TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Expensive Placebos Work Better

46 点作者 tshtf超过 10 年前

6 条评论

x1798DE超过 10 年前
I am very much not convinced of the interpretation of the placebo effect as &quot;the fact that just thinking that you&#x27;re getting some treatment of benefit can have actual benefits.&quot; The placebo (and corresponding nocebo) effect is completely intuitive when you think of it as a measurement artifact. It&#x27;s strongest in self-reported outcomes, it goes away or is massively reduced the better your blinding - all exactly what you&#x27;d expect from a combination of confirmation bias and expectations (both on the part of the person receiving the treatment and doing the study).<p>Even to the extent that there are placebo effects in clearly quantifiable outcomes (e.g. blood pressure, etc) it&#x27;s <i>still</i> way more plausible that these are due to nonspecific treatment effects (e.g. taking a pill every day for your blood pressure reminds you of your problem with blood pressure and so you take the stairs instead of the elevator or you don&#x27;t have a second serving of steak) than that there&#x27;s a way for your mind to just cause arbitrary positive or negative effects above and beyond your normal immune system - but only if it&#x27;s tricked into it.
评论 #8967625 未加载
评论 #8967508 未加载
not_that_noob超过 10 年前
Extending this a bit further, I think this applies to things like cars or cosmetics or fashion or wine. Pretty much any consumer good actually.<p>I remember a study (might be from the Ariely book) where they took wine from the same bottle, put it into two decanters, and said one was way more expensive than the other. People were asked their impressions of the two wines. The more expensive wine received rave reviews while the supposedly cheaper one was marked only passable.<p>Interesting on one level, sad on another. And exploitable for profit, as some smart marketers have been doing for a while.
评论 #8968171 未加载
BtLutz超过 10 年前
This idea was covered in Dan Ariely&#x27;s book &quot;Predictably Irrational&quot;. Glad to see more scientific data backing up the claim.
评论 #8967753 未加载
kristopolous超过 10 年前
Speaking of expensive placebos, how is selling oscillococcinum legal? I can&#x27;t imagine how many well-intended people mistakenly buy these sugar pills believing it is efficacious medicine.
评论 #8968392 未加载
dmamills超过 10 年前
The title could be straight out of The Onion.
praeivis超过 10 年前
Instagram generation could cure them self just by eating melted money.
评论 #8967934 未加载