
评论 #8089488 未加载
chadkruse将近 11 年前
Other - I identify with [insert own name here]. Let me explain...<p>I dated a woman once who dated a woman just prior to dating me (I&#x27;m male). We were having beers with a mutual friend and upon hearing that fact, our mutual friend said &quot;wow, I didn&#x27;t know you were bisexual Jen&quot; (not her real name). Jen&#x27;s response...&quot;I&#x27;m not bisexual...I&#x27;m Jen. I don&#x27;t believe in labels.&quot;<p>I&#x27;m not Atheist, Agnostic, or Lutheran (the religion my parents chose for me). I&#x27;m Chad.<p>I haven&#x27;t used a label for anyone&#x27;s politics, religion, sexual preference, or other complicated matters since. Thank you Jen. The best part...you get to focus on getting to know someone on a personal level instead of arguing about definitions :)
评论 #8088676 未加载
luke-stanley将近 11 年前
I put Buddhist, but consider myself atheistic to many concepts, but agnostic to others (see: Simulation Argument), and pan-theistic in general - as in, the term reflects a unity of the Universe that any true Cosmos fan should come to see, for instance. (Proof of such is hard won by sceptical scientists.) Stats with this kind of options are could be seen as rather divisive and can give a false impression if interpreted without nuance.
gschlenkhoff将近 11 年前
Religion influences the decision to become an entrepreneuer. So are all the Agnostics and Atheists the employed hackers while the believers the bosses? <a href="http://www.voxeu.org/epubs/cepr-dps/religion-influences-peoples-decision-become-entrepreneur" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.voxeu.org&#x2F;epubs&#x2F;cepr-dps&#x2F;religion-influences-peop...</a>
recursion1133将近 11 年前
I consider myself a truthist for lack of a better word. One who seeks the truth, however, more specially, a monothiest.
imsofuture将近 11 年前
&quot;Theist&quot; should be a choice. I believe in god&#x2F;a god, perhaps (likely?) not a knowable one.
geophile将近 11 年前
ZERO Jews? I&#x27;m surprised. (Disclaimer: I&#x27;m an atheist, born Jewish, and currently Jew-ish.)
评论 #8088551 未加载
ethana将近 11 年前
I&#x27;ve turned agnostic recently from being a sole christian. The more time I spend with computing and learn about machine learning&#x2F;AI, I think that we can and will create self-aware AIs. At that point, we&#x27;ll have to question what reality programmed us?
评论 #8089072 未加载
netgineer将近 11 年前
The one scientologist is a troll, right?<p>.... right?
评论 #8088591 未加载
评论 #8088601 未加载
swayvil将近 11 年前
I was working this job (tech writer) at this tech place (little computers) a few months ago (temp). The population was evenly split between christians and potheads. I suppose it says something.
captn3m0将近 11 年前
Here are the poll results in graph format:<p><a href="http://hnlike.com/hncharts/chart/?id=8088478" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;hnlike.com&#x2F;hncharts&#x2F;chart&#x2F;?id=8088478</a>
param将近 11 年前
Sikh!
rocky1138将近 11 年前
The finger pointing at the moon is not the moon
brenfrow将近 11 年前
Now just waiting to do an analysis on what to do with this data?
评论 #8088649 未加载
pstuart将近 11 年前
Spiritual atheist. But when I get the time I&#x27;m going to start a new religion: Ovumist.<p>The holy tract: <a href="http://www.galactanet.com/oneoff/theegg_mod.html" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.galactanet.com&#x2F;oneoff&#x2F;theegg_mod.html</a>
cconroy将近 11 年前
Whichever one is most parsimonious is what you should be.
ketralnis将近 11 年前
I don&#x27;t see a voting option for &quot;I&#x27;d really rather not debate religion on HN at all, please go away&quot;
lifelongUU将近 11 年前
Unitarian
lanna将近 11 年前
Antitheist
aligajani将近 11 年前
and what exactly is the reason behind this poll?
classicsnoot将近 11 年前
How come no Pastafarianism option?
cowbell将近 11 年前
Other: Jedi Knight
spiritualid将近 11 年前
I believe dualism and I know how to do induce out of body exp but I don&#x27;t know is scientific or not. what its criterion?
rando289将近 11 年前
No recognition for the Church of Emacs?!
Ardeof将近 11 年前
I believe in knowledge, does that count? Seems to be quite the rarity around these parts called... &quot;Earth&quot;