TE
科技回声
首页24小时热榜最新最佳问答展示工作
GitHubTwitter
首页

科技回声

基于 Next.js 构建的科技新闻平台,提供全球科技新闻和讨论内容。

GitHubTwitter

首页

首页最新最佳问答展示工作

资源链接

HackerNews API原版 HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 科技回声. 版权所有。

Why We Remember So Many Things Wrong

137 点作者 clarkm超过 10 年前

6 条评论

kijin超过 10 年前
The weird way that our memory works, and how it differs from the way computer memory works, is also a fundamental reason why it&#x27;s so difficult to get privacy and data retention right in the digital age.<p>Ever had someone with &quot;photographic memory&quot; pay attention to your daily life? It can get creepy very quickly, because she notices and vividly remembers all sorts of things that you never imagined anyone would ever notice. But nowadays, with Facebook and Instagram and sophisticated tracking everywhere, all sorts of strangers have <i>literally</i> photographic memory of what you said and did last summer. I&#x27;ve seen lots of people obsessively delete stuff from their timelines after only a short while, not because they&#x27;re paranoid, but because feeling uneasy is only a normal response to any violation of our intuitions about how memory is supposed to work. (Unfortunately, our normal response doesn&#x27;t have normal consequences anymore; the data still exists somewhere.)<p>We&#x27;re meant to forget. We&#x27;re made to rewrite our memories as time goes on, just as any living thing constantly rebuilds itself over time. <i>Homo sapiens</i> never evolved to be reliable preservers of pixel-perfect information. No matter how much our technology and legal framework tries to promote 99.999999999% durability as the golden standard of memory (Amazon S3 actually promises eleven 9&#x27;s), we need to remember that this concept of memory is a very modern invention that most people still have trouble coping with. Maybe we never will. Maybe we never should. Maybe computers will learn to forget like us, rather than us learning to remember like them.
评论 #9002654 未加载
评论 #9002539 未加载
评论 #9003910 未加载
stephengillie超过 10 年前
In gaming, the concept is called a &quot;replay&quot;, where instead of recording the pixels on the screen in every frame, they instead record all inputs processed on every frame, and just replay them thru the same engine. The action is technically idempotent in the game world.<p>Where this breaks down is when features get updated between revisions. If your game patched the &quot;jump&quot; function to increase upward momentum from 1.1 m&#x2F;s to 1.13 m&#x2F;s, the Replay would be incorrect. You would be jumping onto platforms you couldn&#x27;t get up to before, moving faster, maybe even dodging enemy attacks that hit you when you played that match.<p>The human neuroprocessor is always changing and growing, always revising itself. Thus memories replay incorrectly. You apply old feelings to new mental patterns, and sometimes they lead to weird places. Or sometimes you mistake something easy for being difficult, because your memory data is out-of-date for your current processes.
评论 #9006531 未加载
peterwwillis超过 10 年前
The amygdala doesn&#x27;t have a direct connection to the visual cortex, as this article suggests. The amygdala receives stimuli from the thalamus, just as the neocortex does, and (iirc) the amygdala&#x27;s outputs can affect the neocortex, but that&#x27;s not how the neocortex gets its signals. The signals go to both the amygdala and neocortex independently, like a fiber optic splitter.<p>Because it takes so long to think, and probably because the amygdala is so small and simple compared to the neocortex, the visual senses we receive hit the amygdala <i>well before</i> they hit the visual cortex. We experience pain and pleasure memory response from senses before we even know what those senses are.<p>You may have two memories of a horse, one just a plain-old horse, and one a horse while you were getting shocked. Since the amygdala senses the horse first, the emotional memory is returned first, which is why any attempt to bring up &quot;horse&quot; will dig up one of the emotional memory horse records. You then have to wait for the neocortex to catch up and say, hold on a second, this is just a regular horse. When your neocortex is completely swamped by the amygdala it is called &quot;amygdala hijack&quot;.<p>The quoted paper is basically saying &quot;the hippocampus and amygdala can affect each other&quot;, which is basically true: usually one does not rule the other, and they work in concert to give you a full picture of things. And just like the amygdala can provide an emotional veneer over logical memories, the hippocampus can temper the emotional response, for example with mindfulness practice.
superobserver超过 10 年前
Hyperthymesiacs generally don&#x27;t have this problem&#x2F;solution (however you look at it). Personally, I&#x27;d rather not remember things wrongly. The only problem with hyperthymesia is you need to have the right personality for it not to be a burden to you (very high emotional stability, for instance), so it wouldn&#x27;t be great for everyone.<p>Since human beings are still evolving, I don&#x27;t think there&#x27;s any reason to believe we&#x27;re meant to do things one way rather than another.<p>Edit: I should note that hyperthymesiacs are not immune to false memories, despite their superior memory: <a href="http://www.pnas.org/content/110/52/20947.abstract" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.pnas.org&#x2F;content&#x2F;110&#x2F;52&#x2F;20947.abstract</a>
marincounty超过 10 年前
The only thing think I remember succinctly is the loss of my virginity! Everything else is a fuzzy haze.
digital-rubber超过 10 年前
Negative memories are simply stronger. You want to avoid that in the future.<p>Another interesting read on it: <a href="https://www2.bc.edu/elizabeth-kensinger/Kensinger_CD07.pdf" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www2.bc.edu&#x2F;elizabeth-kensinger&#x2F;Kensinger_CD07.pdf</a>