TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

My son won a gold medal. Then was robbed. Apple involved. HELP

3 点作者 mangoleaf将近 11 年前
Hi HNers,<p>MY son won a gold medal for video game design and programming. His game was displayed at the Parsons School of Design in NYC starting in May 2014. Just over a month later, an exact duplicate was released in the Apple appstore (not by my son). It is now #10 in the rankings (called: No Brakes). It even used the exact shape for the vehicle.<p>Is there anything we can do? Any suggestions?

4 条评论

jgeorge将近 11 年前
Apple is &quot;involved&quot; in the same way that the city government is &quot;involved&quot; when someone steals your car and drives off down the street with it.<p>I sympathize with your son&#x27;s situation, but starting out with &quot;Apple involved.&quot; just makes me think your initial interest is seeing how much you could sue Apple for because some developer released a clone of your son&#x27;s game. App cloning happens all the time. It sucks, but it&#x27;s no more Apple&#x27;s responsibility than it is that the city didn&#x27;t stop the car thief from driving off with your car.<p>The developer is apparently UK based, so if there&#x27;s any way you think they could have seen your son&#x27;s game and cloned it in a month, you&#x27;re free to complain to Apple and see if they&#x27;ll pull the game, but beyond that I don&#x27;t think they have any responsibility to help you at all.<p>I&#x27;m sorry for your son&#x27;s rapid experience to learn that there are people out there who clone apps to make money off of someone&#x27;s work. He should go have lunch with Dong Nguyen and Gabrielle Cirulli, they&#x27;ll have something to chat about.<p>BTW, if you&#x27;re on the &quot;lawyer up&quot; warpath, don&#x27;t forget Google too for another fat purse to poke at. No Brakes is in the Play store as well.
评论 #8140922 未加载
评论 #8132146 未加载
mkal_tsr将近 11 年前
What was Apple&#x27;s response when you contacted them about this before posting on HN?
chrisBob将近 11 年前
Gold Medal! Robbed! Apple!<p>That&#x27;s quite a headline. Unfortunately simple games are easy to copy and a <i>style</i> is IP that is almost impossible to protect. I would tell your son that he should be flattered that someone liked his free game enough to reproduce it from scratch.<p>If he is trying to make a business out of this then this is a good chance to learn about how marketing is a good differentiator. If this is just for fun or for a portfolio then don&#x27;t worry about it, and start working on the next project.
评论 #8140938 未加载
Spoom将近 11 年前
Lawyer up.
评论 #8130180 未加载